4 ms·
Contemplating Codec Comparisons
- PaulHoule 4y agoThe quality of image codec evaluations I've seen on the web are pretty bad. Just searching on Google you find many SEO-oriented splogs that pontificate on the topic without having done any evaluation at all. (The horrible fact is that internet users might find these more satisfying than quality evaluation.) One difficulty is that people have different targets for image quality. For instance I might have photos I took with my DSLR that I want to share with people and I am going to think carefully about the image size I present (Often my 6000x4000 RAW is not "tack sharp" if I look at it closely so I am always thinking: "will this look good on a tablet?" or "will this look good if I print it as a 4x6 card, what about a 19x13"?) I've seen web sites that evaluate image codecs on the assumption that you are making images for a web site that aren't meant for close inspection: the target for those is something that is appropriate for some purposes but unacceptable for mine. A codec that is good for one of those cases might not be good for the other.