4 ms·
> according to the musical disposition of that day, he was generations behind it”. He used forms – particularly the fugue – that were unfashionable in the early
by kazinator 4y ago
> according to the musical disposition of that day, he was generations behind it”. He used forms – particularly the fugue – that were unfashionable in the early 18th century.
All the music from the Bach era (1680s to 1750s) that is emphasized today has a great deal in common with J. S. Bach. Bach is just a cut better at it.
Bach didn't just write fugues, and he gave them fun preludes when he did.
From a historic perspective, Bach's music cannot be called anachronistic w.r.t. his period, when taken together with other music from the period which survives.
Hey, look, these three guys were 1685 babies:
J.S. Bach: 1685 - 1750
Scarlatti: 1685 - 1757
Handel: 1685 - 1759
A little senior:
Vivaldi: 1679 - 1741
Telemann: 1681 - 1767
Lol, everyone I can think of off the top of my head is clustered around 1680.
If one of them made old, unfashionable music, they all must have.
- jacquesm 4y agoThat music will be played and played long after our societies are dust and forgotten.
- dj_mc_merlin 4y agoNot necessarily? It's survived some 350 years, which is pretty long as far as music is concerned, but that's because our society places importance on this music. If our societies turn to dust, our inheritors might not necessarily be so infatuated with it. They also could be, much like Greek philosophers have been a fascination in the Western world for thousands of years, but there's no rule saying that people will enjoy classical music forever. Plenty of great things die out or just grow out of fashion. If you're talking about the music being preserved and able to be played in the future, then sure, but the same thing could be said of Shakira.
- jacquesm 4y ago> that's because our society places importance on this music It had already almost been lost. > If our societies turn to dust, our inheritors might not necessarily be so infatuated with it. Maybe. Every generation new people seem to discover Bach and fall in love. > the same thing could be said of Shakira Yes, but Shakira's music does not strike me as timeless. Of course only time will tell...
- pclmulqdq 4y agoRameau, who had a pretty different style from Bach (taking after Couperin and the French style) was 1683.
- coldtea 4y ago>If one of them made old, unfashionable music, they all must have By what logic? Did all use the same forms, in he same manner?
- prvc 4y ago>If one of them made old, unfashionable music, they all must have. Yes, he took the Gould quote out of context, which was in reference to the latter part of Bach's career. Interestingly, JSB parodied Style Galante music in Book II of the WTK here and there, for example in the B major Prelude.
- isaacfrond 4y agoVivaldi is born in 1678