4 ms·
> And you did pretty good: 75% good hires!... But if you had the God’s-eye view of all your applicants, you might find out that 75% of all of applicants were go
by crazygringo 4y ago
> And you did pretty good: 75% good hires!... But if you had the God’s-eye view of all your applicants, you might find out that 75% of all of applicants were good hires!
The author has clearly never been involved in hiring/selecting before, because the idea that application processes are as good as random is positively absurd.
People will apply to all sorts of things they're not even remotely qualified for. Hell, I've certainly done it in the past. A resume screen is essential to eliminate the obvious unqualified, and a first round of interviews weeds out people who also clearly don't have what's needed for the role or who throw up a gigantic red flag. (And then after that it's about trying to find the best match, not just a barely sufficient one, since suitability for a role isn't binary but exists on a continuum.)
Applying and then interviewing/screening is something we do because it's necessary. Obviously people are always looking for ways to improve the process, e.g. what types of signals actually correlate most with job performance?
But the idea that the application is no better than random flies in the face of all evidence, as well as all common sense.
This makes as much sense as saying that going on dates is useless -- just pick a partner at random and get married and be done with it, because the odds are just as good! (When of course the research shows that personality compatibility and chemistry compatibility are huge determinants of successful marriages.)
- feoren 4y ago> This makes as much sense as saying that going on dates is useless -- just pick a partner at random and get married and be done with it, because the odds are just as good! How sure are you this is false? I'm not completely convinced. Some people are very, very bad at picking compatible partners. Now I'm trying to figure out how we could ethically run this study, because I think the results might surprise you.
- escapedmoose 4y agoYou might be able to compare divorce/separation/unhappiness rates between arranged and non-arranged marriages, but culture differences would be a confounding factor… maybe study the average lifespan of relationships started on reality tv haha
- pcthrowaway 4y agoArranged marriages do have a lower divorce rate, so this isn't actually that farfetched (though I still think it's wrong, based on gut feeling)
- crazygringo 4y agoArranged marriages aren't picked randomly. Also divorce rates can only be meaningfully be compared within the same culture. The pressures to stay married or get divorced vary widely between cultures, separately from whether marriages are arranged or not.