2 ms·
States encouraging individuals to enforce the law is highly problematic for several reasons, but primarily because it avoids pre-enforcement challenges. When i
by s1artibartfast 4y ago
States encouraging individuals to enforce the law is highly problematic for several reasons, but primarily because it avoids pre-enforcement challenges.
When it came to abortion and Texas' SB8 ( Whole Woman's Health v. Jackson), the problem was that there was no State representative responsible for enforcing the law that could be pre-emptively sued to prevent it being used.
It seems that the California law was ill-conceived to test this aspect of citizen enforcement, because the challengers did not seek pre-enforcement relief, but maybe I missed that aspect of the ruling. I would be interested to hear the thoughts of others.
Here is the ruling I was able to find, Ironically from a much better sourced, if more biased NRA article.
https://shared.nrapvf.org/sharedmedia/1510684/2064261_2019-03-29-order-granting-plaintiffs_-msj.pdf https://shared.nrapvf.org/sharedmedia/1510684/2064261_2019-0...