3 ms·
Actually even with the requirements I laid out, DRM would still work. A manufacturer could ship a device with decryption keys for DRM content. If the end-owner
by mindslight 4y ago
Actually even with the requirements I laid out, DRM would still work. A manufacturer could ship a device with decryption keys for DRM content. If the end-owner decided to liberate their device, then the decryption keys would be erased and DRM content could no longer be played. The owner would be left with a blank device ready to accept new software, likely open source, and the device wouldn't be relegated to becoming e-waste.
- p_l 4y agoThat's how it works with some of the hw backed DRM schemes that for example try to use remote Attestation with TPM, or secure media pathways on intel me or AMD PSP. The DRM software simply stops working, while you get to run everything you build yourself still.
- cryptonector 4y agoThere's no stopping walled gardens -- not with technology as the vendors would choose not to use such technology. The most choice users will ever get to make (per-device) is whether to be locked-into or locked-out-of the walled gardens.
- josephcsible 4y agoHuh, good point. I wonder how that would be fixable too.
- mindslight 4y agoDoes it need to be? I'm a staunch supporter of libre software, but I don't see the harm.
- mschuster91 4y ago> I'm a staunch supporter of libre software, but I don't see the harm. The harm is we're still perpetuating DRM crap. The music industry has accepted that Spotify's DRM can be trivially broken and completely given up trying to police BitTorrent... it's time for the movie industry to realize the same. Sadly, Netflix failed to get enough dominance to bend over and cane the movie industry into submission, and regulatory agencies worldwide just accepted happily that movie studios went all-in on vertical integration again.
- mindslight 4y agoThe concept of DRM was initially created on general purpose open computers. No TPM, no code signing, no remote attestation. Just plain old proprietary software running on open systems was enough to create something with DRM functionality, and put blood in the water for the control freaks. Having a device be able to store and use secure keying material that cannot be read back out seems like a very useful basic property. A basic property which directly implies being able to store keys for decrypting media content, thus making for a better DRM scheme than could be achieved with a fully-debugger-able processor. Of course, I could missing a way that this property could tweaked to neutralize some of its downsides - akin to how my original comment laid out slight modifications to the usual TPM/SE requirements that would prevent much abuse of TPMs/SEs by centralizing entities.
- cryptonector 4y agoIt can't be "fixed" with technology. It's a matter of market power, and maybe legislation.
- EMIRELADERO 4y agoThe fix would be to make "persons who choose to gain full control and code execution of the device" a protected class.