2 ms·
Other industries manage this problem by having a professional qualification that you do the exam for once, and then you're good for years. Possibly with refresh
by pjc50 4y ago
Other industries manage this problem by having a professional qualification that you do the exam for once, and then you're good for years. Possibly with refresher courses to keep up with rule changes.
> filter out applicants who are completely unqualified, from the vast amounts of people applying.
It's not really surprising that industries which pay incredible amounts of money get a lot of applicants.
The "gate" has to be somewhere. At the employer, or at a professional body, or at the education system? All have advantages and disadvantages.
- BeFlatXIII 4y agoThe problem with programming is that it’s easy enough to self-teach to reasonable competency without going through the formal channels. Contrast becoming a physician or engineer.
- kodah 4y agoThat's not only the history of our industry given that CS and CE arrived much later than programming jobs but it's also a feature. CS and CE cover some theory, but that theory is widely inapplicable to most jobs in the industry. People that don't come from formal backgrounds often work in cross-functional roles or roles that CS and CE deeply don't touch on. An example of the former is SREs. You can become a SWE by getting a CS degree, but a SRE job involves policy, userland software, systems, and so on skills. An example of the latter is Systems Engineering. I've found very few formal schools for Systems Engineering in the way it's practiced in industry. To make matters more complex most systems engineers also need to be familiar with writing application code.
- pessimizer 4y agoI don't think that's a problem, as long as exams are open. The problems would be a) blindspots among the self-taught, or b) largely useless, complex material added to the exam by the people who sell formal education in order to force people into formal education. edit: and only the second is a real problem, the first is a feature.
- jerf 4y agoIf people did generally put the gate only at the employer, where they randomly hire and then fire their way back down to competence, people would complain about that too. And with some reason. A further lemma: No matter where the gate is put, a lot of people will complain.