4 ms·
> Sure I see a lot of hand waving here about that, but this community is notably not necessarily the most diverse HN, like the American tech industry in genera
by rayiner 4y ago
> Sure I see a lot of hand waving here about that, but this community is notably not necessarily the most diverse
HN, like the American tech industry in general, is almost certainly more diverse than the Stanford administration and faculty. Moreover, diversity in HN is organic. Folks on here may happen to be Laotian American (or even Laotian—HN is international). Nobody selected them for inclusion in the community.
By contrast, diversity at Stanford, especially among faculty, is carefully curated by the overwhelmingly white faculty. Your average immigrant from a former colony may not care about eliminating “colonial language.” But the white Stanford faculty wouldn’t hire those immigrants into the cultural studies department of the university. You’re much more likely to get a job at Stanford by writing papers on how colonial terms “cause harm.”
The faculty system and widespread use of race and nationality conscious hiring gives white people at elite universities tremendous power. There’s few other organizations where the white leadership gets to hand pick any minority representation based on its own ideological priors.
- eclipxe 4y agoReally really bad take. Really bad.
- rayiner 4y agoIt’s not only a correct take, but a critical one. Elite universities taking over the discourse has the perverse effect of diverting political and cultural power from minority groups to elite whites (along with a small group of elite minorities hand picked by those whites).
- tsimionescu 4y agoThe use of "Latinx" is one of the best examples of just how disconnected these people are from those they seek to represent/protect.
- rayiner 4y agoThe discourse around policing is another one. Eric Adams addressed this in his recent op ed on moving the Democratic primary to South Carolina: https://www.cnn.com/2022/12/13/opinions/democrats-2024-primary-calendar-black-voters-adams/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2022/12/13/opinions/democrats-2024-prima.... Adams writes that the move could help “address[] the concerns of all people of color and working-class people, many of whom feel the party has misrepresented their beliefs.” Adams is talking about white political elites rather than white academics, but as Elizabeth Warren illustrates, there’s a lot of ideological overlap between the two.
- MockObject 4y ago"Latinx" also proves that the motivation is grounded in bad faith, for if someone were truly offended by the gendered term "Latino", they would surely use "Latin" instead of creating an ostentatious monstrosity that is totally alien to both English and Spanish.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoOr, like the people who came up with :-), lmfao, wtf, l33t, pwned!!!111!1 and similar internet shortcuts, they were communicating in a text only medium and didn't need to worry about pronunciation?
- TeMPOraL 4y agoWait, how does the effort ostensibly against "elite whites" and in support of minorities, that looks exactly like many similar efforts by minorities and their advocates aimed against "elite whites" (or white men in general), ends up being "diverting political and cultural power from minority group to elite whites"? I'm not saying you're wrong, but I'm completely baffled by how you've managed to reach the opposite conclusion to the one I'd expect.
- tsimionescu 4y agoIt's because this is simply an exercise in wasting resources while looking progressive. Instead of advocating to actually help discriminated people in important ways (pressure on wages, blind interviews to combat unfair hiring, unionization to help solidify such practices, and many other real social changes), they are pushing bullshit changes that don't help anyone in the affected groups, but make them feel better and give them a new lever to use against ideological opponents.
- MockObject 4y agoThe project of identity politics is based in the elite classes, and is used to further alienate the working classes, who lack the time or interest to keep up with the quickly-evolving shibboleths, that often contradict their lived experiences. Identity politics is gleefully adopted by the elite institutions, and the base of resistance against it is working class.
- rayiner 4y agoWho are “white elites?” Harvard professors or Wall Street executives with BLM lawn signs might demonize Trump or Elon Musk as “white elites.” They may even mean people who aren’t even all that elite, such as small business owners who support Trump. But they don’t identify with the term themselves, even though they undoubtedly fit the bill. Thus, advocacy that purports to attack “white elites” can nonetheless take power away from minorities and give it to elite whites. Historically, advocacy on behalf of minority groups was done by minority groups themselves. For example, the black civil rights movement was closely tied to black churches. Today, such advocacy has been increasingly taken over by white elites. BLM is funded mainly by affluent white people. Ibram Kendi was selected to be a professor at BU by an overwhelmingly white faculty. Or to use another example, consider MacKenzie Bezos giving tens of millions of dollars to “AAPI” activist organizations. Those groups don’t answer to recent Chinese and Bangladeshi immigrants in Queens. Their whole incentive structure is oriented toward appealing to rich white people like MacKenzie Bezos. The net effect of that is that much advocacy that claims to empower minorities actually ends up taking power away from minorities and empowering white elites. You can see this clearly in New York City, where white people in Manhattan strongly opposed Eric Adams, and so did minority activist groups. But actual minorities overwhelmingly voted for him. But in many, many cases, minorities don’t get to directly weigh in like that. Instead white-dominated institutions act on behalf of minorities, based on their own ideological preferences.
- etrevino 4y agoCan you explain why it's bad?
- ModernMech 4y ago> HN, like the American tech industry in general, is almost certainly more diverse than the Stanford administration and faculty. The point I was trying to make was that HN has some very real and very wide ideological blindspots. It's true what you say that there are many viewpoints here on HN, but they aren't all uniformly represented. That said, the commentariat here is also self selected, so not necessarily representative of the general population. > By contrast, diversity at Stanford, especially among faculty, is carefully curated by the overwhelmingly white faculty. That may be true, but at the same time there are more stakeholders who have input into initiatives like these. > But the white Stanford faculty wouldn’t hire those immigrants into the cultural studies department of the university. You’re much more likely to get a job at Stanford by writing papers on how colonial terms “cause harm.” Do you have evidence that such people didn't have input or their input wasn't allowed? Or are you just speculating to make a point? You seem fixated on white Stanford faculty, but it's not clear that the linked list is even a product of the faculty, it seems like it's a product of a committee of the IT department. It seems to me like you just have some ideological things to say about Stanford faculty without really addressing the facts on the ground re: this list.
- crackercrews 4y ago
- ModernMech 4y ago> If you can't even make your point without repeatedly using one of the forbidden words by accident, then perhaps the forbidden word list is too broad. I'm not accidentally using forbidden words, I'm intentionally using words that are not in fact forbidden, because no one (especially Stanford) has forbidden anyone from saying them. Stanford doesn't police my language, I can use whatever words I want. If someone is offended by my words they can tell me. But Stanford is not in the same position I am, posting on an internet forum. They are a corporate entity looking to manage their brand. I'm going to keep making this point, because so far no one so far has really engaged with it, but this is no different than Coke having an internal style guide for how their logo can be used and in what contexts.
- onetimeusename 4y agoThe current administration at Stanford seems fairly diverse but over-represented by Jewish people[1]. I am not disagreeing that people in other global communities might not care about these issues. Some people abroad are surprisingly attuned to US political wokeness though. I imagine if you are white you might compensate for that by being more woke to protect your career. This is, after all, still a majority white country in spite of the admissions policies of elite universities and the racial makeup of tv commercials and the immigration policies. So that may reflect on staff hired decades ago. Although I believe elite universities will begin to change the racial makeup of their staff and students more aggressively since the status quo is indefensible. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Stanford_University_people#Stanford_office https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Stanford_University_pe...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 4y agoThat doesn’t address the problem I’m talking about, since the process of “changing the racial makeup” of these institutions is going to be done by existing white faculty and administration hand picking the minorities that appeal to elite whites. As they say, you can’t dismantle the master’s house with the master’s tools. We shouldn’t be looking to academics hand picked by white elites to figure out how to police minority communities, or what words to use or not use with respect to minorities, etc. Elite universities are inherently bad vehicles for leading the discourse on those issues.
- ModernMech 4y agoYour conception of how academic hiring works is wrong. Even if it started as you describe, the new minority hires will have a vote on the next hire equal to than of the more senior faculty. If they find themselves on the hiring committee, they have even more power to shape the hiring process. Hiring committees also include a member outside of the department, so there is external input as well. This system has shown to increase diversity in academic departments, and it’s not something the white faculty can conspire to keep under control. The issue is that progress is slow for two reasons: 1) positions open up rarely and 2) the hiring pool is limited. These are issues that are being worked on, but progress is being made.