3 ms·
Above jihadjihad mentions how very American the book is. Their comment combined with yours might explain my bemusement once I’d finished it. ‘What was that an
by lostlogin 4y ago
Above jihadjihad mentions how very American the book is.
Their comment combined with yours might explain my bemusement once I’d finished it.
‘What was that and why is it so well regarded?’
- ghaff 4y agoFitzgerald was very American--and specifically very Northeast upper class. He was even a writer on the film [Dartmouth] Winter Carnival in 1939--not one of the great 1939 films--but, so the story goes, he ended up getting kicked off the picture because he kept getting drunk in Dartmouth fraternities. I suspect some familiarity with that milieu helps one appreciate Fitzgerald just as some familiarity with the South helps one fully appreciate Faulkner.
- 082349872349872 4y agoThe intersection of Fitzgerald and Faulkner is in the latter's comment on leaving his post office job, when he said he reckoned he'd be at the beck and call of rich folk all his life, but at least now he would no longer be at the beck and call of any SOB who had the few cents to buy a stamp...
- 082349872349872 4y agoNot only was it very American in 1925 (perhaps Mencken wondered why a fish would write such cardboard about water?) but it still is. Very few days go by when the HN Front Page does not remind me of Jay Gatz: Gatz' schedule: Rise from bed..................................6.00...........A.M. Dumbell exercise and wall-scaling..............6.15 - 6.30...." Study electricity, etc.........................7.15 - 8.15...." Work...........................................8.30 - 4.30....P.M. Baseball and sports............................4.30 - 5.00...." Practice elocution, poise and how to attain it.5.00 - 6.00...." Study needed inventions........................7.00 - 9.00...." general resolves: No wasting time at Shafters or [a name, indecipherable]. No more smoking or chewing. Bath every other day. Read one improving book or magazine per week. Save $5.00 [crossed out] $3.00 per week. Be better to parents. Edit: and compare the reference made by the book Tom Buchanan was reading with our spate of anti-woke tweets or "replacement theory" videos, and you will have a good idea of the amount of technical and moral progress the US has made between the 1920s and the 2020s. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rising_Tide_of_Color_Against_White_World-Supremacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rising_Tide_of_Color_Again...
- proxyon 4y agoSo we've only made sufficient "moral progress" (whose morals?) when no one on Twitter questions wokeness and when a nation state has such porous borders that the founding stock of it can only come to the conclusion that they're intentionally being replaced by their elite. Moral progress is when everyone submits to your morals.
- 082349872349872 4y agoMoral progress is when people who nominally espouse a judeochristian culture take the Book of Ruth seriously. I suspect our axioms are very different, and am trying to think of where in between to start from; will write more later tonight.
- 082349872349872 4y agoSome questions, from back to front: 1/ How are "they" being replaced by "their" elite? What even is the "elite"? 2/ What makes you think this "replacement" is intentional? 3/ How do porous borders imply a single conclusion? 4/ What constitutes a "porous" border? 5/ What is the "founding stock"? (Does it include the 3/5-counted people in 1789? How about people in 1776? Beforehand?) 6/ How does "woke" differ from "not characterising one's country as a Mary Sue" (universally beloved, possessed of all positive virtues and suffering no negative vices)? 7/ What is the difference between your morals and those of Lothrop Stoddard? from front to back, my positions (we can either seek a middle ground on any of these, or simply agree to disagree): 7/ my morals are secular: "climbers: do not pull the ladder up after you" 6/ "woke" is a recognition that much of US history has been driven by slavery and bigotry — neither of which fit the ideals of the country: "with liberty and justice for all" 5/ Although I don't count, say, Lakota among my people, I do have people who were in the New World before 1789, as well as those who arrived after 1883's "Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free..." All were pioneers in their way (I have kept up the family tradition by emigrating from The Old Country); were any more or less "American"? 4/ Can the US border truly be said to be porous if the foreign population is only 14% (compared to my adoptive country's 25%?) 3/ Freedom of movement (one of the 4 freedoms of the EU) can easily be explained on liberty grounds, on economic grounds, as a necessary counterpoint to freedom of capital, etc. There are many possibilities beyond replacement. 2/ if we ascribe stupidity before malice, why should we think replacement (stipulating in this case that it occurs) is due to the latter and not the former? 1/ assuming non-Hispanic white people decline to under 50% of the population, so what? why would that be bad? Are minorities so poorly treated in the US that becoming a minority should be cause for concern?