4 ms·
This article concerns the metrics we use to decide how to advance kids into advanced educational opportunities. How is that a “trite matter of near zero import?
by rayiner 4y ago
This article concerns the metrics we use to decide how to advance kids into advanced educational opportunities. How is that a “trite matter of near zero import?”
I think your view of the conservative reaction may be colored by the fact that you don’t have the other side of this culture war wherever you are in Europe or Asia. To my knowledge, elite high schools in Germany or China aren’t abandoning objective metrics like grades and test scores on the theory that those things are “racist.” Heck, Germany and France don’t even track outcomes by race the way Americans do obsessively.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- defrost 4y ago> This article concerns the metrics we use to decide how to advance kids into advanced educational opportunities. Not to my reading. I would summarise this as an article about the shortcomings of the National Merit Scholarship Corporation [1], their failure to put sufficient postage on notifications and their offloading of their notifications onto schools. [1] https://www.nationalmerit.org/s/1758/interior.aspx?sid=1758&gid=2&pgid=399 https://www.nationalmerit.org/s/1758/interior.aspx?sid=1758&...
- rayiner 4y agoThat summary ignores all the relevant context. Since the 1980s, TJ has been a highly selective public high school. The average test scores there are comparable to several Ivy League colleges. As is common all over the world, TJ’s admissions process was based on standardized testing and grades. This was completely uncontroversial for decades. The National Merit Scholarship is based on a standardized test called the PSAT. It’s not the most important thing in the world, but important enough that every year the Washington Post would publish the list of students from the DC area who were selected. This was great marketing for the school, because TJ students were like 2/3s of all the students recognized out of dozens of high schools in the area. There was no pizza party, but the school would go to some effort to publicize the result because they felt it reflected very positively on the school. Two years ago, there was a huge fight over TJ’s admissions process. The school had become 70% Asian, and had very few black students. In that fight, progressives attacked standardized testing as racist. The progressive school board then changed the admissions process to a lottery system. A federal judge found that the change was motivated by anti-Asian racism: https://www.baconsrebellion.com/wp/we-won-coalition-for-tj-won-against-racism/ https://www.baconsrebellion.com/wp/we-won-coalition-for-tj-w.... Then an appellate court overturned that decision, and now the Supreme Court is deciding whether to hear the case. In that context, what the article is about is the TJ administration downplaying the National Merit Scholarship results, which until recently they had publicized and pointed to as a source of pride. The story is thus about a deliberate decision by the administration to downplay a certain kind of educational metric, based on progressive ideas, that until very recently the school had embraced as an important metric. Frankly it’s bizarre for someone from outside the US to say conservatives are waging a frivolous “culture war” here. What the conservatives want to do is keep the system that TJ had until two years ago, which is still the system most of Europe and Asia has.
- defrost 4y ago> That summary ignores all the relevant context. All that you added was not in the article and therefore not in the summary of the thrust of the article. > The story is thus about a deliberate decision by the administration to downplay a certain kind of educational metric It's about results arriving late and then filtering through what is pretty much a universal hand to hand to students that all school suffer through. WE have similar systems here, important reults and awards are directly notified to students, not filtered through a school admin. The fault lies with the National Merit Scholarship Corporation .. who seem to expect others to do their work for them. > Frankly it’s bizarre for someone from outside the US to say conservatives are waging a frivolous “culture war” .. Do you not read your own countries media? Have you not seen the baseless hysteria over trans people, "woke history", etc?
- rayiner 4y ago> All that you added was not in the article and therefore not in the summary of the thrust of the article. If I picked up an article in a newspaper in your country about some long running politically contentious issue, would it include years of backstory so I could understand the significance of it with zero background knowledge of the situation? > It's about results arriving late and then filtering through what is pretty much a universal hand to hand to students that all school suffer through. TJ isn’t some neighborhood high school. It sends dozens of kids into Ivy League schools and Cal Tech/MIT every year. The administration is like a well oiled machine in making that happen. In fact, taking the National Merit Scholarship test is completely optional, but TJ makes it mandatory for its students. That’s because the school was very proud of the fact that the Washington Post would publish the list, and local schools would have a few each and TJ would have 150+: https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/local/2002/11/14/students-are-scholarship-semifinalists/41b3a112-e1d9-4b70-9b7b-d1eb888d11e2 https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/local/2002/11/14/stud.... The National Merit Scholarship results have been distributed to schools the same way for decades. TJ always publicized the results to students promptly (and not by sending an email to some account nobody ever checks). I remember when the results came out my year, it was announced publicly and everyone went to check the list. The fact that TJ downplayed it the last couple of years reflects an ideological change, not some administrative mixup. > Do you not read your own countries media? Have you not seen the baseless hysteria over trans people, "woke history", etc? We’re talking about education. Simple question: In your country, do you have people trying to get rid of standardized testing on the theory that it’s “racist?”
- UncleMeat 4y agoTJ isn’t abandoning objective measures either. The system proposed by the proponents of change (and decried as racist by people like Asra) was a merit lottery where GPA and advanced math enrollment were the only application metrics. The adopted system, although removing the standardized test, still incorporates grades as an absolutely essential metric.
- rayiner 4y agoNot true. The new system is based on a quota for each middle school feeding into TJ. GPAs and academic standards in each school are completely different. It uses a “holistic review” that includes a “student portrait” and heavily weighs “experience factors.” https://northernvirginiamag.com/family/education/2022/03/30/tj-admissions-timeline https://northernvirginiamag.com/family/education/2022/03/30/.... A federal judge in the eastern district of Virginia ruled that getting rid of the admissions test and the new holistic review was expressly motivated by a desire to change the racial balance of the school. The fourth circuit stayed the district court order pending appeal in a 2-1 decision. The Supreme Court upheld the stay, over the dissent of three justices.
- UncleMeat 4y agoThe adopted system is indeed holistic. The proposed merit lottery was not and purely considered gpa and math enrollment. But that was also deemed racist. So it is clear that the “holistic” elements aren’t what piss Asra off. And the adopted system does still deeply consider grades, which you claim are being discounted.
- UncleMeat 4y agoNone of the metrics were changed. The article does not concern the metrics. It concerns the mechanism of communicating awards.