22 ms·
If only there were some agreement or treaty possible in which young workers from neighboring countries could easily (without red tape) come to provide low cost
by gumby 4y ago
If only there were some agreement or treaty possible in which young workers from neighboring countries could easily (without red tape) come to provide low cost labor, and even allow retirees to easily move to lower cost areas.
- dekken_ 4y agoIf there was already adequate housing for everyone then yeah, cause otherwise you're going to make getting housing harder for the countries poor, just look at the cost of living in Paris
- hutzlibu 4y agoWas there really a housing problem, while the UK was still in the EU?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nibbleshifter 4y agoYes, but it had fuck all to do with immigration. The UK's housing issues are largely a housing policy problem. Its not that the UK has a shortage of accommodation units, its largely that the free market rewards property value speculation over actually occupying those accommodation units in areas of high demand, and having actual tenants is seen as a liability. There is an imperial assload of empty residential units across the UK (and especially in London) where the owners are deriving greater value from pure speculation than rent seeking. There's other aspects to the issue than this, but that's one of the bigger issues that could be resolved with policy changes to penalize the fucking absurd practice of keeping properties empty.
- 6510 4y agoEven more radical would be to restore purchase power to a point where one can produce new baby workers domestically. If you've squeezed the life out of working peoples baby budget you just wont have fresh bodies for your own parasitic class to suck the life out of. Should we wonder how their empire got this small?
- ElfinTrousers 4y agoThere's still smaller. Ideally, I'd like to see it, at most, roughly coterminous with the grounds of Buckingham Palace.
- wrycoder 4y agoOne does not simply restore purchasing power. To do that, the society would have to strip out all the nonproductive parasitic layers that accumulate over time, and then redistribute excess wealth. Those actors will resist strongly, so good luck with that.
- 6510 4y agoExacerbation it is then.
- AdrianB1 4y agoIt makes no sense for these young workers to come. I know people from Eastern Europe use to come to work in UK because even the low cost labor was enough for them to get some money for back home, but the neighboring countries have a much higher cost of living than Eastern Europe, so it is economically not attractive. Also moving permanently to UK is not attractive for a bunch of reasons, from weather to weird laws. Did you know more people are arrested yearly in UK for posting online on social media than in Iran?
- nibbleshifter 4y ago> Did you know more people are arrested yearly in UK for posting online on social media than in Iran? This isn't exactly true. The Mal Comms laws are a fucking travesty, but the reporting on them has tended to be wildly inaccurate. Most incidents of "suspected mal comms" are resolved with what's called "words of advice", followed by no further action. Words of Advice happens like so: you call Karen a slag on Facebook, Karen reports you to the cops, the cops are obliged to "do something", so a neighborhood officer swings by and let's you know its been reported, don't do it again, no further action is taken. More serious cases tend to involve an invitation for a voluntary interview, usually resulting in no further action or (rarely) a caution or (even rarer still) the CPS deciding to prosecute. Voluntary interview is a bit of a misnomer - if you refuse to come in for said interview, there is two possible outcomes. Either it gets no further actioned and binned off, or they now have the option to arrest you for the purposes of an interview. Most of the time when someone is actually arrested for "malicious communication" its something high profile and/or they already refused that so called "voluntary interview" and/or they have been repeatedly given said words of advice. Personally I think the UK is a fucking hellscape and a police state, but I find the online commentary about the Malicious Communication laws - especially on primarily American forums - wildly inaccurate.
- AdrianB1 4y agoI was pointing at the Communication Act. It seems that even the Prime Minister is concerned about this: https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/20267545/rishi-sunak-stamp-out-woke-policing-crime/ https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/20267545/rishi-sunak-stamp-out..., so it looks like a real problem.
- ominous 4y agoAlright, let's talk in this way. You mean a sink of human capital that would in the process destroy the social fabric of the neighboring countries by robbing it of their best, while at the same time give no reason for a country's most profitable companies to feel inclined to raise how much they are willing to pay for labor? Or you meant a way to ignore that a country does have a way to make young workers and expand towards attracting outside young workers, while ignoring the reasons the local sources of young workers fail? "socio-political degeneration absorbs and neutralizes a decaying trend of techno-economic advance"? wow, what a great idea.
- time_to_smile 4y agoI'm so glad to hear that your primary concern around immigration is the impact on other countries. Good news! It turns out that while your thesis sounds reasonable it is in fact not the case. Here in the US our two largest immigrant groups are people from Indian and China. It turns out that both of these countries seemed to have benefit greatly from the exchange. While many very talented migrants have chosen to remain in the US, a sizable number of taken the skills and experience they've learned here and brought them back to their home countries. Not only that but during our period of highest immigration, salaries from those very companies hiring the most migrant workers were some of the highest in the world, much higher than typically seen in, for example, the UK. At the same time we've also seen salaries rise in India and China. I'm guessing on seeing that your theoretical concerns don't pan out in the real world you'll likely change your stance on the issue. If not that there must be some other logic I'm missing that is guiding your opinions on the topic.
- nine_zeros 4y agoHistory shows that when goods and people can move around between two regions, both regions prosper. This is exactly what has happened with USA <-> China and India. These are literally the 3 gigantic economies that are growing rapidly today.
- ominous 4y ago
- kkfdkerpoe 4y agoOnly works as a temporary solution. Eventually you'll run out of wage-slaves even if you hire from the entire planet as young people can't afford having children with those salaries. What if shareholders were happy with a bit less money, and companies used that money instead to provide a decent wage? Seems more sustainable to me than mass migration of the working poor.
- jacooper 4y agoBut who's is going to do this? Who's going to push this change? They keep getting even more money every year, and they won't stop just for the good of humanity.
- willcipriano 4y ago> But who's is going to do this? Who's going to push this change? Look around you, the economy is trying to rebalance itself but leaders around the world via central banks and immigration policies are fighting it tooth and nail. Leave it alone and higher wages will follow shortly.
- bakugo 4y agoAh yes, lower wages and higher rents, exactly what every country needs right now.
- VLM 4y agoColonialism with extra steps