8 ms·
As a practical matter, it is very difficult to tax wealth (and even harder to do it fairly.) I don't think the issue is lack of will but lack of plan that actua
by bawolff 4y ago
As a practical matter, it is very difficult to tax wealth (and even harder to do it fairly.) I don't think the issue is lack of will but lack of plan that actually works in the face of assets with unclear value and/or difficult to liquidate.
And this doesn't just affect the ultra rich but people like SWE too. How much is the stock you have in the non-public company you work at really worth? SWE are probably one of the groups most likely to be "paper millionaires" and hence screwed by such a system.
- dontreact 4y agoIt’s hard problem that can only be solved through attempts and iteration. The fact that a wealth tax is difficult is not a good enough reason to not try, because the problem of wealth inequality is so severe now.
- dumpsterlid 4y agoBingo
- aqme28 4y agoThere are also some things that do work decently well that we don't do anymore for political reasons, such as estate taxes.
- r00fus 4y agopolitical reasons being: wealthy have gamed the politics and made those options "political".
- bawolff 4y agoYeah, but that isn't a wealth tax, its a tax on the heir's income. There is lots of ways to improve taxes on income and capital gains, but that is really different from a general wealth tax.
- mindslight 4y agoThe problem with this hollowing out of the regulations government used to have, is that people react by jumping for extreme, impractical things like "wealth tax". Nobody is going to go for the idea that the government comes around and explicitly collects a significant percentage of everything you own every year. (And they already do much of what they can get away with through inflation and real estate taxes). Rather, to continue the spirit of the top level comment, what is also now missing is the estate tax, which is/was around 40% (it's graduated too, but it tops out quickly). IIUC, the federal threshold used to be around $1M a few decades ago, and is now $10M - this was the anti "death tax" political issue you might vaguely recall. Furthermore, due to wider use of trusts, it's been basically eliminated unless your family is extremely unlucky. Fundamentally, I'd rather just tamp down the amount of money given away to the rich - stop the government giving trillions of dollars to the financial industry to prop up the fictitious asset bubble pyramid scheme, and either let natural technological deflation happen or at least spend the money deliberately ala MMT. But either way, something is required - the system we have right now has the government continually giving away gobs of money to asset holders, while doing very little to collect it back. This is exactly why these personal wealth bubbles continue to grow.
- throwawaylinux 4y ago> Nobody is going to go for the idea that the government comes around and explicitly collects a significant percentage of everything you own every year. I think you'd be surprised. When the majority of people own nothing, it won't take much for the ruling class to convince them that taking everybody else's wealth for the greater good is the right and moral thing to do.
- ant6n 4y agoMaybe start by not allowing this "stepping up" of the book value of asssets without paying taxes when assets are inherited:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stepped-up_basis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stepped-up_basis That means rich people can accumulate generational wealth without ever even paying capital gains taxes. And during one's lifetime, one can get liquidity out of assets by borrowing against them without selling them. The rule also seems strange from an outside perspective. Either the book value of assets should be kept the same when inheriting (I believe Germany does this), or the book value should be changed to current market value but the difference be taxed as gains (I believe Canada does this).
- bmitc 4y agoThe rich buy stuff, do they not? Tax those things to force realization and thus tax of unrealized wealth. Buying a second, third, fourth home? Here's your increasingly high tax and interest rate penalty. Instead of throwing up our hands with "they don't have cash", force them to realize investments into cash and deincentivize being able to keep everything hidden being investments and purchasing things with unrealized wealth.
- lelag 4y ago> Buying a second, third, fourth home? It's too easy for the ultra-rich to find loopholes in any rules. If there is a tax on homeownership, they will simply not own any home but will own some corporate entity that own the asset. See ? No secondary residence. Just an investment in a corporation that happens to home a bunch of houses.
- Yizahi 4y agoMake prohibitively expensive for corporations to own residential properties (cut off by square meters or land use type).
- nomdep 4y agoThey would create a separated business for each property
- kelseyfrog 4y agoI see this loophole brought up a lot. Is there really no way to prevent it?
- notahacker 4y agoTaxing businesses which own residential property at the same rate as second homes stops that particular wheeze entirely. If you wish to exempt certain types of business you believe have valid reasons to own residential property at low/no property tax rates then that becomes an exemption they have to demonstrate eligibility for, not the default. Second homes being misclassified as non-residential property might be trickier to deal with, but a lot of jurisdictions already have laws around what is and isn't residential...
- SilverBirch 4y agoIs this really... true? I get that there's this idea in people's heads that you couldn't tax for example some incredible rare art collection, because who is to say it's true value and you damage the owner by applying such a tax burden they actually have to sell the art. But let's take a step back. Where is the real money? Bezos, Gates, Buffett, Page, Brin, Ellison, Ballmer, Bloomberg, Zuckerberg. Further down the list the same thing is true - the people with wealth actually have the vast majority of their wealths in companies. It's not difficul to liquidate, it's not difficult to value them, it's actually quite comically easy. Even the guys who actually do have enormous art collections are almost all art dealers, they can and do liquidate their investments all the time. On to the core question: how much is the stock in the non-public company you work at really worth? I don't know, sell it and we'll find out. A SWE with illiquid stock probably actually has a much shorter timeframe of when they want a liquidity event than the US government has. The truth is that the reason it's difficult to tax rich people is because the first thing anyone does in this conversation is talk about how hard it would be, without thinking for a second if it actually would be hard. Let's lay aside any talk of real wealth taxes, and just stick to our current tax system, Elon Musk borrowing against his Tesla stock is not a taxable event. Let's change that today. It's specific, easy, would immediately drive revenue, and doesn't require any innovation around true wealth taxes. But... we won't, because it's not difficult, the government just doesn't want to do it. What does that mean? The burden of tax is primarily put on income not wealth, meaning your SWE with non-public stock is already getting absolutely pounded with taxes on their income instead.
- WalterBright 4y agoBorrowed money is not income.
- nmfisher 4y agoNo, but it is an avoidance mechanism specifically designed to avoid tax on income. If an independent third party has deemed your stock sufficiently valuable (and stable) to lend money against, then you should be taxed on that loan. You can get a credit when you repay the loan (to offset tax on the income you used to repay).
- vladvasiliu 4y agoBut as far as I understand, the stocks, and other difficult to liquidate assets, as log as you hold them in that form, are worth "nothing". You can't go buy bread with that, not even a house. At some point, you need to sell and get your local currency in exchange. That can be considered income, and taxed at that value. It doesn't matter whether you had 1M which melted to 1000 or if you bought it for peanuts and got lucky.
- creakingstairs 4y ago> At some point, you need to sell and get your local currency in exchange. But ultra rich people actually don’t. They can just incur debts using their wealth and use that instead.
- vladvasiliu 4y agoBut how are those debts paid back?
- sam_lowry_ 4y agoSo what? If banks will be taxed when selling collateral, debt costs will adjust accordingly and pass on to wealthy still.
- creakingstairs 4y agoSo we get to pay 40%+ tax on our income on a yearly basis while they get to pay a mystery amount that may or may not be factored into debt costs that can also be deferred for a while? Yeah that sounds fair.
- sam_lowry_ 4y agoWhy misery amount? The government can choose whatever tax it deems appropriate. Also, where I live options on shares are taxed at 10%. The government does not have to wait until they are exercised to take a cut.
- EricDeb 4y agoWhat about a tax such that you can only use assets as collateral for a loan if you've paid any outstanding capital gains on them? Would affect normal people through HELOCs but otherwise would mostly affect the very wealthy.
- Yizahi 4y agoIt is reasonably easy. Step 1. The country creates a law forbidding any financial interactions with "offshore" countries (list is populated manually by lawmakers) and also with companies working with such offshore companies (shell intermediaries) in "good" countries. Step 2. Country forbids its citizens from owning any assets or be incorporated in the same "offshore" countries. Step 3. Blanket ban of cryptotokens. Step 4. Huge inheritance taxes. Step 5. Incremental tax hikes for second and more houses/apartments owned. Restrictions for corporations owning a lot of residential properties and huge taxation. Step 6. Ban or restrictions of airbnb-like activities to discourage parking money in the housing market. Basically look where rich hide money go for that. When they switch tactics you follow. Step 0. Big independent financial auditor structure, independent from law and judicial branched both (or almost independent). From experience - you can dismantle a lot billionaires even with existing laws, if only someone looked close enough and punished them. This is a huge problem in eastern europe for example.
- robertlagrant 4y agoWhat will be the downsides of these moves?
- Yizahi 4y agoIf any single country will try this alone - devastating. For the country :) . If USA alone will try it - maybe it will work, idk. If USA plus EU plus major Asian economies will do it collectively - it will work.
- robertlagrant 4y agoSorry, I wasn't clear. Assuming you get what you want, what will be the downsides?
- Yizahi 4y agoFor independent financial auditor - none that I can think of. For offshore restrictions - you as a country lose all existing assets already there. A lot of people will move their business to a better countries, providing less restrictions and eventually taxes for them. Probably election loss and further dismantling of all these laws by disgrunted businessmen using their pocket political forces. If will hugely depend on the collective size of economies doing the ban. For housing - its tourists plus rent seekers vs. regular citizens. You hurt one group and you benefit another and vice versa. There is no win win scenario here, balance must be found. I personally vote for regular citizens, even if tourism industry will be hurt a little bit. For inheritance taxes - no downsides. For token ban - no downsides.
- FiberBundle 4y agoI agree. Taxing unrealized capital gains is just not a good idea at all. What's more problematic than people having huge sums of unrealized book value, is that in the current system they're allowed to live a lavish lifestyle by taking out loans against those assets (which effectively is an income for them) without paying any taxes at all. That is what should be taxed in some form.
- jmyeet 4y agoWe tax property without realizing a gain. We even tax bonds on deferred interest (eg zero coupon bonds). We can and should do this for stocks. The ultra-rich already borrow money to avoid realizing gains (and thus paying taxes). If they want to keep their stocks let them borrow to pay their tax bills.
- yourapostasy 4y ago> We tax property without realizing a gain. Not only do we do that which dis-proportionally hurts the less wealthy more, but property taxes are assessed upon assessed valuations of which the homeowner who does not sell or gets loans upon that valuation obtains zero benefit from. So the insurance company (which also uses the valuation) and the property tax jurisdiction(s) obtain yield from the valuations that year, and do not endure a clawback when the valuations ever decline.
- astrange 4y agoProperty taxes are pretty bad! Everyone hates paying them, retirees can’t afford them, and they tax building improvement which motivates owners to tear down their buildings. LVT is a much better related tax. Anyway, wealth taxes are probably bad because taxes are supposed to be deflationary, but wealth taxes are inflationary if you collect them in USD, since taxpayers have to sell assets first. Unless the IRS is willing to take a % interest in a collectible painting as the tax.
- Tiktaalik 4y agoI guess LVT is better, though I find it almost a pendantic thing at this point given that in so many places where property is expensive the property tax is effectively a land value tax already as the land dominates the assessed value so strongly.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y ago> As a practical matter, it is very difficult to tax wealth (and even harder to do it fairly.) Switzerland does it and it seems to work pretty well.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoCan you give some details for the non initiated?
- Leherenn 4y agoYou declare all the assets you own* in your tax declaration (bank accounts, properties, art, cars, equity, ...), even if abroad. You also declare your debts. I don't know how they enforce/check that, especially for foreign-based assets though. * except for household and personal common usage goods
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoOK, cool, but you didn't explain how does that fix wealth inequality in Switzerland or make wealth taxation fair? You just described a tax declaration system, not a taxation system. Anyone can declare assets anywhere but if they're not taxed, or taxed very little, then inequality grows. So does Switzerland do this better or fairer than other countries?
- eertami 4y agoBecause you pay a percentage of your total wealth in annual taxes every year (in addition to your usual income taxes). It differs between cantons (states, kinda) and has progressive banding. Someone with 100k in wealth will pay maybe 100-200 or so. If you have 100 million CHF, in Geneva you would pay around 1 million per year in taxes on that wealth. As the OP stated, it is global assets and wealth, so foreign/offshored investments still attract the tax. Plenty of people choose to be resident in Switzerland even with these taxes.
- Leherenn 4y ago
- Garlef 4y agoOne could very well argue that valley SWEs would be rightfully taxed by these measures. Yes they're not the super rich. But still among the top X %.
- firecall 4y agoIt's only very difficult within the constraints of western capitalist democracies. China has seen how Capitalists have overrun government and have moved to quickly re-educate anyone that steps out of line. I'm not advocating this, I'm just saying... Corporations and the wealthy play games and have more resources than our tax departments, and so have found strategies to win that are not available to people who earn an income and work for a living.
- xracy 4y agoI mean... you could start by taxing realized capital gains at >20% It's hard for me to give an argument like "this is difficult" credence when we already have a capital gains tax that's lower than most income taxes. I will buy this is difficult when you raise that number to 50% and we still have the same issues.
- bawolff 4y agoTaxing realized capital gains would be what i consider taxing income not wealth. I agree that taxing realized capital gains is relatively easy.
- roenxi 4y agoWhat if, while grappling with these complex issues, we institute a land tax as the obvious easy part? That is easy, hard to dodge and all but breaks inter-generational wealth transfers as a matter of practice. It is hard to get wealth from grandparent to grandchild in anything other than land; everything decays and you just need one idiot in the chain to lose everything with no chance to recover. The way the market intended.
- hestefisk 4y agoWhy is it hard? Tax capital gains, tax inheritance, tax corporate super profits, tax consumption (vat), tax FX / currency / speculative securities trading (Tobin tax), etc. It’s not hard, our politicians just lack the will and would rather drive a race to the bottom (“tax reforms”).
- klgkjghkjh 4y agoThe rich won't leave? See Europe
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hestefisk 4y agoI’m pro taxation of wealth.
- prottog 4y agoI see you have a bottomless appetite for taxing more and lots of imagination on how to do so. Do you have any answers on how that taxed money will be spent? How we can ensure that it's not just lining the pockets of the politicians and bureaucrats in charge of disbursing the money? How we measure the successes and failures of any taxpayer-funded program, so that we can be reasonably confident that the money is being put to good use? How all of this would play out over generations, knowing that the less money (and therefore power) the people have and the more money (and therefore power) the politicians have, the more likely it is that we will slip into authoritarianism?
- hestefisk 4y agoAnd I forgot: outlaw BEPS (base erosion profit shifting), so all corporations pay tax where they originate revenue. There’s way too much tax leakage via double Dutch sandwiches.
- nobodyandproud 4y ago> I don't think the issue is lack of will but lack of plan that actually works in the face of assets with unclear value and/or difficult to liquidate. At least in the world of stocks, dark pools help solve exactly this sort of problem. Once you have enough assets there are many tricks available that are simply inaccessible and unusable by regular salaried employees. Many of the tricks employed by the wealthiest forcefully remove transparency by a combination of legal and practical methods (e.g., Canada and Delaware share a lot in common). Disallow opaqueness first, then the solutions will emerge.
- fakedang 4y agoApparently Islamic principles have found a balance for this, so why can't we apply it directly? Short term stock holdings - pay on the net gain of the sale. Long term stock holdings - pay on the net value at that point in time. Non public companies are charged based on the last valuation round. Companies without funding aren't charged because the intrinsic value is zero. Dividends - pay on the dividend amount received All payments above are in cash, at 2.5% for all.
- iflint 4y agoThere is a fairly simple way to tax wealth: inflation. There are downsides to inflation of course, lower economic growth is a big one. But we are entering a higher inflation, higher interest rate environment whether we like it or not, and that will result in lower wealth inequality. Money will have less direct purchasing power, and assets like housing or company equity will decline in value due to higher borrowing costs. There are many people who will retort that 'inflation hurts the poor'. Yes, it hurts everyone, but it disproportionately hurts the rich. It is no coincidence that wealth inequality increased dramatically during the low inflation, low interest rate period we have experienced over the last two decades.
- empiricus 4y agoIf you own land, shares, companies, then inflation will not affect you.
- Tiktaalik 4y agoI don't think it's very difficult at all. We already have an elaborate system to measure and tax wealth with our system of property taxes on real estate. That's already in place. It would be trivially easy as well to track and tax the wealth of people hold public equities. Those two things there are an enormous bulk (majority?) of wealth. It only gets a bit more complicated with privately held equities this I will grant. If you start to get into the nitty gritty of assessing assets like ming vases and such it gets complex as well and likely diminishing returns, but at this point, with this stuff, you might as well not even bother because few are going to hold their wealth in ming vases.