2 ms·
If businesses want to pick and choose among domains for various like them being disposable email services or something, I tend not to argue, as that's not reall
by cratermoon 4y ago
If businesses want to pick and choose among domains for various like them being disposable email services or something, I tend not to argue, as that's not really a technical problem. The problems I highlight address technical misconceptions, like "all domains end with a 3-character TLD", or "valid email addresses are constrained to a certain character set". The only one you highlight as being "not valid" that is in fact technically wrong is "unreachable domains". There are many reasons why a domain could be unreachable in some sense but still be valid for email. If, on sending an email, it fails, then it can be blacklisted.
These days I see more providers going to a strategy of requiring the new signup hit a link sent in a confirmation email. In that case it's possible to accept nearly anything as an email address for signup, without any technical validation, because the ultimate accurate check happens: does the user get the email? Then the business is free to pick and choose and refuse certain domains without having to worry if they are tripping over some subtle aspect of RFCs 2822, 1034, or 1035.