3 ms·
> etymology doesn’t determine meaning. Otherwise we would have to conclude that “woman” is male-gendered because it etymologically derives from “man”. Man was
by slavik81 4y ago
> etymology doesn’t determine meaning. Otherwise we would have to conclude that “woman” is male-gendered because it etymologically derives from “man”.
Man was not gendered when "woman" originated. In Old English, the words for men and women were "wer" and "wif", while "mann" described any person. Over time, wifmann became woman, and for whatever reason, wermann didn't end up becoming a word.
Other examples of trouble through etymology might include "virtue" and "world", which both derive from "wer".
- lstodd 4y agoHow very interesting. Thank you.
- HideousKojima 4y agoWer did survive in the word "werewolf" as well.
- School-Cotton 4y agoOkay, but my point still stands. If etymology determined meaning we’d have to conclude that “man” is ungendered, which is clearly wrong.