5 ms·
> Both were involved in effective altruism — a community focused on using data to maximize the long-term impact of charitable donations. > She got into crypto,
by neilv 4y ago
> Both were involved in effective altruism — a community focused on using data to maximize the long-term impact of charitable donations.
> She got into crypto, she explained on another episode, because she was hoping to make lots of money to give away as part of her commitment to effective altruism.
Should the term be capitalized, as Effective Altruism?
It seems to be a new, branded definition, and not in common usage like the generic terms effective and altruism.
It's also bringing some bad associations to good old-fashioned altruism.
Also, in the space of questionable philosophy appealing to insulated rich kids, Objectivism is already capitalized.
- dmix 4y agoCuriously this was flagged @dang? I personally can't tell why.
- EGreg 4y agoBasically, it seems that earn to give isnt the best way. Billionaires like Jeff Bezos got that way by building a very successful organization that helps a lot of consumers (being able to do so thanks yo wage slavery until automation started kicking in). Since then, it has grown a lot and Bezos has to do nothing to reap the benefits but keep his shares. But just because Bezos built one great thing that helps so many consumers, does that make him the best at giving away wealth? He claims it is actually HARD to do effectively. His ex-wife seems to bave given a lot more than he has. And Warren Buffett outsourced it to Bill Gates. And tons if people even hate Bill Gates for his vaccination programs in Africa - despite eradicating Polio. Bill also speaks to world leaders and wants to spray mist in the atmosphere to cool the planet. And kill all mosquitoes. Pretty big plans. Plus Bill buys a huge amount of farmland for some reason. What makes people think central planning would be the best way to allocate donations in the world?
- agentultra 4y agoThere are no such things as benevolent billionaires. There’s a problem with a society that enables billionaires to exist at all. It shouldn’t even be possible but we’re here for a lot of reasons. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0Cu6EbELZ6I https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0Cu6EbELZ6I
- corndoge 4y ago> There are no such things as benevolent billionaires. Interesting thesis, do you have any reasoning to support your claim?
- allenbrunson 4y agoi'll take a crack at it: the act of accumulating a billion dollars is an anti-social act. billionaires should have been giving it away hand over fist long before that happened.
- MrOwnPut 4y agoThey own part of the company that is worth that much. They can't liquidate all their assets without harming the company, thus the livelihoods of their employees. Look at what they create, not only what they are worth. Also your charity endeavors are more effective with the compound interest of a billionaire vs a multi-millionaire.
- allenbrunson 4y agothat sounds to me like a great excuse a billionaire could use to make himself believe that no, really, me keeping all this money is actually good. sam bankman-fried is purported to have used a variation of this.
- EGreg 4y agoShares represent extracting rents from the value exchange ecosystem the company participates in. Selling shares is fine for growing a company. But the perverse part is shareholders then go ahead and sell them to others, sometimes forming a bubble, other times pushing company management to extract ever more rents / eke out ever more profit for them to support sky-high valuations. This investor bubble hurts both consumers and producers and enriches those who passively park their money in things. Don’t get me wrong, I think in growth stages, stock exchanges do allocate money to fuel productive sectors of society. But during other periods of a company’s life, they are mere zero sum games, where money goes mostly from retail investors to enrich hedge funds. I think the problem is that there is no limit to shareholder value extraction. The non-productive sector of society parks their money in shares in order to legally plunder the value exchange of producers and consumers. Now that we have utility tokens, the network can be owned by the participants. Raise money by selling utility tokens at a discount. They have a ceiling after all (the value of the utility token) and you can only sell as much as people believe there will be demand in the end from actual customers. You can raise money by selling shares temporarily but have the shares be usable as discounts on utility tokens so you can sell them to customers. And that way you can ignore your shareholders clamoring for you to cannibalize your ecosystem for them.
- 77pt77 4y agoThere are audio recordings of Fried saying that it was something he needed to say in order to fit in with the right crowd. There were never any philanthropic objectives. It was always a scam from the get go. Also look into one-coin and Ruja Ignatova.
- yewenjie 4y agoAre those recordings publicly available or any source?
- jychang 4y agoNot audio recordings, they were screenshots of a twitter conversation
- 77pt77 4y agoMy bad. I heard a reenactment. The point stands. He said what he thought he needed to say and there were never any philanthropic objectives. This is what I meant: https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/3FuCAM_X4mREv2FJTnDv_QMmD6M=/0x0:1244x1074/920x0/filters:focal(0x0:1244x1074):format(webp):no_upscale()/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/24202642/Screen_Shot_2022_11_16_at_7.34.01_AM.png https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/3FuCAM_X4mREv2FJTnDv_QMmD6M=... Or this: https://youtu.be/qMKEvAui9SU?t=580 https://youtu.be/qMKEvAui9SU?t=580 https://youtu.be/qMKEvAui9SU?t=860 https://youtu.be/qMKEvAui9SU?t=860
- 3np 4y agoWould also appreciate a link. What I have (maybe GP is mixing these up?): Alleged Twitter DM conversation between SBF and Vox reporter that fits otherwise: https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/23462333/sam-bankman-fried-ftx-cryptocurrency-effective-altruism-crypto-bahamas-philanthropy https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/23462333/sam-bankman-frie... Audio recordings of two calls between SBF and Tiffany Wong where he says he donated to Democratic Party publicly but equivalent amount to Republican Party dark to play both sides: https://piped.video/watch?v=6DezodR9hNI https://piped.video/watch?v=6DezodR9hNI https://piped.video/watch?v=xP54LZB3WRw https://piped.video/watch?v=xP54LZB3WRw Maybe there's more in those, I found it too tiring to listen to all of it due to it being hard to make out what SBF is saying. CoffeZilla commented and subbed parts: https://piped.video/watch?v=0rL35_WV3lE https://piped.video/watch?v=0rL35_WV3lE
- dmix 4y agoI also can’t think of Effective Altruism without thinking of the inverse radical Objectivism. I don’t agree with Ayn Rand’s amateur philosophizing [1] but it’s a great example of using the Rational vs Altruistic dichotomy for extreme ideological ends. Both just happen to be able to justify the acquisition of infinite capital without typical counter-weights that society puts forward… and inversely to justify authoritarian state control of everything for either purely rational or purely altruistic pursuits as was in vogue in the 1910-1940s. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Virtue_of_Selfishness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Virtue_of_Selfishness
- lordfrito 4y agoInteresting insight. Sometimes it seems like the ultra wealthy need some sort of story to tell themselves (and others) as to why they are different, why they have earned and deserve these vast richest, etc. Philosophy more and more seems to be a rich mans game. Wonder if it has anything to do with Imposter Syndrome? As if preaching a philosophy can somehow make up for the ruthlessness (and I have to believe some emptiness) underneath it all? Also, there seems to be an element of fashion involved. Like when it was in vogue for celebrities to adopt foreign kids (only to have them raised by nannies). Gotta virtue signal. Maybe that explains why the beliefs come and go, Objectivism was so last year, etc.
- cma 4y agoThe Effective Altruists bought two castles. Why? The ambiance helps them think clearer and hold better events of course! Since they are the main character (ironically Rand-ish), the castles are a better use of donations than cheap mosquito nets, famine relief, etc.
- alvah 4y agoAnybody who generates wealth via business ownership is different from most of us - business risk should have at least a chance of reward, otherwise why take the risk? Of course rent-seeking, regulation-gaming & parasitical industries such as finance and real estate muddy the waters, but fundamentally the existence of some number of ultra-rich individuals is a natural outcome of the opportunity to generate wealth via business.
- NiloCK 4y agoIt absolutely should be! This also applies to "open source" vs "Open Source". The former has regular connotations from regular English usage. The latter, and only the latter, should refer to the proprietary definition offered by the OSI.
- jefftk 4y ago> Should the term be capitalized, as Effective Altruism? I've seen it written both ways, though it looks like lowercase is more common. Ex: Wikipedia uses lowercase https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_altruism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_altruism
- dougk16 4y agoCapitalized, yes. It should also have air quotes. "Effective Altruism" is more appropriate in this case.