7 ms·
From the article: "Eric Ries greatest venture may be the Lean Startup movement itself." The top ranked review of his book on Amazon seems fairly dubious about
by davidw 15y ago
From the article: "Eric Ries greatest venture may be the Lean Startup movement itself."
The top ranked review of his book on Amazon seems fairly dubious about the value of the book:
http://www.amazon.com/review/R3287ICLQ9STI3/ref=cm_cr_dp_cmt?ie=UTF8&ASIN=B004J4XGN6&nodeID=133140011 http://www.amazon.com/review/R3287ICLQ9STI3/ref=cm_cr_dp_cmt...
I have a weakness for business books and am tempted to buy it anyway, but I'm still not convinced; I'm trying to cut back on books that don't actually leave me with anything.
- DanielBMarkham 15y agoI bought Ries book and made it most of the way through. The problem here is that the Agile/Lean startup field is still in its infancy. The ideas are just now congealing. That's good news because it means the field is wide open -- there are going to be a lot of cool new developments. But it's also bad news because every book you get is going to be hit-and-miss: a few good ideas, a few ideas that sound wacky, and a lot of noise. Agile is like that. It's a collection of best practices around iterative and incremental technology development. That's why it drives some folks nuts: different people can give you different answers and in the end it's all about custom tailoring and results-oriented process. What we're seeing now is this agile/best-practices idea extended to the startup world. That's a good thing! There's really good stuff in there. But it's going to evolve over many years, and just like Agile in the end you're not going to end up with a recipe book as much as a place to start, a lot of good material to absorb, and some guiding principles. It'll probably be something like the learn-do-adapt process we see in Scrum (Obligatory plug: just blogged about this the other day and posted about it on HN. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3404085 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3404085) So I like the Lean Startup idea. I'm just not sure what it is yet. I don't think anybody is.
- davidw 15y agoI'm fairly convinced that there is some good stuff behind 'lean startups', and that it's not just a fad. What I'm a bit more skeptical of is how much of it can actually be distilled into practical advice, and how much of it would fit just fine in a one page summary. Here's another way of looking at it, for fans of the book: What concrete things did you do after having read it that you might have overlooked previously? Let's measure something:-)
- DanielBMarkham 15y agoHere's one for you. Last year I tried an experiment where I developed a new website or app every two weeks. At the end of two weeks, I switched and started on something new. "Normally," you're supposed to spend years on one idea, slogging away. I said "screw that" and decided I try an iterative shotgun approach. I put out a lot of things, talked about them all, and then let each one of them compete for my attention. hn-books was one of these ideas (http://hn-books.com http://hn-books.com) This was extreme iterative behavior, and I don't know anybody that recommends it. But I had a really good experience doing this and plan on starting back up in January. I found it's a better experience learning about the entire process of business model creation over and over again than just doing it one time and trying to get it perfect. If I were at YC, I'd probably pick up on a lot of that through social contacts with all the other folks, but on my own I found that iteration on something real and tangible was really the best way to learn. EDIT: My comment seems very ironic considering that a couple of the other comments on this thread are basically along the lines of "it's really smart people and theory, but nothing that practical" In fact, in this experiment found it to be extremely practical.
- akg_67 15y agoI have found customer discovery section of Steve Blank's Four Steps book and Business Model canvas from Business Model Generation book to be very invaluable tools for evaluating new ideas whether my own or of other new potential entrepreneurs. I actually converted customer discovery section into one pagers like canvas. It allows me to quickly go through evaluating any new idea, document different aspects, and identify holes in my understanding and where to focus. none of the stuff listed is unique but it provides a easy step by step actionable structure. I find just documenting business model canvas, product and customer hypotheses enough to figure out potential and challenges involved in pursuing an idea.
- swombat 15y agoI'm still reading it, so not had the time to truly practice it, but one important idea I've taken out of it is the idea of the growth and value hypotheses being the key assumptions in a startup's infancy. I already believed that a startup is a series of hypotheses to be checked out, but focusing on the value hypothesis (will this product deliver value to its customers/users) and growth (will we be able to grow the user base as we expect) first is a good insight.
- DanielRibeiro 15y agoRies book is very interesting, and Running Lean is more product focused and pragmatical[1], and less about the theories behind it. And the book was a result of testing Lean Startup Ideas, and taking a very skeptical look into it (which is, in itself, a very lean approach). For me though, it seemed like a refreshing refocus and evolution of Agile into a more customer centric product development[2] [1] http://www.runningleanhq.com/ http://www.runningleanhq.com/ [2] http://www.slideshare.net/HackerChick/lean-startup-how-development-looks-different-when-youre-changing-the-world-agile-2011 http://www.slideshare.net/HackerChick/lean-startup-how-devel...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]