3 ms·
> for those downvoting, can you tell me how I’m wrong, if that is the case? Sure. Your claim that X is not female is correct. Your claim that Y is not male is
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
> for those downvoting, can you tell me how I’m wrong, if that is the case?
Sure. Your claim that X is not female is correct. Your claim that Y is not male is wrong. Y is male. If one or more Y chromosomes are present, a male will develop, and if zero or fewer are present, a female will develop.[1]
Cloning a normal male's single X chromosome would lead to the type of problems familiar from inbreeding, but would be unlikely to lead to nonviability; two different X chromosomes, which all normal women have, are already too many and parts of them must be inactivated so that normal development can proceed.
The Y chromosome is unimportant enough that chromosomal abnormalities generally leave the organism in a viable, if often defective, state. The subject of this experiment is an example, with three (XXY) sex chromosomes. One X chromosome and no Y chromosomes (which would usually be described "XO", not "X") would get you a female with Turner syndrome.
In a handy table:
X alone: female, Turner syndrome
Y alone: male, but nonviable; this will be a miscarriage.
XX: female, normal
XY: male, normal
YY: male, nonviable
XXX: female, triple X syndrome
XXY: male, Klinefelter syndrome
XYY: male, Jacobs syndrome
YYY: male, nonviable
[1] There is an exception related to androgen insensitivity. There you have a genetic male that develops into what is mostly a phenotypic female. Such people have female psychology and female external anatomy, but they do not have a female reproductive system and are therefore sterile.
- psychphysic 4y agoThanks nicely laid out.