3 ms·
Nothing which costs that much and excludes so many people can honestly be called egalitarian – especially since it comes at the cost of removing so much public
by acdha 4y ago
Nothing which costs that much and excludes so many people can honestly be called egalitarian – especially since it comes at the cost of removing so much public space from any other use.
The intellectual dishonesty here is especially staggering:
> Horses, intercity trains, streetcars, you name it, were always used mainly by the relatively wealthy and were inaccessible to the poor, especially in cities.
In addition to being flat up wrong about streetcars, note how he mixes things like horses which have always been expensive and intercity trains (which serve a different purpose) without mentioning things like buses or bicycles which poor people heavily depend on.
Later, he puts access to a car as a sign of egalitarianism without asking whether that’s a sign of preference or necessity. Someone who looks at percentage of income paid and the difficulty of maintaining employment without a car would come to very different conclusions. That is, of course, if the goal was to learn rather than to find support for the position they started with.
- AuthorizedCust 4y ago> Nothing which costs that much and excludes so many people can honestly be called egalitarian But sky high costs of dense urban living is egalitarian?
- acdha 4y agoThat's a policy choice in a few cities[1], not an unalterable natural law. It's also confounded by how you do the comparison. If you're asking how much it costs to buy a 4,000 square foot single family dwelling, yes, cities are far more expensive but it's not that simple because, for example, suburbanites are far more likely to need cars ($11k/year average according to AAA) and people who live in cities don't need as much space because e.g. rather than having to pay for a lawn their kids play in the local park. It's also again important to consider how much of this is policy. For example, Tokyo is far more affordable that many American urban areas because they didn't have policies preventing density and the city wasn't gutted to provide highways for suburbanites who only contribute minimally to the economy and culture. In the U.S. the history of racism behind the rise of suburbs makes that really complicated because the neighborhoods most likely to be bulldozed or cut off for highway projects / parking lots were the poor neighborhoods, reducing the supply available for low-income residents. 1. And, for example, the median income in NYC is $43k so there are definitely reasons to question stereotypes: https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/newyorkcitynewyork/HSG010221 https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/newyorkcitynewy...
- HDThoreaun 4y agoUrban living is cheaper than suburban living. Not having a car allows for huge savings.
- pandaman 4y agoAt best you can save the car's ownership cost: financing + taxes + insurance + maintenance, which is, according to AAA, ~11K/year on average for a new vehicle in 2022 [1]. This is provided you don't pay for transportation at all and do not suffer any additional expenses because of your situation e.g. you don't pay for delivery, your shopping costs are not higher because of the reduced selection etc. 1. https://www.aaa.com/autorepair/articles/your-driving-costs https://www.aaa.com/autorepair/articles/your-driving-costs
- acdha 4y agoDon’t forget storage: that’s pricey in urban environments and elsewhere it is often is a considerable part of overall housing costs unless land is basically free.
- pandaman 4y agoI don't think many apartment dwellers pay for storage unless they have moved to an apartment from a house. If you are talking about car "storage" I am pretty sure it's free when you own a house.
- acdha 4y agoI was talking about car storage: you get a bill if you park at a garage for work but at home it’s far from free since you’re paying for a significant amount of land and structure on your property and if you live on a private driveway you’re paying some fraction of that as well. If you live in an outer suburb or more rural area the land costs are pretty low but if you live anywhere near a city it’s not uncommon for that to be adding 20-30% to your housing costs. Even if that’s available a la carte at an apartment complex it means land not being used for people, increasing the per-resident overhead costs, and since parking and traffic concerns are often used to prevent density it reduces the overall supply.