8 ms·
Why Don’t We Value Spatial Intelligence?
- ams6110 15y agoI definitely remember standardized test questions such as identifying what the shadow of an object should look like, what rotations of various shapes would look like, etc. But there were usually only a few of these. I don't specifically recall if any were on the SAT but definitely were on some of the tests I took in middle and high school.
- bediger 15y agoIn this article, "value" means "perform standardized testing for". In that sense, we don't value much at all, because even the things we test for ("verbal", "math") we reduce to some inane blather for the purposes of testing. From a larger viewpoint, what does this author think we do for football players? Do we not "value" them? In large part, what the players do is the "spatial intelligence" of the article. Do we not "value" airplane pilots? Same thing there.
- ndefinite 15y agoAgreed!
- ndefinite 15y agoI got minus'd a point for that? I still agree though. The first thing that comes to mind when I think of the "elite" spatially intelligent are professional athletes and race car drivers. Value is subjective and some fields value traits that vary from what is valued in other fields. To be a successful mathematician, you don't need to be particularly capable when it comes to spacial intelligence. The article highlights concerns but reality is different; the statistical analysis I conduct in a day requires very little spacial intelligence. The most productive athletes in my city do require a superior level of spacial intelligence and they are compensated incredibly well for their contributions (paid more in a year than I am likely to be paid in may entire career).
- jaggederest 15y agoRight, by his description the only things we value are 'skill at taking standardized tests'. I'd say if you look at peak salaries, some of the most valued professions are spatial.
- nosse 15y agoIf there would have been spatial tests in school, I might have thought of it as work. And if I had thought so I might not have played with my mechanic Lego's all afternoons. But it would bee good to test spatial ability when applying to university level mechanics..
- stonemetal 15y agoAnd they certainly don’t design these devices by writing an essay on the topic or even by solving a mathematical equation. Rather, they imagine it in their minds eye, and then they draw it or construct it. Remind me not to drive on that person's bridge. Sorry but if you can't hack the math to make sure your invention isn't going to explode and kill people then perhaps you should put down the power tools. Almost every modern invention is heavily math driven, because you have to know it will work not just be able to visualize and assemble it. Love that red herring about the nobel laureates, after all it has been shown that after a certain point drive is much more important than intelligence when determining outcomes.
- buff-a 15y agoI knew a fellow at college who was awesome at setting up experiments and having them work. He worked with some incredibly bright post-grads and post-docs who couldn't scramble an egg. Sometimes you get these two "intelligences" in the same person. Usually you don't. We're better when we recognize different talents and work together.
- kvnn 15y ago"Almost every modern invention is heavily math driven" - citation? Anyway, no one is advocating the building of bridges by school kids who can build things without math. The article advocates giving school kids who have great spacial skills, but not apparently great math or written skills, a chance to participate in technical greatness.
- leoedin 15y agoEngineering school is almost entirely math. It's applied to structures, to electrical circuits, to fluid flow, but the essence of it is all the same - using math to describe things. Yes, a lot of design doesn't require calculations to be done on the spot, but almost every design made by an engineer will be informed from the beginning by their knowledge of math. It's hard to think of a modern invention that's as big as the internal combustion engine or the aeroplane, but any recently designed item you buy today has had math applied to almost every facet of it. The design process for a product case uses extensive geometry, the design of gearboxes uses extensive mathematical modelling - pretty much every mechanism that's manufactured will be first described mathematically. Even things that don't have complicated mathematical models describing them will have had some form of math applied to inform the initial design process. You can't design a lever without taking into account it's length, the moment it applies etc - that's all maths! Technical greatness in our world requires math. You can't design and build a truly unique and functional device without applying some form of math to it. Certainly spacial awareness is absolutely fantastic. It lets a designer envisage a concept in their mind, think through how something will work and identify the pitfalls of a concept before anything is put to paper, but it's not a replacement for mathematical ability when it comes to actually designing a functional mechanism or mechanical system.
- newhouseb 15y agoJohn Hopkin's Center for Talented Youth summer camps (aka nerd camp) have been offering the Spatial Test Battery as a qualification method since I was in middle school (~10 years ago). See http://cty.jhu.edu/ts/stb.html http://cty.jhu.edu/ts/stb.html and for a sample subsection see http://cty.jhu.edu/ts/stbsampSD.html http://cty.jhu.edu/ts/stbsampSD.html. I never took it (you could also take the SATs as well) but as a heavily technical person my brain does backflips of excitement solving the sample problems.
- mattquinn 15y agoCTY was the first thing that came to my mind when I saw this article submission. I took the spatial test back in middle school and it was fairly difficult, but that's what's to love about CTY - they make everything challenging to get a true understanding of your strengths and weaknesses. K-12 and higher education could do worse than to mirror some of the aspects of CTY.
- aspensmonster 15y agoThanks for the link. I loved the sample problems!
- devs1010 15y agoI think spatial intelligence can help with programming, I'm not real up on all the different categories of intelligence, but I think I tend to be more of a spatial thinker which could be part of why I have more and more come to like designing complex applications with different, smaller components because when I visualize the entire application in my mind I see it in basically a 3D space as far as how the components interact
- ams6110 15y agoAbsolutely, visualization is commonly done, everything from ER diagrams to object models to flow charts to the little blocks and arrows drawings we made to understand pointers and data structures.
- Tycho 15y agoEven just tracing how all the different functions in a program fit together is kind of a spatial task... Or something that has more in common with spatial reasoning than with numeracy or verbal reasoning.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jacobolus 15y agoFor those who never saw it, Ken Robinson’s 2006 TED talk is as amazing as it ever was; go watch it right away: http://www.ted.com/talks/ken_robinson_says_schools_kill_creativity.html http://www.ted.com/talks/ken_robinson_says_schools_kill_crea...
- _Y_ 15y agoIndeed I also quite liked his RSAnimate talk on http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zDZFcDGpL4U http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zDZFcDGpL4U
- fleitz 15y agoWho is we? At best you can say that the school system and large bureaucracies don't value these skills. Certainly Apple and the British empire value Ive's contribution to design immensely. The Tony Starks of the world are not meant to be low level grunts, keep in mind that the school system is designed to produce interchangeable parts to work in large manufacturing and bureaucratic organizations such as fortune 100s, the government and the military. The levels of leaders who self select out is acceptable and therefore the system will not be changed. The school system is not for the betterment of the people who go through it; it is for the benefit of the owners. It's not a bug that our school system produces learned helplessness it's a feature.
- Arcanum-XIII 15y agoSpatial intelligence is not always related to design things. I'm way more at ease with spatial concept, and in direct way with structure, than with word and number. But I can translate all my mental image into words and numbers, albeit not perfectly — this give me the ability to program, learn new things pretty fast, manipulate mathematics... the hard part is going back to the world of symbol.
- brandall10 15y ago"Imagination is more important than knowledge." - Albert Einstein "When he moved from Germany to Switzerland at the age of sixteen, Einstein spent a year at a school that emphasized independent thought, free action and personal responsibility. He thrived in a learning environment without rote drills, memorization and force-fed facts. Based on the philosophy of a Swiss educator named Pestalozzi, the school helped students move through a series of steps from hands-on observations to intuition, conceptualization, imagination and visual imagery. “Visual understanding is the essential and only true means of teaching how to judge things correctly,” wrote Pestaslozzi, and “the learning of numbers and language must be definitely subordinated" ...It was at this school that Einstein, age sixteen, started picturing what it would be like to ride along a beam of light.” http://sparkmygenius.com/2007/07/myth-busted-einstein-on-education/ http://sparkmygenius.com/2007/07/myth-busted-einstein-on-edu...
- Jach 15y agoOne problem is not everyone has imagination--just like there are some photo-memory people there are those with no capability of 'picturing' anything in their mind. Another is that people's mental imagery is probably very different, how can you teach it directly? If the school is good at getting people to discover that mental imagery on their own it will probably work out, but it's hard to teach it to someone who doesn't share it. (I'd love to see some other psychology studies on this, I think I first ran across the view from a Feynman video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cj4y0EUlU-Y&feature=BFa&list=PLF15963DE7F6FA70F http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cj4y0EUlU-Y&feature=BFa&#... )
- jacobolus 15y ago> not everyone has imagination You need to spend more time with young children.
- Radix 15y agoSee nitrogen's post. The gp didn't mean imagination so much as internal picturing. I'm not sure about children but some people lack this ability the same way others are better with turn by turn directions than a look at a map.
- Shenglong 15y agoI hope this doesn't come out ignorant, but how often does someone possess a phenomenal level of spatial intelligence, yet very little verbal/mathematical intelligence? I'm not arguing that there isn't something wrong with current education, but I feel the point here may be misrepresented.
- kvnn 15y agoIts not about "very little verbal/mathematical intelligence", its about not-incredibly-high verbal/mathematical skill. If you feel the point is misrepresented, I suppose you should be more specific.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- tokenadult 15y agohow often does someone possess a phenomenal level of spatial intelligence, yet very little verbal/mathematical intelligence? I know an example among my close relatives. The person in question is probably in poor shape as to verbal and mathematical achievement/intelligence much more from having lousy instruction in elementary school than from having a bad family background (considering what other people in the same birth family with different teachers in school were able to do, and what neighbors who had the same teachers were NOT able to do), but the effect in adult life is the same--lacking reading and math skills holds many people back, even if they have very strong spatial abilities. More broadly, for any set of subsets of mental abilities, some people will be lucky and have above-average levels in all of them, and some other people will have wide "scatter" in their abilities. This is rediscovered every time a new brand of IQ test is normed.
- enjo 15y agoMaybe not "very little" but I would claim to fit this mold. I think it's made me an excellent programmer. I'm... competent (at best) at math. I'm below-average as a writer. However, mechanically I do very well. I can visualize and understand how things fit together very easily. I have a sort of inherent sense of order. That comes in really handy when working on complex systems. In computer science efficiency is often found in organizing systems, not necessarily in pure calculation (map-reduce would fall under that for instance, even if there is a strong mathematical basis). Spatial reasoning is actually one of the biggest things I look for in hiring.
- EREFUNDO 15y agoThe problem is that it is currently easier to measure math and language skills. It would also be difficult to teach because it is less mechanical. But I believe advances in CAD's and user interfaces would eventually help in creating a curriculum for developing spatial intelligence.
- JVirissimo 15y agoIs this a joke? Last time I checked, professional athletes make huge amounts of cash.
- glidey 15y agoYeah you're wrong, spatial intellect is not the primary thing that makes Athletes successful. Their greater muscle memory, and the fact that their bodies often do the right physical act without thinking (limbic system). Look up any interview with a great athlete talking about what it's like being in the "zone" while playing. Most athletes constantly reiterate that they don't contemplate every move, their bodies are that advanced.
- ww520 15y agoThey do test spatial intelligence. Dental entrance exams test your spatial intelligence, like folding 3-D boxes, hidden surface deduction, etc.
- Confusion 15y agoThe article doesn't explain what 'spatial intelligence' actually is. There's a link to a paper that goes on and on about 'spatial ability', but never defines it. As if 'IQ' wasn't useless enough, they had to come up with with 'EQ' and now everyone and their brother tacks 'intelligence' after a phrase they think should be desirable. Not to mention the fact that every test I've ever taken did include a section testing this 'spatial ability' (the paper contains examples, so I can infer what it means).
- mcdowall 15y agoI can relate to this, my maths is pretty decent, english language something I always struggled with but I always excelled at visual spacial 'tests', case in point being the 7 rounds tests I had to take for UK Air Traffic Control, they certainly value visual spacial skills!.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- im3w1l 15y agoWouldn't a better way to make a gifted kid learn the value of hard work be to put it in an environment where the work is challenging enough that it is required?
- lionhearted 15y agoThe obvious answer is that verbal intelligence is what's largely used in negotiation, recognition, and diffusing of ideas to non-visual people... see, ie, Jobs getting a lion's share of credit for his various teams' work. Mind you, I think Jobs deserves most of that credit. Great verbal ability captivates damn near everyone, and pulls the world forwards, whereas great visual/spatial requires someone equally skilled to truly appreciate. Anyways. I think things are going to get better, sharing credit and humanitarian ethics, along with transparency rising will help a lot. But to answer the question, "Why Don’t We Value Spatial Intelligence?" I think Occam's answer would be, "Because Spatially Intelligent People Don't Always Verbally Promote Themselves Well."
- wccrawford 15y agoThis article misses the entire point of school. It isn't to challenge kids. It's to teach them. If there were something to teach there, they'd have classes and tests on it. Grades aren't for bragging rights. I'm saying this as one of those kids that wished school taught me more. I was bored constantly. And I still wish that schools would teach kids at the level they need to be engaged and want to learn. But tests for spacial intelligence, just to have tested it? Why would we pay tax dollars for that? If the kid is gifted, they'll know it and automatically move into a field that uses it. (Or not, as they wish.) There's nothing to teach.
- Tycho 15y agoBut the point of test (exams) is simply to separate people and decide which candidates are best suited for further development. Tests should absolutely try to cover as many of the essential skills necessary for the various careers open to pupils, regardless of how easily those skills can actually be taught by schools. It would probably result in identifying pupils with potential that previously would have been ignored in favour of pupils who were only superficially superior. It would also encourage pupils who possess more ability in that area to put more effort into their academic careers in general. And would help pupils with other academic strengths to identify fields which will be more difficult for them (there was a former maths teacher on my IT postgraduate conversion course who was really surprised that she struggled with programming, since she thought her maths ability would have made it a shoe-in). And, to say spatial intelligence cannot be taught seems to be jumping the gun a bit. Have we really even tried to teach it?
- wccrawford 15y agoMost tests in our schools are not to help direct the students. They're to make sure they hit a minimum level. That's it. I agree that there are a few that are designed to help a student direct their ambition, but they are few and far between. In fact, I can't say I've ever taken one. The closest thing would be the college entrance exam that basically just tells the students what their worst subjects are, and forces them into the lowest classes for those. Not really a direction. But let's talk about teaching spatial intelligence. How would you do that? What techniques are employed while using it? Has anyone ever written a book on it? (A quick search says 'yes', but they appear to be ridiculous self-help books.) Honestly, I'd love to read more about it, but there doesn't see to be much. I happen to be really, really good at things like re-arranging furniture because I can always tell when something is going to fit or not. I've called it down to less than half an inch before when reshuffling an entire room. What techniques did I use? Intuition. I can't teach someone that. And I can't see them teaching me, either.
- calibraxis 15y agoAnyone interested in this should probably read Seymour Papert's _Mindstorms_: there are multiple routes to mathematical ability. (As well as, of course, other abilities). Mentions the story of a child he observed who he believed was turned mathophobic by school — ironically due to his high verbal ability. The school actively penalized a verbal route to math which likely would've served him best.
- Tichy 15y agoI doubt complicated machinery can be built without maths.
- jodrellblank 15y agoSays the multi-billion cell evolved mathless organism.
- sharmajai 15y agoStrange that the author doesn't mention Howard Gardner [1], who pioneered the theory of multiple intelligences [2] which lists spatial intelligence as one of the intelligence form. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Howard_Gardner http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Howard_Gardner [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_multiple_intelligences http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_multiple_intelligence...
- hiroprot 15y agoThis made me think of Ender's Game (finished re-reading it last night).
- cmfoster 15y agoFact, Doc brown invented the flux capacitor. What a great invention, I may have to go forward to the past and change the education system.