3 ms·
Ridiculously US centric article, and this: > The claim that “accessible public transportation” can produce greater equality ignores the fact that mass transit,
by defrost 4y ago
Ridiculously US centric article, and this:
> The claim that “accessible public transportation” can produce greater equality ignores the fact that mass transit, whether private or public, has generally been used mainly by an elite.
skips over a public transport history of the US that has seen the elite (eg Koch brothers) work to sink any public transport effort specifically to increase the per capita use of fossil fuels (and their profits), and planners using infrastructure projects to divide vibrant neighbourhoods and push out those determined as poor, unwanted, etc.
- IIAOPSW 4y agoThe use of "elite" to describe people using public transit is absurd at face value, but makes perfect sense when you understand "elite" as coded language for anyone living in a city, tinged with a connotation of contempt and awash with political undertone.
- oblio 4y agoWhich is insane since cities were the original great leveler. The way for poor people to achieve social mobility.
- AuthorizedCust 4y ago> Ridiculously US centric article... The lived experience of the vast majority of US citizens is an illegitimate viewpoint? Whose viewpoints deserve a seat at the table?
- acdha 4y agoThe author is making a globally-sweeping claim in service of their opposition to "government planning". If their claim is trivially disproven by looking at countries with similar or greater quality of life around the world, that suggests that this is in fact not a universal truth but a deliberate policy outcome. The fact that it's also not true even within the United States (currently in some places, everywhere prior to WWII) similarly confirms that this isn't a deep truth but rather a convoluted restatement that most people will end up using the option which is favored by policy.