4 ms·
>In this case, they're trying to get their own law ruled unconstitutional so that SCOTUS will have to agree that the TX abortion law is, too. I dont think that
by s1artibartfast 4y ago
>In this case, they're trying to get their own law ruled unconstitutional so that SCOTUS will have to agree that the TX abortion law is, too.
I dont think that is true. The SCOTUS didn't rule on the constitutionality of Texas's citizen enforcement.
>The U.S. Supreme Court's ruling in Whole Woman's Health v. Jackson, leaves abortion providers without any possible defendants to sue in a federal pre-enforcement lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of SB 8, because there are no state officials charged with enforcing the law.[1]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_Heartbeat_Act#Whole_Woman's_Health_v._Jackson https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_Heartbeat_Act#Whole_Woma...
- dragonwriter 4y ago> > In this case, they’re trying to get their own law ruled unconstitutional so that SCOTUS will have to agree that the TX abortion law is, too. > I dont think that is true. It was approximately true when the law was adopted, before Roe was struck down. Specifically, they were trying to present a situation where the Court would either be forced to rule that the mechanism the Texas law used to try to avoid federal court review of the substance by calling it something other than state action would be ruled as not serving that purpose, or states would be free to do whatever they want by the same method, including things that judges that preferred avoiding reaching the merits of the Texas case given Roe would not approve of. With Roe overturned, that fork no longer works to protect abortion rights, but that was the (fairly overt) purpose of the law. And it still works on other things, and other states have either adopted or discussed using the Texas mode to attack other rights which remain federally protected that California would have the same issue with by the same means Texas used on abortion, so the basic concern is still active even if the particular issue is less so.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI think my point was that California's attempt was Dead on Arrival from a strategic perspective because it required its opponents to seek preemptive relief to force the SCOTUS to apply the law equally (or expose hypocrisy) . This is something that the opponents could simply sidestep by not challenging it preemptively, and waiting to challenge it later. The California Strategy only makes sense from the PR perspective because so many people erroneously believe that the SB8 ruling found the law constitutional, when in fact the actual ruling was that constitutional challenges needed to proceed at a later date. With that said, I do believe citizen enforcement is problematic in both cases, as well as the less discussed precedent of environmental regulations.