3 ms·
It's a trivalent or worse response based on complex belief and observations 1) yes. It has next to no concrete demonstrated downside if you don't want to die o
by ggm 4y ago
It's a trivalent or worse response based on complex belief and observations
1) yes. It has next to no concrete demonstrated downside if you don't want to die of severe head injury excluding all other outcomes
2) yes. It alters your risk from life ending to merely disfiguring, or potentially quadriplegic, but at a significantly reduced rate compared to total risks unprotected on a bike.
3) yes. But, it won't stop other complex non head non neck related injury which can of course also be terminal, and has no strict bearing on their risk.
There is a confounding theory that wearing a helmet may make you take more risk.
There is a confounding theory that wearing a helmet makes you a target of abuse, attack and increases risk.
There are confounding stats on injury and death rates presenting at EMT and hospital which demand good statistics around increase in bike riding, age, sex, alcohol, drugs.
My personal belief is the confounding theories are bad logic to ride helmetless because they mistake second and third order effects and confuse risk and frequency against total population changes.
I live in an economy with compulsory bike helmets and I know emergency doctors none of whom seriously want this ended despite increases in survivable but horrific accidents for cyclists: prior to helmet law most of these people died.
My personal opinion is yes: you're a bloody idiot, literally and figuratively.
For this opinion you have to wear a well designed standards conforming helmet properly, with chinstrap done up and fitting. Otherwise it's performative and may be worse than useless.
I wear a helmet. My helmet of choice is protec.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-07135-1 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-07135-1 is well written.
- celticninja 4y agoHere is another confounding theory: drivers give cyclists in helmets less space when they overtake them. Seems that they assume a cyclist wearing a helmet is more experienced so the driver gives less space. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2006/09/060911102200.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2006/09/060911102200.h... I wear a helmet on my bike, either off road or on road cycling.
- ggm 4y agoYes, I've read that too. It's subtly different to targeted abuse because there's no malign intent, they just subconsciously don't give you as much space.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Fricken 4y agoI only wear a helmet on trails and long road rides. On trails, the false feeling of confidence I get from knowing I have a helmet gives results in faster times on my various trail circuits. Once I forgot my helmet and decided to ride anyhow and my times were bad because I was too chicken-shit to go balls out, always tapping the brakes. The psychologic effect is massive. I'm a rock climber as well. Climbers will regale you with harrowing tales of all the times they thought they were gonna die, but when you look at the accident reports, more often than not it wasn't the "scary" parts of the climb where they got hurt. It's the things like rapelling where lapses in situational awareness lead to absent minded mistakes. When you fear for your life you are not absent minded. And so Alex Honnold is still alive, even though by all "reasonable" statistical judgement he should be dead a hundred times over.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Fricken 4y agocyclists live longer than the average non-cyclist. Even cyclists without helmets live longer than the average non-cyclist. Going off the stats, even a bloody idiot non-helmet wearing cyclist has a better survival strategy a typical non-cyclist. Of course generalized safety data means almost nothing to you specifically, because the situations you get into are not general, they are very particular, and you may be particularly well suited to manage the trouble you're in, or not.
- Kim_Bruning 4y ago4) No. If you are not engaged in risky activity, that is to say: If you are riding a) a safe commuter bicycle [1] b) at safe commuter speeds [2] c) on a safe separated/protected bike lane [3] d) That is kept maintained in a safe state for the current weather You probably don't need a helmet. 5) Yes, In other situations, you might want to consider it. [4][5] -- [ note: It turns out that implementing a)-d) are actually attainable in a fairly fiscally sustainable way (see eg.: Netherlands, Denmark), but it may need something of a turnaround in many a local government's safety culture ] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roadster_(bicycle) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roadster_(bicycle) [2] 12.4 km/h according to https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2018/01/02/dutch-cycling-figures/ https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2018/01/02/dutch-cycling-... [3] https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fietspad https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fietspad [4] eg. when doing more dangerous activities like mountain biking or racing [5] or -of course- cycling in many places outside the netherlands or denmark. :-( [5] https://www.cyclehelmets.org/1261.html https://www.cyclehelmets.org/1261.html "Why are Dutch cyclists more likely to be injured if they wear helmets?" (edit: +references)
- tmottabr 4y agoThat is total BS because you are not taking into account everyone else driving around.. you can be the safest rider in the world, ride only at the proper speed, only in the proper place, that place is always well maintained and everything else you can thing of.. All it takes is someone else doing something irresponsible and you are screwed.. i.e: a drunk driver loose control of their car, it invade the bike lane at high speed and hit you.. you are in for a bad accident that could be made a little less bad if you were wearing a helmet, even while doing everything you said.. now, if you are riding alone, in the middle of nowhere with zero change of someone else screwing it up.. then sure, you can skip the helmet, but if you are riding on road even if you do everything right you still at risk and helmet will improve your odds of surviving if something bad happen..
- Kim_Bruning 4y agoWe are mostly in "violent agreement" as it is called. If you are on a separate / protected bike path (not on a road intended for cars), then there are no cars there, nor can they easily get on that path. In practice such protections/barriers might range from moderately difficult to surmount (raised curbs ~ 50 km/h) ; nearly impossible to penetrate (row of trees, solid concrete wall, drainage ditch full of water ~ 80km/h); to outright having the bicycle path follow a different right of way altogether( >80 km/h ). In general, the routes for cars, bikes, and pedestrians should be separated wherever there are large differences in speed that can lead to danger. Edit: See also one of the sources for the video, eg. https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/bmjopen/5/11/e008052.full.pdf https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/bmjopen/5/11/e008052.full.pd... The conclusion is that wearing a helmet doesn't help as much as physically separating bicycles from other traffic. While it may be good to be protected in case of accident, it's much better to avoid having the accident altogether.
- fvdessen 4y agoAll your arguments also apply to wearing a helmet while walking. The rate of injury while walking or cycling are similar. Do you wear a helmet while walking ?
- iforgotpassword 4y agoHeh, good point actually. Made me wonder. I guess the rate of accidents for cyclists is still much higher than for pedestrians, as walkways are usually even more separated from roads. Also, let's imagine I ride my bike along a busy street with lots of small alleys to the right which are mostly obstructed by buildings or trees. I have right of way. Even if I travel at the safe but unrealistic 12.4kmh that came up as a safe speed of travel in another comment, I might not have enough time to brake for a drunk driver confusing their gas and brake pedal and shooting out the alley at 60kmh. As a pedestrian I approach the alley at maybe 6kmh and my chances at jumping backwards in time should be significantly higher. Admittedly, this is a random example I just pulled out of my butt with no data to back it up. I guess in the end it is up to everyone to draw the line somewhere between comfort and safety. This can be backed up by data, but is ultimately subjective. Even with a helmet, I can get run over fatally when walking somewhere. I could lower the risk further by just staying home as much a possible. Am I willing to?
- fvdessen 4y ago> I guess the rate of accidents for cyclists is still much higher than for pedestrians You don't have to guess ! It's in the video, the rates are surprisingly similar :)
- marssaxman 4y agoFor complete consistency, anyone who criticizes bicyclists for declining to wear a helmet ought not only to wear a helmet while walking, but also whenever they ride in a car.
- fvdessen 4y agoAlso they should wear a bulletproof vest, as there's 20x more gun than bicycle related deaths in the USA
- iudqnolq 4y agoI don't know anything about helmets in particular. About a year ago I did some reading into risk compensation, the general theory that safety interventions cause people to take greater risks leading to worse outcomes than there would be without the intervention. There's plenty of theoretical speculation. It's attractive to a certain sort of contrarian who thinks they're smarter than domain experts. But any time anyone has actually collected real world data they haven't found the effect. Given it's been decades since the invention of the theory, and there's no evidence for it, at this point I think it's on the proponents to do some actual research. Until they do, I think we should disregard the speculation.