3 ms·
> The trouble is finding manufacturers that actually do that, rather than just using a tiny motor with no computer and plastic gears with no torque sensing. If
by mschuster91 4y ago
> The trouble is finding manufacturers that actually do that, rather than just using a tiny motor with no computer and plastic gears with no torque sensing. If you design things with old fashioned methods, you need to use old fashioned heavy parts.
Oh yeah. Like Surefeed smart cat feeders. They don't use end reed or contact switches to control the lid motor - they use current sensing on the motor and stop it when the current surges due to reaching the end position. The problem is, they also use cheap-ass plastic gears on an apparently pretty strong motor... my old Surefeed from five years ago is still going strong, but the newer revision (which is, admittedly, easier to clean) failed after not even a year because the motor had shred the gears and could no longer detect if the lid was fully closed or opened, making noise for so long that the cat refused to use it.
Fucking hell, these things cost 150€+ apiece. Two contact switches and wiring would have cost them less than ten cents. Now they have to pay for the cost of handling the warranty claim... but I'd rather like to have a well-designed product in the first place.
(Oh, and it doesn't like rechargeable C cell batteries either, because they apparently saved the dollar that would have given them a boost voltage regulator, so you're stuck buying disposable alkaline batteries)
- eternityforest 4y agoOne of my general rules is not to buy anything that uses disposable batteries, unless battery life is measured in years. Not only does NiMh always seem to be a hassle, it usually seems like rechargable-based devices are more up to date in general. They probably wouldn't even need a reed switch, just a wad of foam for some buffering plus a more sensitive stop algorithm. Or better yet, don't give the motor enough current to shred gears even at full stall.
- mschuster91 4y agoMeh, I have grown to dislike devices with integrated batteries. For whatever the fuck reason, I seem to burn through batteries... like eight or so phone batteries, original Samsung at that, an Apple MBP2015, various gadgets, all gone to swelling, and often enough an utter PITA to replace. No, no bad chargers either - Anker and original chargers that came with the devices only.
- jemmyw 4y agoThe old model was impossible to clean. Did the designers never meet a cat? I've got two sure microchip cat doors. They've been reliable. Same problem, hard to clean. When one of our cats figured out how to break through the door sure sent me a 3d printed plastic part that clipped on over the latch. I think their customer care is pretty good.
- mschuster91 4y ago> The old model was impossible to clean. Did the designers never meet a cat? The new one isn't much better tbh... > When one of our cats figured out how to break through the door sure sent me a 3d printed plastic part that clipped on over the latch. I mean, my cats are smart enough to open doors, cupboards and drawers, but how on earth can a cat break through a cat flap?! Brute strength?
- jemmyw 4y agoHe's a big cat. There was a little gap at the bottom where the latch came up into the door. He would get his claws under the gap and then he could wrench it open. The clip on part covers the gap. I guess they have enough people with that problem to have designed a fix but not enough to update the product.