5 ms·
Tesla’s dropping share price takes valuation below ExxonMobil’s
- yunruse 4y agopaywall-free link: https://12ft.io/proxy?&q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ft.com%2Fcontent%2F0f051e02-da07-4d7f-a2fc-0a62b96cc790 https://12ft.io/proxy?&q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ft.com%2Fcontent%...
- scaramanga 4y agoA car company that sells low-quality cars that are dangerous is worth less than an oil giant that provides the energy the global economy is powered by? The more you learn...
- KerrAvon 4y agoTesla’s absurd value as a memestock is propped up entirely by Elon’s reputation. Short of Elon going into some kind of rehab facility where he gets serious psychotherapy, dropping all of his commitments other than Tesla, and never tweeting again, I would expect Tesla will in the near future be valued at something approaching its actual value, which means a much reduced share price even compared with the close today.
- panick21_ 4y agoTesla valuation is a based on growing quickly, while having good margin and good profit. And that they will continue to grow pretty quickly for a the next few years at least. > valued at something approaching its actual value And you know what that is? I hope you are a billionaire. Please tell us what it is and how you calculated that.
- boyka 4y ago> And you know what that is? I hope you are a billionaire. Please tell us what it is and how you calculated that. Please review the HN guidelines on snarky low effort comments. If you value billionaires and their assessment of reasonably calculated P/E you might want to consider Buffets assessment to close almost the entire BYD position at a P/E of 50.
- panick21_ 4y agoBYD and Tesla are not same company. And Tesla despite its growth numbers: > P/E ratio as of December 2022 (TTM): 38.2 Also analysis on P/E is very flawed in general and even more so with growing companies.
- lawn 4y ago> And you know what that is? I hope you are a billionaire. Implying that your opinions are only valid if you're a billionaire, and that all billionaires have valid opinions?
- rajbot 4y agoAfter this week’s share price drop, Tesla’s P/E ratio fell to 42 (was 50 last week) Contrast that to other car makers like Ford with a P/E ratio of 5 or GM with P/E of 6 Or contrast that with tech stocks like Google with a P/E of 18 or Apple with a P/E of 21. Exxon’s P/E ratio is 8.71 Why is Tesla stock valued so highly, with a P/E ratio an order of magnitude higher than other car companies and twice that of Apple?
- gorbypark 4y agoIn theory, Tesla’s stock is valued so high because of expectations of future earnings. It is however hard to say exactly how much is actual expectations versus “hype” and momentum. We are in a exceptional period of time in regards to how some stocks are valued which I think will be studied in textbooks of the future. Ford and GM are behemoths which realistically don’t have much room to grow their market share/revenues very much. A win for them is not being eaten alive by competitors. That being said, Tesla’s valuation (especially at its peak) was so high they basically are/were valued at at level where the “expectations” of the market is that they’d be the only vehicle manufacturer left on earth who will nearly capture the entire market. I think most will agree that is pretty far fetched and a lot has to do with hype/inflation/momentum/FOMO (it always goes up!).
- cypress66 4y agoTheir profit margin is also a huge factor. > Nikkei Asia’s analysis shows Tesla made $9,570 per vehicle during Q3, enough to make Tesla more profitable per vehicle than any other manufacturer on the planet. However, the report states this is unconfirmed. Toyota made only around $1,200 per vehicle. Basically investors see Tesla as the future Apple of cars.
- boyka 4y ago10k is still half of recently re-IPOd Porsche profit per car though. That probably doesn't explain the majority of their valuation. Especially given that Porsche are similarly priced [0] and don't have revenue from CO2 certificate sales which are 20% of Tesla profits [1]. https://fred-lavery.porschedealer.com/how-much-does-a-porsche-cost/ https://fred-lavery.porschedealer.com/how-much-does-a-porsch... [0] https://carboncredits.com/tesla-regulatory-carbon-credit-sales-jumps-116/ https://carboncredits.com/tesla-regulatory-carbon-credit-sal... [1]