5 ms·
If they really cared about this niche market I think they would need to rethink the problem. A lot of the important rendering is done in rendering farms (AKA cl
by gumby 4y ago
If they really cared about this niche market I think they would need to rethink the problem. A lot of the important rendering is done in rendering farms (AKA cloud these days).
So build a two part design: a rack form factor with a storage fabric and a lot of processors combined with a super mac studio for display and control, all connected with 10 GB. The investment would be immense compared to the market (not just in hardware but with the end user tools) and hard for most companies to develop software for.
The only upside for Apple with this approach would be that their cloud back end could benefit from this development.
It's the classic Innovator's Dilemma: I don't see this market being worth investing in at all for a company like Apple.
- ChildOfChaos 4y agoThey don't have much of a cloud back end at the moment though do they? Thought they used Google.
- rmorey 4y agoApple runs their own DC’s for some things, but is also primarily an Azure customer, IIRC
- scarface74 4y agoYou overestimate how much work is actually done in the cloud. While I can’t speak definitely how much rendering is done in the cloud, I can speak to how much general IT spend is done in the cloud from someone who should know… https://accelerationeconomy.com/cloud/amazon-shocker-ceo-jassy-says-cloud-less-than-5-of-all-it-spending/ https://accelerationeconomy.com/cloud/amazon-shocker-ceo-jas... Disclaimer:Jassy is my skip*7 manager
- gumby 4y agoNot an external cloud, but those pixar movies are generated by big server farms. The cloud just resides in pixar's buildings, not amazon's. And that's the point of the cloud metaphor (starting from the original Internet protocols paper from Cerf et al): you don't care. It doesn't mean "a computer somebody else owns"
- scarface74 4y agoThat’s no more “the cloud” in modern parlance than the two servers sitting in a server room and arms throw away that we accessed via a green screen in the 90s,
- dragonwriter 4y agoAssuming that thet use dynamic provision of services abstracted from physical servers, that is exactly the modern definition of “private cloud”. You seem to be confusing cloud with “public cloud”, but private (and hybrid) cloud is very much a part of the modern understanding of cloud.
- scarface74 4y agoYou could do that with old IBMs. Does that mean if I have one laptop where I can provision multiple VMs, I’m doing “cloud computing” from my house?
- dagmx 4y agoYou still need high performance and low latency for local rendering so the artist can make interactive changes
- gumby 4y agoYes, but... I think a Studio can do 90% of the lifting, or you could do some server side rendering feeding the results back over a 10 G wired ethernet.
- dagmx 4y agoIt really depends on the shot and the show. If you are relying on the farm to provide interactive rendering , the speed of the connection isn’t an issue. it’s not that much data to send over since studios sync the assets, so you’re usually only needing to sync attribute values and pixel data back and forth. The issue is that you need dedicated cores for it on the farm. When a show is going all out, those farms are saturated for usage. If a lighter asks for interactive use, they’re either waiting or you’re constantly having to reserve systems for them. That wait time is the latency I mean. In which case why not just buy them the higher spec hardware?
- highwaylights 4y agoOr just market bundles of Ultra studios for those customers with some niche zero-conf convenience feature as a hook. Only thing is at that point it makes sense to have either a monster PC somewhere out of sight or cloud resources, so whatever hook they come up with would at least need to appear like it usefully alters the workflow, because it's going to be really expensive relative to an out-of-sight PC. It really begs the question of who the Mac Pro is really for anymore? If you need that amount of power you're probably better off with a MacBook and an external compute resource like above, or even just an eGPU (I know, the ARM chips don't support them, but you could just buy used Intel SKUs in a pinch).
- zozbot234 4y agoThe old Intel Mac Pro is available in rack-friendly form factor. Alternately, people have racked Mac Minis, so I think Mac Studio's would be mostly the same?
- ascagnel_ 4y agoA quick search came up with 3U plates that will allow you to mount two Mac Studios. https://www.macrumors.com/2022/09/06/sonnet-mac-studio-rack-mount/ https://www.macrumors.com/2022/09/06/sonnet-mac-studio-rack-...