8 ms·
The future our grandchildren deserve
- mc32 4y agoProvide education, jobs and contraceptives to those with high reproduction rates —pop growth will slow thus putting less pressure on the environment (see China vs India). Less encroachment on nature, less sequestered carbon released. Help to modernize poor countries' energy grids and electrify the hinterlands. Get people in rich countries to give up cheap disposable stuff and give up energy consuming entertainment (international travel, etc) and get them to live frugally, obviously including the superwealthy. Don’t celebrate becoming rich. Don’t celebrate consumerism. Put down tiktok, put down instagram. Practice secular (or religious) asceticism and be comfortable with that. Oh, wait, people don't want to actually do what will work.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y ago<< Get people in rich countries to give up cheap disposable stuff and give up energy consuming entertainment (international travel, etc) and get them to live frugally, obviously including the superwealthy. You may be onto something. It is fine to pay lip service to this ideal in an abstract, but as Covid pandemic has shown, politicians will drop the facade of masks at the drop of a hat if they are personally inconvenienced ( CA comes to mind, but it is not an isolated incident ). At the end of the day, I want the rules to be applied equally, but they are not ( and likely never will be ). Come to think of it, and it is going to sound truly awful, why do we devote so much energy to other countries instead of focusing on what is happening in US? Wouldn't it be a time better spent to make US ( the land I and Gates live in ) a better place? << Don’t celebrate consumerism. I am not sure you appreciate how much US economy relies on this. << Put down tiktok, put down instagram. No argument from me. << Practice secular (or religious) asceticism and be comfortable with that. Eh. I think the question that comes to mind is why. I am not trying to be combative, but why do you think it is reasonable to impose your vision upon others.
- mc32 4y agoEndless growth is not attainable on this Earth. Japan hit the inflection point some decades ago. They are doing alright. They still innovate. In some respects it's stagnant, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. It does mean that offspring will not perpetually think "they will (potentially) earn more than their parents" and that's okay. We need to accelerate this in places that are still growing, slow them down but also modernize them. Asceticism may not be necessary, but it is a target. Like many targets it's one one may miss, but in going for it it reduces footprint.
- peteradio 4y agoWhen I google asceticism I see a picture of a monk with rib bones sticking out, not too dissimilar from a mummy.
- ctoth 4y agoIt is an excellent thing, then, that we are not simply stuck on this Earth.
- tmtvl 4y agoFor practical purposes we are. At least for the foreseeable future. Yes, we can support a handful of people on a space station for a few months, but that's no long-term solution. Unless you mean we could simply run like Logan, which, while indeed a possible solution, is not a particularly attractive solution.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y ago<<Unless you mean we could simply run like Logan, which, while indeed a possible solution, is not a particularly attractive solution. I will admit that I think Bill Burr put the issue of overpopulation in mainstream consciousness and I can't deny that I worry that the solutions ( or forced by circumstances -- war comes to mind ) proposed are unlikely to be pleasant for the globe as a whole. Still, in parent's defense, I am not seeing that stance in my interpretation of that post.
- slothtrop 4y agoThe first paragraph is all you need. Instances of consumerism that are a problem can be dampened through tax or other means, but it's a moot point because environmental encroachment scales with demand. If demand is stagnant (because the population is, and has already been lifted out of poverty enough to demand things), then there's no question of sustainability for basically anything, except certain finite resources. No one's going to care about the impact of travel if there 3-4 billion people instead of 8 billion.
- mc32 4y agoEven if we got the world pop to 1960s levels we cannot indefinitely consume and defile the environment. We need to exercise restraint despite our capacity or ability to do things.
- slothtrop 4y agoPeople don't have an infinite capacity for consumption. That's why 1st world countries use immigration policy to boost the GDP (a reflection of consumption). Between gains in efficiency, renewables, etc the "need for restraint" has a ton of legroom if the population simply does not grow. The rise in emissions from the last couple of decades is largely owing to growing demand from China and other countries with an emerging middle class. Vaclav Smil makes this clear in a few of his books (e.g. How The World Really Works), you don't need to rely on conjecture if you just look at the numbers. Since it would be inhumane to demand that the 3rd world not make use of fossil fuels to improve their quality of life (including for instance ammonia for fertilizer), we can expect demand to continue growing. There's no reason to believe that, assuming a stable population, we would be relegated to conditions of asceticism in order to keep the planet habitable.
- Xelynega 4y agoIt's all you "need" from one perspective, but if the topic is "the future our grandchildren deserve" than a criticism of consumerism that seeks to eradicate it is relevant(IMO) and isn't equivalent to minimizing it with "tax and other means".
- lo_zamoyski 4y ago> Provide [...] contraceptives to those with high reproduction rates This we should not do. First, Malthusians have always been wrong and I claim will continue to be wrong. Second, contraception encourages declining birth rates and low birth rates are destructive to societies. Third, contraception is intrinsically immoral because it frustrates and perverts the function of the sexual faculties (it's the analogue of bulimia). Fourth, contraception has the psychological effect of divorcing the intrinsic function of sexual intercourse from pleasure which results in a hedonistic view of sex, the objectification of people, and exploitative attitudes, among others. Not exactly a winning recipe for a healthy society. I would also emphasize the distinction between promotion and permissiveness; I am arguing against promotion only and a culture that normalizes its use as opposed to one that merely tolerates it. > (see China vs India) China is below replacement (1.70). India is at replacement (2.18). Fertility rates are low everywhere except Africa. I think Africa has had enough of philanthropic "interventions". > Practice secular (or religious) asceticism and be comfortable with that. You don't need to be ascetic. You just need to avoid prodigality and the consumerist vice of excessive acquisitiveness. Where clothing is concerned, prefer high quality, classic styles that last, even when they cost more upfront. Don't live beyond your means. Don't buy stuff you don't need or doesn't contribute real value to your life. Don't buy impulsively (unless you want to fill your garage with garbage). All these are just common sense.
- potatochup 4y ago> Fourth, contraception has the psychological effect of divorcing the intrinsic function of sexual intercourse from pleasure which results in a hedonistic view of sex There is so much more to sex than procreation or pure hedonistic desire. What about infertile couples? Should they just not have sex because there is no hope of procreation? Gay couples?
- illuminerdy 4y ago
- dgf49 4y agoWhat´s wrong with you?
- usedtoprog 4y ago
- dgf49 4y agoNothing - I don`t blame others for any conspiracy but try to do my best where I can instead. Thanks for asking.
- dang 4y agoPlease don't respond to a bad comment by breaking the site guidelines yourself. That only makes everything worse. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dang 4y agoWe've banned this account because it has been using HN primarily for ideological battle. That's not allowed here, regardless of which flavor your favor. It's not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for. Past explanations here: https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comment&storyText=false&prefix=false&page=0&query=primarily%20test%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme.... Please don't create accounts to break HN's rules with.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- stefantalpalaru 4y ago
- fuckHNtho 4y ago
- dang 4y agoCome on you guys, knock it off.
- 4qz 4y ago
- dang 4y agoI'm defending Hacker News, it's really just that simple. Can you please use the site as intended? It's only worth anything if it's interesting, and vandalizing it is just a way to destroy it for everybody. I'm sure you don't leave campfires burning in dry forests or toss your trash on the street. Why do the equivalent here? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- bena 4y agoIf I'm going to be frank here, it's because you've already allowed the trash in the street. The allowance of certain subjects to be discussed, combined with some of the moderation policies ostensibly designed to quell flamewars, have given a certain segment of the population a license to think they can act like this. You bring the hammer down just as hard on people also trying to defend HN. And since those people want to play within the rules, those who don't essentially take over. Because they have the time to do so. And they all fit a certain mold.
- dang 4y agoI have little to no idea what you're referring to. I'd need to see specific links to what you're talking about.
- 4qz 4y ago
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoEh. I am going to bite. Why should we do that?
- dang 4y agoPlease don't respond to a bad comment by breaking the site guidelines yourself. That only makes everything worse. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dang 4y agoWe've banned this account for posting flamebait and/or unsubstantive comments. Please don't create accounts to break HN's rules with. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- programmarchy 4y agoImprovements upon math education, ultrasound technology, and construction technology all sound like very reasonable, practical goals. Perhaps the most radical goal is gene therapy, but also the most exciting and sci-fi.
- jeffbee 4y ago> construction technology Isn't it a bit odd to present a chart that shows buildings to be the least-important component of the problem, and then go on to talk about only that small component? Especially saying "Buildings are a surprisingly large source of emissions" when the graphic just above that sentence shows that buildings are not.
- itishappy 4y agoThe previous 12 paragraphs of the building section were dedicated to addressing exactly that. He speaks about the work being done in the agriculture and energy sectors. "Surprisingly large" does not imply it's the largest.
- Xelynega 4y agoMath education: Microsoft hires hundreds of math graduates yearly, an excess of those would be beneficial to Microsofts bottom line. Ultrasound technology: Microsoft has a "digital health" department that would benefit similarly from more graduates in the field. Construction technology: Microsoft has existing partnerships in construction technology, and would similarly benefit from an increased number of graduates in the field driving down wages. Why are these things that benefit Microsoft the "future our grandchildren deserve"? It seems to be a pretty biased view of the future.
- yCombLinks 4y agoYou're just bashing everything related to Gates/Microsoft in the whole thread, you look crazy.
- rs_rs_rs_rs_rs 4y agoBill Gates does not care about the future of your grandchildren, he only cares about his public image.
- dang 4y agoMaybe so, but please don't post unsubstantive comments to Hacker News.
- stephc_int13 4y agoAm I the only one growing suspicious of this since the SBF/FTX effective altruism turned out to be a front to masquerade a good old Ponzi? I don't think the Gates foundation is a Ponzi, but I am not entirely convinced that all of this is really what is advertised. Are there any reliable (external and independent) audits for charities?
- 23B1 4y agoThe IRS. Which, as I'm sure you're aware, is doing a great job of it. https://archive.vn/n1AQy https://archive.vn/n1AQy
- akprasad 4y agoThe closest I can think of is GiveWell [1], but it is part of the broader effective altruism movement, so perhaps it won't meet your bar. [1]: https://www.givewell.org https://www.givewell.org
- stephc_int13 4y agoClearly not.
- doitLP 4y agoAny extremely well-funded private initiative that seeks to influence governments should be watched closely.
- godelski 4y agoIt's also possible that things start with good intentions and get taken advantage of. I'm just saying that it is possible MacAskill got conned along with everyone else that invested and used FTX. I don't want to stop you from being skeptical (please do), but I want to suggest that there are alternative and mundane explanations for things. It helps us actually solve issues with the system instead of promoting conspiracy. People can be doing both good and bad at the same time. People are often well intended and end up doing wrong (quite common actually. I guarantee both of us do this). As for the Gates Foundation, it is also possible that Gates is trying to use the money most effectively to solve problems he thinks is important, while not having a good grasp on what is important to the median person, while also getting major tax benefits, and is influencing the government (it is possible that Gates's interests may not align with the public's and thus that influence is harmful despite them thinking it is beneficial).
- stephc_int13 4y agoMoney is only a proxy for power, because it is easier to measure and is fungible. But talking about inequalities, especially related to political systems and redistribution, we should be taking a closer look at power because this is, always, ultimately, the real thing. Money can be kind of boring when you have too much of it, power has a longer lasting appeal, and for some people, the appetite is bottomless. I tend to be wary of power-hungry types. Also, contrary to wealth, power is a zero sum game, and the size of the pie is directly defined by the demography.
- SuoDuanDao 4y ago>contrary to wealth, power is a zero sum game Not sure I agree. Power over other people maybe, but there is also power to affect the nonhuman environment. A modern farmer's power to alter his immediate environment is similar to a feudal lord's.
- stephc_int13 4y agoThis is semantic counter-argument. I agree that Power, as a word, is a bit vague. And to some extent I also agree that power tends to not be self-limiting to other humans, we tend to use it over animals and nature.
- 29athrowaway 4y agoThere are dimensions of power. A corn farmer is ruled by the government, the market, the seed corporations, the fossil fuel industry, the different machinery manufacturers (vendor lock-in), the banks, etc.
- syntheweave 4y agoOr alternately, the anecdote of Alexander and Diogenes. Wherever you voluntarily become the student, the teacher has the power - even if the teacher has nothing material. The materialistic power ladders are just visible and highly competitive. People who don't want to bother with it usually gravitate towards something more esoteric.
- alfor 4y ago
- janef0421 4y agoThis seems overly focused on novel technologies, which I think is a grave mistake. Humans have been developing technology for millennia, and many of these technologies would be very useful in the modern age. For instance, the Persians created wind cooling towers, which can be used to effectively cool indoor spaces without using large amounts of energy.
- RunSet 4y agoOur grandchildren deserve a future without the vendor lock-in and anticompetitive behavior that gave Bill Gates the fortune he is currently using to attempt to whitewash his legacy.
- kulahan 4y agoI hate how nobody can have a change of heart and do an INSANE AMOUNT OF GOOD without some goofball constantly needing to feel cool by pointing out they weren't always doing good stuff. Who gives a shit about anticompetitive behavior in comparison to saving human lives from a preventable disease? Talk about missing the forest for the trees. It's so miserable to talk about positive actions these days, because it's verboten to focus on that when there are negatives to point out.
- swader999 4y agoYeah, well there are those flight logs that tell a pretty disgraceful story.
- darkwater 4y agoSorry, never heard of this. What do you mean?
- swader999 4y agoThe Epstein plane that was used to shuttle underage kids to his island and elites that were served by them has Bill Gates name listed. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/12/business/jeffrey-epstein-bill-gates.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/12/business/jeffrey-epstein-...
- lordfrito 4y agoI'm not a Gates fan or apologist, but apparently the links between Gates and Epstein are weak at best. It seems he flew with Epstein once, in the context of business/philanthropy. [1] I get the impression Epstein met a ton of who's-whos, which makes it easy to generate a ton of click-baity "guilt by association" type articles. I.E. "Hey did you know that <controversial public figure> <met/dined/visited/flew> with Epstein?". Guaranteed views, little substance. Again, not a Gates fan. [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-factcheck-bill-gates-epstein-island/false-claim-bill-gates-traveled-to-epsteins-island-multiple-times-idUSKBN22R2C4 https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-factcheck-bill-gates-epst...
- thesagan 4y agoWe should be thankful for people like Mr. Gates, he sets an example we should follow. Role models are powerful, and he is among the top.
- pstuart 4y agoIn philanthropy, yes. His personal conduct appears to not be so admirable.
- pyuser583 4y agoHow important is that?
- Xelynega 4y agoConsidering that everyone has a chance to make personal decisions, but most people won't have the opportunity to make philanthropic decisions, can you see why the personal decisions someone makes are really the only thing important to get a measure of how good a role model they are.
- yunwal 4y agoIt's very important in that by positioning his foundation as the largest global health provider in the world he could easily use it for nefarious or selfish means if he desired. It's very difficult to judge the motivation for Gates Foundation work on the foundation alone (for the same reason it's tough to judge the value of a VC-based startup by it's initial pricing scheme), so it's reasonable to look at his personal conduct to understand his motivations. I for one, am not super happy that half of the third world relies on a child rapists' friend to get their Malaria vaccines.
- pseudo0 4y ago> Our work on education goes back to the foundation’s earliest days, and our focus on improving math skills goes back almost as far. Although there are many factors that affect a student’s trajectory, the evidence shows that it’s extremely important for them to succeed in math. For example, those who pass Algebra I by ninth grade are twice as likely to graduate from high school and more likely to go on to college, get a bachelor’s degree, and go on to a high-paying career. And those who don’t complete Algebra I have just a one-in-five chance of graduating from high school. This looks a lot like correlation/causation confusion. Inability to understand basic algebra seems like it would be strongly correlated with learning disabilities or significantly below average IQ. Getting more students to squeak by with a barely passing grade won't fix those underlying issues.
- Xelynega 4y agoIt also looks like conflating "success" with "high-paying career". Most people would probably consider a high paying career success, but the idea that we're not even questioning that assumption when talking about children's education shows how it gets propogated.
- thefounder 4y agoI wonder, why would you like your children to pursue a low paying career unless you are already relatively rich/financially "stable"? It's a great adventure to live on the edge when you are young but unfortunately we are not forever young. Add a wife, kids and a low paying job and the story gets dramatic. Not to mention any health issue.
- Xelynega 4y agoThis isn't an article titled "what your kids should pursue to live comfortably", it's called "the future our grandchildren deserve". Having the ability to pursue a "low paying career" when you're not financially stable is the future our grandchildren deserve, not just a future where some of them get high paying careers.
- 4y ago
- RickJWagner 4y agoThere's a lot of good news in that post. I'm glad Gates is using his money for good. I think some of what he's doing is one-foot-on-the-gas-other-on-the-brake, though. For instance, as traditional family structure deteriorates, grades decline. It's sub-optimal to concentrate on math and reading until we shore up families (and that's hard to do.)
- MaximilianKohlr 4y agoI'm not a fan of this list. Other than climate change, I do not see it addressing the biggest issues of our time. Not a single mention of the exponential increase in chronic disease which is leading us down the path of Idiocracy. Having the main focus on infant/child mortality seems misguided. Perhaps in your bubble you're surrounded by intelligent and competent people. Out here in the real world the vast majority of people are extremely unintelligent, incompetent, and sickly. And it pervades all professions. There is nearly no such thing as a "professional" anymore; just a bunch of bumbling fools trying to make it through their day and get back home. Replacing all professions with AI should be a primary goal, so that we no longer have our lives in the hands of incompetent, sickly, poorly functioning people. Overwhelmingly I see the most intelligent & healthy people not having kids, and the most unintelligent, sickly people making more copies of themselves.