5 ms·
Thermodynamics is thermodynamics. However what I think people are meaning to argue is that “just don’t eat as much” can be akin to saying, “just stop being depr
by Waterluvian 4y ago
Thermodynamics is thermodynamics. However what I think people are meaning to argue is that “just don’t eat as much” can be akin to saying, “just stop being depressed.” It can basically be impossible if not dangerous for some.
Also, our calorie furnaces all work a bit differently. Thermodynamics laws hold, but some of us have far wider margins for how generously our body will burn off or otherwise not hold on to those calories.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- paulpauper 4y agoexactly, I don't get why so many people who are presumed to be smart always default to this oversimplistic assumption, ignoring that food consumption and calorie burning are as biologically-driven as almost everything else in life.
- actionablefiber 4y agoThe reason is that it works well enough, most of the time, for most people. If you are trying to lose weight, you do not need an exact formula to compute the derivative of your weight with respect to time; you need a mental model of your diet and metabolism that moves you toward your goal. CICO basically tells you to look at your two most important levers for doing that (how much you eat and how much you move) and adjust them until your weight moves in the right direction.
- JackFr 4y agoBut people have an extremely poor mental model of calories out. In particular there is a great misunderstanding with respect to the role of exercise. It’s not the calories you burn during the period of exercise, rather it’s the changes to your body that exercise causes that encourage weight loss.
- josephcsible 4y agoYou don't need to have a good model of calories out. Just keep track of calories in and your weight over time, and reduce calories in until you're losing weight at an acceptable rate.
- PeterStuer 4y agoAll models are wrong, some models are usefull. The (over)consumption industry is trying to hammer home a message that basically boils down to 'calories model is not perfect, please do not moderate your consumption'. If forced hey are ok with you consuming 'different', but not with consuming 'less'. The results can be observed every day on every street.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Retric 4y ago> some of us have far wider margins for how generously our body will burn off or otherwise not hold on to those calories. That’s always seemed like a nonsensical rebuttal. Nobody is actually measuring how many calories they burn per day or the actual content of their food down to 4 decimal places, but you can quickly get a baseline based on comparing rates of weight loss and total calories consumed because the difference in died aren’t subtle. If 2100 calories doesn’t work fast enough try 2000...
- 8note 4y agoThe missing measurement is how many calories you poop, and what relationships exist between what and how much you eat to the amount of calories you poop
- hahajk 4y agoActually you lose most of your mass through carbon dioxide, through breathing. (And similarly, trees and plants get almost all their mass through carbon dioxide, not the soil.)
- jwiz 4y agoYou just track calories in, and weight. If you stop losing weight, reduce calories in. It doesn't matter if you "have a slow metabolism" or whatever, because that just means you don't get to eat as much as someone else who weighs the same as you. There are confounding factors so that you can't predict how much weight will be lost by a given calorie deficit. But that doesn't matter. You will lose weight if you eat less.
- nsxwolf 4y agoAnd here’s where the problem comes in for me - when I reach that level, where weight loss begins to be measurable, I am so miserable I can’t think about anything but food 24/7. It’s like being in a staring contest where the other person never, ever blinks.
- 4y ago
- 22c 4y agoPeople also seem to think that "calories out" == "exercise" which it doesn't. For example, if you ate gasoline encased in glass marbles, you'd be eating a lot of calories. The body wouldn't use much of it, though! It's not really widely understood how much the caloric content of our food is actually converted to fat.
- slowmovintarget 4y agoCalories out means exhaling carbon dioxide (that's the end of the chemical reaction chain of burning fat). So exercise certainly helps.
- _ph_ 4y agoYes, exercise helps. But it also can have the side effect on making people hungry. So if the other nutritional inbalances in the people are not kept within limits, the exercise might not be as effective.
- SyzygistSix 4y agoSome types of exercise help me to mitigate hunger. Other types make me ravenously hungry and are detrimental to reducing caloric intake. The same goes for different types of food. Finding out what works and what doesn't took a while.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoYour metabolism doesn’t use 100% of the energy content of food. It’s actually quite hard to tell the true calories you will get from any give food, it probably depends on many individual factors of both of the human and the food.