3 ms·
Rust is absolutely a "drop-in" replacement to C in most cases even for existing projects, it was absolutely built with that goal in mind. You can go as fine-gr
by zozbot234 4y ago
Rust is absolutely a "drop-in" replacement to C in most cases even for existing projects, it was absolutely built with that goal in mind. You can go as fine-grained as replacing a single function with a Rust-coded version (even using bindgen to ingest existing C headers) - though that generally involves unsafety because you're dealing with general pointers, extern calls and such. Even Checked C cannot prove these things 100% safe, it just catches common misuse.
(Of course some C projects could abuse the preprocessor in ways that make it infeasible to even replace a C function with a Rust equivalent, but that's incredibly rare. And Rust has macro facilities of its own.)
- maxbond 4y agoWe're using different senses of "drop in", it's a bit of a vague term. Rust is interoperable with C (it can do C FFI) but it is not compatible with C (C code is not Rust code and Rust code is not C code). Compare this to a language like Carbon or C++; that is what I'd call a "drop in replacement", because they are compatible, using the definitions I've provided. If FFI were sufficient, Python would be a "C replacement." It's true that there is a path to integrating Rust into C projects and potentially replacing C in that project, I just see lots of threads on HN derailed by the statement "Rust is a C replacement", and I think using more nuanced language would help.
- zozbot234 4y agoBy that standard, Carbon is not compatible with C or C++, and neither is Cppfront. One could argue that C-style uses of pinned data or possibly-aliased pointers are not idiomatic in Rust and are a pitfall for interop with the Safe subset; nonetheless these uses can be expressed in the language.
- Tozen 4y agoAnd there are other languages that interop well with and have a FFI for C.
- xigoi 4y agoC++ is not source-compatible with C and never has been.