5 ms·
I lost 50 pounds in 2020 with this one trick: I counted calories and stayed under 2100 per day. I didn’t even pay attention to what kinds of food I ate. That
by Waterluvian 4y ago
I lost 50 pounds in 2020 with this one trick: I counted calories and stayed under 2100 per day.
I didn’t even pay attention to what kinds of food I ate. That came automatically as I would look at a treat and think, “130 calories? That’s so expensive.” I naturally learned what foods made me feel full for longer. It was fun.
Diet can be complicated, but I have a feeling that for most of us, it really doesn’t need to be.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y ago“130 calories? That’s so expensive." That's exactly how I came to lose all the weight I have - I started counting calories which caused me to treat it like a budget. I never deprived myself of what I wanted, but new if I splurged on supper I'd not be able to do as much dessert.
- Waterluvian 4y agoMy favourite part of it is that it’s so simple you can barely call it a system. The diet industry/community really disinterests me because there is so much complexity.
- andreareina 4y agoUnfortunately the simple thing is hard. To the extent that every system that isn’t counting calories works, it works by manipulating appetite and satiety to induce a spontaneous reduction in consumption. People will jump through all sorts of hoops to not feel deprived.
- mkraft 4y agoImagine trying to reign in spending without a budget by drinking lots of water to avoid buying starbucks and other similar indirect tricks. Without the budget you’d easily overspend. This is how I think of calorie counting as the only proper way and other diets as inefficient indirections.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoThis method is simple, and works well enough for enough people, but it doesn't for some. I still kind of agree with you, because I have a sneaking suspicion that people mostly cluster into groups of "any diet / intervention works" and "none of them work". Unfortunately, the body itself is a complex system, and likes to throw curve-balls. Going by some of the things I've read over the years, it's clear the body has defense mechanisms against starvation - such as lowering metabolism and activity levels in lock step with diminished caloric input, or turning you into food-obsessed zombie, hardly capable of a non-food-related thought, until you feed the body enough to cancel red alert. Problem is, for some people, those defense mechanisms seem to kick in before they reach negative energy balance. As simple as calorie counting is, it's not helpful if the body hits the "override" switch before you reach Calories In < Calories Out. I don't know if there's a solution for this case, but I suspect all the variety of diets is really just people doing a blind search in hopes of finding specific tricks that shut down the defense mechanism in subgroups of individuals. (In a sense it's like a puzzle game: your goal is to sneak past a security system without raising an alarm. The security system consists of a great variety of sensors of all kinds - but only a random subset of them are in use, configured with random thresholds. Every player gets their own, unique puzzle.)
- bumby 4y agoA lot of eating is habitual, driven by social cues etc. E.g., anyone who is used to eating breakfast but skips it one day will feel like they are "starving", but if they skip it for two weeks they no longer get that hungry feeling in the morning because your body is no longer habitualized to release ghrelin at the same time. >lowering metabolism I believe this has been debunked. Your calories out is a function of calories in (e.g., protein takes more energy to metabolize than, say, glucose), but your body doesn't really downregulate it's metabolism the way it's been touted in the past. >search in hopes of finding specific tricks that shut down IMO, what consistently works is whatever "tricks" you use to reduce calories below what you burn. For some people, it's eliminating meat. For others, it's eating nothing but meat. For others, it's a flexible approach as long as they count calories. But the main commonality seems to be the reduction of calories (and movement away from the standard american diet).
- raverbashing 4y agoYeah, I feel like it's "complicated" only if you DGAF about what you eat The nutrition info is "in your face" for a reason. Use it. How many calories on that bag of chips? On that big cookie you ate? On that fast food sandwich/burger? On that soda which is 100% empty calories with a high GI? The biggest fraud in nutrition has been replacing high-caloric food that actually help with satiety (high protein/"high" fat/high fiber content) with sugary crap
- throw0101c 4y ago> My favourite part of it is that it’s so simple you can barely call it a system. Simply ≠ easy. What to slow/stop/reverse climate change? Simple: "just" reduce carbon output.
- elzbardico 4y agoCounting calories helped me with adding more greens to my diet. I found out that I could start lunch (which is my main feeding event) with a healthy portion of lettuce salad and then eat more moderate portions of carbohydrates and meat as my main course and still feel satiated.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoYeah, my personal rule was that fruit and veg were free.
- eloff 4y agoThat’s also how I manage my weight. After a while you don’t necessarily need to count everything, you get pretty good at just estimating. I know if I have some drinks, I tend to go over budget and I compensate by trying to have a subsequent day under budget, or do some more exercise. I like it because I don’t feel deprived. If I want something, I just fit it into the calorie budget. You pretty quickly learn that potato chips, soda, beer, and candy consume budget quickly and don’t fill you.
- teeray 4y agoThat’s what drives me crazy about calorie counter apps. They demand perfection which is just totally unreasonable in the messy world. I can’t tell you exactly how many cups of fries are on my plate, or what that sauce is made out of. So you have to guess, but they treat that guess as exact. It would be nice to have a fuzzier counter which keeps track of how sure you are and produces error bars.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dgfitz 4y agoI’m quite surprised you haven’t been accosted with the “calories in, calories out isn’t real” yet. Fwiw it is how I and others I know have lost significant amounts of weight. There was a “keto” thread on hn the other day and holy moly was keto/calories in, calories out attacked and rebuked.
- paulpauper 4y agoThen why not just eat nothing? That way you only have to focus on the calories out portion? Obviously, some people find it much harder at this than others. Some average-sized adult males get overweight with just 1300-1700/calories a day due to slow metabolisms or other genetic factors.
- scottlamb 4y ago> Some average-sized adult males get overweight with just 1300-1700/calories a day due to slow metabolisms or other genetic factors. I think this is largely a myth. (The 1700 calorie end is vaguely plausible but not the 1300 calorie end). There was a good article posted here a while ago [1] which talked about this. Now, it isn't necessarily easy to maintain a certain calorie count, in terms of either knowing how much you're eating or actually sticking to it despite hunger pangs. And some foods can help you feel fuller with less, you can have different balance of muscle vs fat at the same weight, etc. In those senses I agree with people who say calories in calories out isn't the whole story. But in the end, thermodynamics always wins. Quote from the article: > Starvation Mode is this wacky idea that if you eat too little an amount of calories for an extended period of time your body stops burning fat; in fact, it starts doing the opposite–you start gaining weight ‘even when consuming 800 calories’. Sound familiar? > So, how much truth is there to this? > Well, see, Starvation Mode is an odd one. Because, while it’s not entirely correct, it’s not entirely incorrect either. > The correct part: When you reduce calories, more specifically as you begin to get leaner, there is, in fact, some slowing of metabolic rate. > The incorrect part: Due to this low-calorie consumption your body decides fuck you and proceeds to enter this phantom zone of otherworldliness where the laws of thermodynamics cease to exist, resulting in no fat loss, or worse, gaining fat on some absurdly low number of calories. It goes on for quite some time, and it's worth reading, but I'll quote just one more part. > This British actress was adamant she had a slow metabolism, turned out she was simply misreporting calorie intake. > When she recorded her food intake via video journal, her intake, according to her, was 1100 calories. When they checked her actual intake (with doubly labelled water) it came to 3000 calories. > Even when she was keeping a food diary, she misreported by 43%. [1] https://physiqonomics.com/eating-too-much/ https://physiqonomics.com/eating-too-much/ discussed at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31381410 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31381410
- melling 4y agoI didn’t even count calories and lost 30 pounds last year. Eat less food. Stopped snacking between meals, and ate a salad for dinner a few nights a week. Also, tried to reduce my meal size, in general. Getting that hungry feeling between meals that I would always satisfy meant I was creating a deficit.
- eitland 4y agoExactly. Find something that works for oneself. Keto works for some people. Just reducing plate size helps for some. Personally I skip breakfasts (I love breakfast, but it is not worth the brain fog that I personally get later in the day) and most workdays I just drink 1/2L of whole milk, preferably cold. I get plenty enough energy from dinner and now I can also enjoy some snack in the evening together with my family.
- vram22 4y agoDo you eat lunch?
- eitland 4y agoNo, I usually skip breakfast and the usual lunch. Typically I just drink 0.5L of milk and walk 2-4 km during the lunch break although I do make exceptions once a week or something. For me personally this works well, I don't get hungry either as long as I know I am not going to eat.
- matthewdgreen 4y agoThis worked beautifully for me when I was in my 20s. Now that I’m in the second half of my 40s it doesn’t work well at all. My body requires a starvation diet before I see even a little weight loss, and I can’t keep it up while remaining productive in my job. This is one of the useful lessons of age: you essentially get to experience living in more than one body within your lifetime. Younger-me would have posted the same confident advice as you did, and it would have seemed just as intuitively obvious - how could it be wrong when I experienced it myself! But in practice for someone with a different metabolism (at any age) it’s deeply unhelpful, even demoralizing.
- stubish 4y agoThis is (was?) Weight Watchers. Gamified dieting before that was a word. They used points though rather than calories, which was easier to monetize and meant you didn't run out of fingers.
- xcrunner529 4y agoYep I was “cutting” (restricting calories in a way to try and lose fat to become more tight and muscular looking) and lose 15 lbs and still had a pizza every week.
- LargeCompanies 4y ago
- squarefoot 4y ago> I lost 50 pounds in 2020 with this one trick: I counted calories and stayed under 2100 per day. Same here. I lost 30 Kg since Jan 2022 when I suffered a heart attack and was installed 2 stents (one more necessary but too risky at the moment). Still need to lose some more weight, although it is becoming more difficult, but counting calories does indeed work. I succeeded only because my soon-to-be wife helped me immensely, or I would have failed miserably if left by myself.
- raffraffraff 4y agoI used an app with a barcode scanner and a huge library of products. It not only tracked calories but gave a nice daily count on fat, protein, carbs and sugar. Simply staying under 2100 calories will drop your weight. No doubt! However, if you want to be able to maintain that long-term, you need to figure out what to eat so that you get the right balance of carbs, sugars, fats and protein. If you don't then you're either gonna be continually hungry or malnourished (or probably both). By using the app long-term I developed a set of recipes (that can be modified so I don't get bored) which make up my foundational diet. This is now sustainable without the app, and without cognitive load or will power.
- fbn79 4y agoAnother improvement step is to stop eating food that comes with a barcode.
- Semaphor 4y agoAt least for me, that would exclude about 40% of vegetables I eat.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoThat's almost all of the food. The food that doesn't have a barcode when you're buying it was most likely delivered in a barcoded box or bag to the shop itself.
- wildylion 4y agoSo, no zebra meat? Bummer. >:3
- wrp 4y agoCounting calories has a dramatic effect because it makes you aware of how much eating is habitual rather than because you need the input. People start eating less without consciously trying to. I've read that calorie counting is the most effective strategy for losing weight, but it is also the strategy people are most resistant to trying because of the perceived hassle. It is a pain for the first few weeks as you go about measuring everything, but once you acquire data on your habitual foods it's not a big deal.
- suprfnk 4y ago> I lost 50 pounds in 2020 with this one trick: I counted calories and stayed under 2100 per day. Yes, I don't think there's anyone that will dispute this. Weight loss is pretty simple. However, it's definitely not easy. "Just keep your calories below X" is way easier said than done. It's like saying: "Everyone can run an ultramarathon, just keep putting your foot in front of the other until you're there. It's really simple."
- hnfong 4y agoIt's not even that simple. The problem is that the body will compensate for the lower calorie intake. The intensity of this effect differs from person to person though. At extreme cases you'll basically have to keep running a marathon on a starvation diet before you can get your body to burn the fat. As an anecdote, my weight doesn't change much regardless whether I eat 1500 or 3000 calories a day. I'm overweight, but eating 1500 calories is pretty negligible to my weight loss, and I generally have to embark on those more extreme diets to change anything.
- bumby 4y ago>The problem is that the body will compensate for the lower calorie intake. For the most part, this is a myth, just like the idea that one's metabolism slows as you age. What can happen is your behavior modifies. E.g., if you eat more, you unconsciously fidget more and burn more calories. Most people (even dietitians) are not good at gauging their calorie intake. Unless you are weighing all your portions, it's more likely that measuring error is the culprit, not that you can double your calories consistently and not gain weight.
- gadders 4y agoLikewise. I worked out what weight I wanted to be and by when, and put that into a Renaissance Periodisation calorie calculator that told me I need to be below 1600kcal/day.
- thayne 4y ago> It was fun. Not for me. I tried it for about a month, and it was the opposite of fun. I hated having to keep track of everything I ate. I hated trying to figure out how many calories were in homemade meals. I hated measuring things out to know how many servings I was eating.