5 ms·
I tried to read your message few times with an open spirit but I don't buy it. The moment I, for any reason, I cannot collaborate unless I get my hands back on
by epolanski 4y ago
I tried to read your message few times with an open spirit but I don't buy it.
The moment I, for any reason, I cannot collaborate unless I get my hands back on an Apple device (and possibly Apple id which is even more complicated) it stops being a collaborative software.
- gandalfgreybeer 4y agoI sort of have an idea on what he meant. Everyone in my family and close friends have at least one Apple device and the “collaborative” environment in that sense is wonderful, especially with Reminders, notes, sharing files etc. It however fails once you go outside. Might be a stupid analogy so let’s net focus on this but I sort of see it like this:in my country, we can speak our language and it works for collaboration. Once you go outside, it fails. But that doesn’t mean it wasn’t successful as a “collaborative” tool for that environment. I think you and op just might have different scales of where you think it should work well enough.
- goosedragons 4y agoMore like everyone entrenched in the ecosystem. I can't imagine this is a super great experience for someone who only has an iPhone SE but non-Apple everything else. Especially when the creator is used to the canvas of their 27" Studio Display.
- kyawzazaw 4y agoMany people in their targeted market has an iPhone and maybe a macbook.
- browningstreet 4y agoI’ve worked in design companies where every machine… including the bookkeeper’s, was a Mac. This app Won’t run into any issues in that environment. It’s like every time somebody posts a commercial SaaS app people will ask if it can be self-hosted. We know what these things are. Seems fair to start there.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoI've worked and interviewed at several tech companies that were nearly or fully Mac-exclusive. The only two exceptions that come to mind was at one where the finance guy had a Windows laptop because he lived in Excel and at one where one of the backend guys ran a custom built Linux tower, both of whom were the oddballs in their respective companies with everybody else toting MacBooks.
- tshaddox 4y agoI agree with brookst. The fact that most Apple first-party software only works on Apple devices is a given, and any time you call an app “collaborative” it’s a given that we’re talking only about the devices which can run the software. What are we supposed to call it when they add collaboration to one of their apps? “Adding walled garden” is nonsensical, because to whatever extent it’s a walled garden, that was already the case before adding collaboration.
- j16sdiz 4y agoPages have a web version.
- eigen 4y ago> I cannot collaborate unless I get my hands back on ...( Apple id which is even more complicated) it stops being a collaborative software. getting an Apple id doesn't require apple hardware and most of the tools are available via icloud.com. if an apple id prevents something from being a collaborative tool then google docs, Microsoft 365, Slack, et al are not collaborative tools.
- tosc 4y agoYou’re expressing an ideology here. It’s not pragmatic and doesn’t reflect real world experience. Yes, I have friends who don’t have Apple devices and I can’t use Freeform with them, so of course there are limits. I recently sent my 85 year old mother an iPad so she can more easily watch videos and do video calls. She can use Freeform with me, but there is no chance she would be able to use a Linux or Windows collaboration tool, or even something web based. By your logic, there is no such thing as a collaborative tool, but this is obviously not what people mean.
- twmiller 4y agoMeh. The moment I, for any reason, cannot collaborate unless I get my hands on a computer it stops being collaborative. Or not. 'Collaborative' doesn't mean 'accessible by anyone'. Collaborative just means capable of supporting two or more parties working together, and freeform clearly meets the criteria...
- itishappy 4y agoI don't understand the point of your distinction. Barriers will always exist. You'll always need to download an app or visit a website. If something can be used for collaboration, it is be definition collaborative, is it not? A multi-user tabletop projection system is collaborative, even if it requires everyone to be in the same room using the same device. Is Slack, Teams, or Trello not collaborative because it won't run on my XBox360?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y ago> Is Slack, Teams, or Trello not collaborative because it won't run on my XBox360? This is not their point because your XBox360 is not something you use to perform your job (or, at least, it's not something most people use to perform their jobs). If I use a Windows computer for work and I can't use this software to collaborate on that work, then this isn't really "collaborative" software in the practical sense.
- epolanski 4y agoExactly my point. If it's OS locked it's not collaborative for me. Collaboration should be about lowering barriers, not rising them.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- r00fus 4y agoYou sound like a non-Facebook user complaining about Facebook messenger not being collaborative enough. Fair point (can't use FB if you're not subscribed) but completely not representative of the greater population or (in this case) Apple's target market.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- last_responder 4y agoHow is getting an Apple ID complicated?
- kemayo 4y agoThat one does seem at the level of "if you have to make a free account to access something it's not collaborative", which is quite the bar.
- epolanski 4y agoAsk apple why does it take them up to January 4th 2023 to contact me to recover my account since I've forgot the password. I'm locked out of my account since Nov 19th
- brookst 4y agoVery interesting that people can have such different definitions. I suppose your view is that any tightly controlled software can’t be collaborative? Like Epic, that likely helps your health care professionals and labs exchange info and collaborate on your care, or air traffic control systems where lots of people collaborate to route planes and control airspace. Those kinds of things aren’t collaborative software because they run on limited platforms and access is tightly controlled. Is that congruent with your viewpoint?