4 ms·
Synthesizers are musical instruments, which means they have a control part and a sound generating part. Because they are electronic, synthesizers can decouple t
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
Synthesizers are musical instruments, which means they have a control part and a sound generating part. Because they are electronic, synthesizers can decouple these to a greater degree than acoustic instruments. That's why you can play any MIDI-controllable synth using a Yamaha EWI (a wind-driven controller) or a touchpad or a capacitative sensing service or a Haaken Continuum or or the pads on an Ableton Live surface or, yes, a MIDI keyboard.
Pianos are a very specific type of instrument in that they have fixed pitches (compared with any non-fretted string instrument, the tuba or the human voice). MIDI has many assumptions built into it that are derived from the way pianos work, which means that using it in contexts where you want the sort of control not possible on a piano is ... challenging. One obvious example is playing something in a way closer to what you can do on a guitar: MIDI has no real way of representing the sorts of control a guitar player has access to. That said, people have tried, and the best systems are quite good, although they tend to subvert MIDI semantics and just use the syntax of the protocol.
- Gordonjcp 4y agoYou've got different ways of adding expression to your playing with a synthesizer, not least of which being the traditional design of having a roughly coffee-table sized control panel covered in knobs. Why limit yourself to trying to make it work like a guitar or a saxophone? The Yamaha EWI is a lot of fun to play, but I don't really see what it adds. You can add a bit of expression to relatively crappy samples, or to some unconvincing physical modelling synthesis of a woodwind instrument, but it's never going to fool anyone. You can use it to drive other parameters on a more "conventional" (by which I mean, creating artificial sounds rather than attempting to emulate acoustic instruments) synthesizer, I guess, but how much does that really help?
- singingfish 4y agoI would just like to point out that an EWI can in no way reproduce a real woodwind instrument. That's because woodwinds rely to varying degrees on vocal tract resonance and other properties of the airstream. I occasionally think about how an EEG-like array of electrodes around the throat could reproduce this but lack expertise in understanding how that might happen or if it was even possible. Anyway it makes the EWI experience really disapointing for me compared to playing a real saxophone especially the big grunt that articulating and intonating a baritone sax can produce, and the totally hammed up in your face emotionality possible on the soprano sax.