10 ms·
No no, I think the majority getting mad, or at the very least myself, see two things: (1) the vast majority of the words on this list do not have the claimed ne
by tsimionescu 4y ago
No no, I think the majority getting mad, or at the very least myself, see two things: (1) the vast majority of the words on this list do not have the claimed negative connotations in the slightest, and should be liberally used in Stanford materials, and (2) if the geniuses who compiled this list are allowed to make it a standard of speech for Stanford materials, it will sooner or later be adopted by many other places looking for a list of "safe words".
The whole thing has to be ridiculed from top to bottom, both for what it's direct stated goals are, but also for fear that it will make its way into more places if it's not nipped in the bud.
Note: some words on the list, such as a several obvious slurs they chose to include, of course must be avoided. Black hat (hacker) or black box or blind review or commited suicide or user (!!!!) or calling a spade a spade or man-in-the-middle or [...] are not among those.
- ModernMech 4y ago> the vast majority of the words on this list do not have the claimed negative connotations in the slightest Sure I see a lot of hand waving here about that, but this community is notably not necessarily the most diverse (edit: by diverse I mean has notable blindspots and well-known biases). For example a lot of people here on HN have no problem using terms like “master” and “slave” in a technological context, but other people have told me those terms make them uncomfortable. I don’t want my students to feel that way so I don’t use those words in a classroom context, even if every single person on HN is okay using them. Maybe we can all appreciate that perhaps the people who wrote this list are in fact expressing a genuine concern about language that is held by others, even if you do not personally see the concern? > it will sooner or later be adopted by many other places looking for a list of "safe words". First, I appreciate the slippery slope, but at this point it’s behind a Stanford login, and is really only addressed to Stanford IT. Then again it says it’s in line with peer institutions so perhaps the slope has already slipped. But even if more people want to do this, so what? It’s their choice. These documents are about others policing their own language, not them policing yours. Your comments about “ridiculing” and “nipping it in the bud” are closer to policing the speech of others than this list is.
- swayvil 4y agoVowels make me uncomfortable (due to an encounter with a quartet of yodelers at an early age). Please refrain.
- coldtea 4y ago>Sure I see a lot of hand waving here about that, but this community is notably not necessarily the most diverse The communities deciding those terms as "potentially harmful" are even less diverse: mostly white, mostly of the aspirational classes, mostly of a certain ideological bent and demographic, with the token social climber members that don't represent their communities thrown in for good measure... It's like the white people deciding on "latinx" for latinos, when majority real world latinos consider it idiotic (and don't find the term "latino" or "latin america" insulting). >But even if more people want to do this, so what? It’s their choice. These documents are about others policing their own language, not them policing yours. Hardly
- rmellow 4y agoNo one ever asked me if I liked being called 'Latinx'. I don't like the sound of it, and I feel I'd be seen as 'difficult' if I were to tell people in my company I don't like it. How is 'Latin' offensive? There is a loud minority within the Latin group who wants the term so they can feel powerful, and of course, the squeaky wheel gets the grease. In the end, all society is accomplishing is rewarding outrage.
- googlryas 4y agoLatin/Latino itself actually isn't inclusive since it is commonly used to refer to basically anyone from central/South America, even though many people there have no Latin heritage and may not even speak a Latin language(eg descendents of the Mayans)
- tsimionescu 4y agoIs Latinx any better from this point of view?
- TedDoesntTalk 4y ago“Killing two birds with one stone” promotes violence to animals. I will use this term to my grave and yet I’ve never committed violence to animals. Nor do I promote it. It’s a figure of speech.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoPeta came out with a list of "vegan" idioms. Probably mostly a publicity stunt and some are clunky, but I try and use "feeding 2 birds with one scone" because it's a good pun.
- cutemonster 4y agoOr "feeding 2 cats with one bird"
- forgetfulness 4y agoThat's really problematic because scones are not part of a bird's natural diet, and makes them subservient to the charity of humans.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoThat's gonna be a fun one to watch if they ever follow up on this reasoning, given that at this point, most land-dwelling animals are "subservient to the charity of humans". Those that aren't are either hiding in few undeveloped areas, or gone extinct.
- ticviking 4y agoThat is a good pun, and tells me a lot about someone if they've modified their habits of speech that much to avoid speaking like everyone else to project their worldview onto it. I really admire people who are actually wholly integrated that way.
- bell-cot 4y agoI'm sorry, but "figure" is obviously offensive to a huge number of people, starting with anyone who's ever suffered from anorexia. And "speech" is clearly a slur against mute persons. Please self-censor in the future, or the Stanford Brain Police will be forced to take appropriate measures. /s
- Cthulhu_ 4y ago> the vast majority of the words on this list do not have the claimed negative connotations in the slightest And who are you to judge that? Are you in any way subject to descriptors they offer alternatives to? I'll have to admit my bias though, I presume everyone here who rails against this list is themselves a financially, physically and mentally healthy heterosexual white male aged 20-40. You're not going to be offended by any of these terms, that's fine, it's not for your benefit.
- omginternets 4y agoHe’s speaking for himself, and I think he hit the nail on the head. So he’s speaking for me as well, now.
- politician 4y agoDo you think slurs against the group of people you so precisely targeted belong on this list, or no?
- tsimionescu 4y agoWell, you got one of your assumptions wrong at least (probably two, since you probably forgot to mention you likely assume that everyone here is from one of the wealthy "Western" countries). Regardless, I'm a speaker of English, and I have read up on the origin of most of those words, and understand how connotations work - apparently better than whoever put together this list, who seems to think "whitespace" is using white in a way which implies white=good, or "black box" somehow implies that black=bad. Also note, words are rarely a real problem. People can use perfectly normal good words to belittle you, even unintentionally (my father was asked a few times "do you have Google there?", for a country that's been a member of the EU for well over 10 years). The attitudes people have don't particularly change with the language they use. Reminds me of a segment John Stewart once did, where a state senator from some US state took the word and started complaining that "African-American kids just don't learn as well as white kids, they just lack the mental ability [...]". As John joked at the time - if you're going to be that unabashedly racist, just call them the n-word, it won't make things worse.