4 ms·
I think you're missing the point of a social network. Barack Obama is not social on Twitter. You can't talk to him. You can't have a conversation. Look at his
by lapcat 4y ago
I think you're missing the point of a social network.
Barack Obama is not social on Twitter. You can't talk to him. You can't have a conversation. Look at his Twitter feed: when's the last time he's replied to anyone? He issues mini press releases, that's all.
You can't email Barack Obama either, by the way. I mean, you can try, but good luck with that.
You talk about a messaging service, but it's entirely one-way messaging between famous people and non-famous people.
Mastodon users aren't looking to follow famous people and be passive recipients of press releases from famous people. They're looking to have conversations with each other. In this respect, Obama is irrelevant.
- crazygringo 4y agoYou're missing the point that Obama was just an example, to use the most followed person on Twitter. There are tons of people on Twitter with over 10 million followers who interact with Twitter a ton. They're very "social". If a social network can't handle people who are popular, then that's a real problem. And remember, people's accounts can start unpopular, and then they gain millions of followers over years. So what do you do, boot them off for the sin of saying things lots of people want to listen to and interact with?
- lapcat 4y ago> There are tons of people on Twitter with over 10 million followers who interact with Twitter a ton. They certainly don't interact with 10 million people. That's impossible. They only interact with a tiny subset of their followers. > If a social network can't handle people who are popular, then that's a real problem. And remember, people's accounts can start unpopular, and then they gain millions of followers over years. I disagree. The most popular person I followed on Twitter had 300K followers and had been on Twitter since 2006. It's really not a big deal if there are no celebrities. The celebrities can post wherever else on the web they like. Don't need them. Let them continue on Twitter, whatever. Not a problem. I've spent literally decades on the internet, on countless forums, never interacting with celebrities. It's fine. It's great!
- crazygringo 4y agoYou're completely missing the point, again. This isn't about "celebrities" (a word I never used), it's about popular people all around, like authors, journalists, and so on. And sure nobody is personally replying to all of their 10 million+ followers, but those 10 million+ followers do want to follow! And popular figures absolutely interact with and reply to tons of their followers quite frequently, that's the whole point. Frankly, nobody cares if you "don't need" anybody popular. But to argue that a place like Mastodon should make it impossible for anybody to be popular, is ludicrous. If Mastodon wanted to stay tiny for people like you, separated into little popular-people-not-supported bubbles with a some hard max limit on followers, then why would it even have been built on federation in the first place...? The idea that an author with only a few followers could have a best-selling book, and then at some point enthusiastic readers try to follow them only to get "error: max follow limit reached", would be a total and utter failure. A bug, not a feature.
- lapcat 4y ago> This isn't about "celebrities" (a word I never used), it's about popular people all around, like authors, journalists, and so on. I don't want to quibble over terms. Celebrities, popular people, whatever you want to call them. > And popular figures absolutely interact with and reply to tons of their followers quite frequently, that's the whole point. And popular people have plenty of places where they can do that. But why does everyplace have to be amenable to people with 10+ million followers? > But to argue that a place like Mastodon should make it impossible for anybody to be popular, is ludicrous. That's a straw man. It's simply a question of whether it's technically/financially feasible to scale to that level. And there's no reason why it has to be. I don't see why it needs to be designed around the needs of super popular people. > The idea that an author with only a few followers could have a best-selling book, and then at some point enthusiastic readers try to follow them It's possible for a person to outgrow a place. That doesn't mean there was anything wrong with the original place. Popular people have different needs than non-popular people, but that doesn't mean we have to cater to popular people as a prime directive. I find it ludicrous that every social space on the web would have to make itself accessible to celebrities (my word), as if it were a legal requirement like making it accessible to the disabled. Celebrities are not a protected class. ;-) The sites that cater to celebrities are supported by advertising. They need all the eyeballs brought by celebrities. Mastodon does not have advertising. It doesn't have the same incentives. That's not a flaw, it's just a different set of choices and priorities.