3 ms·
So we have now come full circle. Crypto started out as a naive attempt at money without government. But this was quickly shown to be an open invitation to ram
by jqpabc123 4y ago
So we have now come full circle.
Crypto started out as a naive attempt at money without government. But this was quickly shown to be an open invitation to rampant fraud that is still ongoing and technology alone can not prevent.
So now in a last ditch effort at survival, crypto is begging for a government lifeline with oversight and regulation.
I said all along that the only thing government needed to do to kill crypto was absolutely nothing --- just give it some space to self implode.
This has largely come to pass. Only one final realization remains ---- if regulation is needed, crypto is not. It no longer will have any compelling *legal* reason to exist
- logicchains 4y agoThis is not crypto, it's parasitic centralised exchanges that want a bunch of institutional money in the ecosystem so that they can collect their cut of the fees.
- acdha 4y agoThat is cryptocurrency, even if you find it inconvenient for marketing purposes. You can “no true coin” everything negative but at that point there’s almost nothing left — all of the billions in funding have had surprisingly little real-world impact because once you subtract the scams and the effort spent trying to work around problems created by the design there isn’t much left.
- jrm4 4y agoBut "not much" is completely different from "nothing," and it would be a massive mistake to presume "little real world impact" because you haven't seen it now, or yet, e.g. Black Swans et al.
- acdha 4y agoI said little real world impact because after many years and billions of dollars, the number of people outside of the industry who’d be inconvenienced if it disappeared is very small - perhaps a few people who can save a percentage over Western Union and some people in Venezuela who prefer laundering money that way. Contrast that with things like the web which despite much higher barriers to adoption had been incorporated into normal people’s lives within a couple of years. In less than the time bitcoin has been around, we went from the pre-iPod era to one where most people were connected everywhere and the way people worked, played, traveled, dated, etc. had changed notably.
- jqpabc123 4y agoAnd why do these "parasitic centralised exchanges" exist? Because the crypto market isn't really functional without them. Even people using so called "decentralized" exchanges turn to them to obtain a market rate for their transactions. In effect, "decentralization" is just a crypto marketing/selling point that has never been achieved. It takes more than accounting to build a functional market.
- mjburgess 4y agoThe only thing decentralised was the ledger and it's consistency. There never has been any sense to "political decentralisation" having anything to do with crypto. A social network isn't decentralised because it's people use a centralised or decentralised proof-of-correctness. An economic network isnt centralised or decentralised if its ledger of promises is stored centrally or otherwise. This is a fairly obvious fallacy to anyone who understands that centralisation of power is a social-graph structure, and economic centralisation is transaction-graph-structure and crypto "decentralisation" concerns only the storage-and-computation of a ledger. Ironically, the crypto "economy" is radically more centralised in social-graph and transaction-graph terms. So much so that it's incredibly fragile to a handful of individual failures. The idea that these have anything to do with each other is such an obvious nonesense that the only reason its repeated is just people do not understand at least one of these issues. Ie., very few are both in the camp of technically, politically and economically competent. Money is already close to the maximally decentralised a ledger storage can be. It's already close to maximally decentralised proof-of-correctness. Having a bank-note in your hand is extremely good proof it's yours, and extremely hard for others to steal. Decentralisation, in the only relevant sense to crypto, already exists in a close to perfect form (ie., money).
- matthewdgreen 4y agoDecentralized exchanges are in their infancy. They're not as efficient as centralized exchanges yet, but that seems more like a temporary technological limitation rather than some sort of iron law. What can't be decentralized is the fiat currency interconnect.
- bookaway 4y agoFrankly, I was expecting Coinbase to capitalize on the roaring 20s by slowly pivoting from crypto to something that had legs in the real world and start building software useful for small businesses, you know, start slowly entering into something like Stripe's domain, since they had a front-row seat to the mess and should have been able to see that the good times couldn't last. I was stupefied as I watched the opposite happen. If memory serves me correctly, it was Stripe that started getting into crypto instead of the other way around as the bubble was bursting--to my amazement. And this despite having patio11 in their ranks. Yeah yeah big company etc etc, but still, it really dented my confidence in the Stripe brand and the people working under its umbrella.
- jqpabc123 4y agoLots of companies start with a singular idea ... and never grow beyond it. At one time, I looked at using Coinbase/crypto for money transfer purposes. I had several clients who tried to open an account but their applications were rejected. They were more strict than most banks.
- kodyo 4y agoBitcoin isn't going away, sir.
- jqpabc123 4y agoI never said it was. But with regulation and increased focus on blatant market manipulation/fraud/speculation, the demand for it will likely decline from current levels in my opinion. Just wait for a full government mandated audit of Tether and other "stable coins" then get back to me on this. "Stable coins" are the support mechanism for Bitcoin and the crypto market in general. And they are on less than firm ground --- again, in my opinion. It's difficult to say anything truly definitive about the current crypto market because transparency is the exception rather than the rule. This will likely change with government regulation.
- hypertele-Xii 4y agoBitcoin has gone away several times already. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_bitcoin_forks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_bitcoin_forks
- jakupovic 4y agoYou're right we are going to rid of the biggest money invention ever just because. Even beanie babies are still around. You give no reasons, no facts, basically make shit up and then draw a conclusion. Probably should research the subject a bit more before committing to your conclusion.