3 ms·
Copyright shouldn't last even one decade. Most of the profits of games and movies are made in the first few weeks. Give them like five years of protection in or
by matheusmoreira 4y ago
Copyright shouldn't last even one decade. Most of the profits of games and movies are made in the first few weeks. Give them like five years of protection in order to be exceptionally generous and allow for exactly 0 extensions.
That's it. That's how copyright should work in order to be tolerable. Anything else is pure rent seeking.
- nearbuy 4y agoA lot of great indie games wouldn't even have been finished when their copyright expired if it lasted only 5 years (Factorio, Minecraft, Terraria). And Cave Story wouldn't have made any money. It was released for free in 2004 but few people knew about it at the time. It wasn't until 2010/2011 when it released on Nintendo and Steam (paid version) that it took off.
- elsjaako 4y agoMinecraft kept being updated during early development, so unless you wanted to play a five year old version it would still have been under copyright. I agree it probably wouldn't have sold for a billion dollars, but they were making a lot of money before the sale. Cave Story I'm less familiar with, but again the Nintento and Steam versions would probably be different and have new copyright. But I think you're saying the game sold well despite a free version being available. Isn't this an example that you don't need any copyright to make money off a game?
- nearbuy 4y agoYeah, the first 3 games were (and still are) being updated. Still seems problematic to lose your original copyright before your even finished making your game. People looking to make a quick buck could put old copies of your game on Steam, same name and everything. The Cave Story Steam version had some minor graphics changes but no major differences. Mainly, a lot of people hadn't heard of it before then, and people weren't necessarily aware there was a free version. Copyright was important here; without it, someone else would have put it on Steam years earlier.
- dahart 4y ago> Most of the profits of games and movies are made in the first few weeks. This is mostly straw man, it only applies to big-budget AAA titles, it doesn’t apply to indie games & movies, it doesn’t apply to artists or musicians, especially most small-time artists. It doesn’t apply to books or to software or to journalism or to educational or corporate content. Your claim isn’t really even true for Marvel movies or whatever either, box office is complicated and movie profits are now based on global sales and streaming and ancillary rights and merchandising and all kind of things that don’t happen in the first few weeks. Copyrights might be too long now, but these laws have been around for many centuries, and ala Chesterton’s fence, you seem to be failing to consider the reasons that copyrights appeared in the first place, and the ramifications of significantly reducing or abolishing copyrights. The problem that led to copyrights is IP theft, unscrupulous people publishing work as their own and rent-seeking all the profit they can. This will happen at a massive scale if we cut the period down to 1 decade or less. You might want to consider the possibility that if copyright were shortened to less than a decade or abolished today, it might not really hurt Disney and other big media corps at all, it might just kill independent artists because large corporations can control the internet and legally steal your independent creative work before you can make money from it.
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> box office is complicated It's really not. It either makes more money than it cost or it doesn't. If it does, it's considered a success. If not, it's a flop. That's how everything I've ever read about the copyright industry puts it. I don't really see a need to complicate this. Yeah, corporations make additional money from licensing, merchandising and whatnot. Making toys and stuff is fine but this licensing bullshit really should end after a few years once the work enters the public domain. They've already made their money, they're done and it's time for the work enter the public domain. > The problem that led to copyrights is IP theft, unscrupulous people publishing work as their own and rent-seeking all the profit they can. And how is the copyright solution working out for them? Days ago I saw someone here posting about how their web game was cloned by someone else. Did they sue? No, it's too expensive. Meanwhile corporations will kill your YouTube videos and steal your advertising money if someone walks by on the street playing a song they own. You might consider the possibility that this trillion dollar copyright industry has already coopted this so called "system". They turned it against the very same people it was designed to protect.