6 ms·
I am sure I am not alone in finding the lexical structure of the "windows subsystem for... " very unfortunate. Windows is the dom0 and the android or linux is t
by ggm 4y ago
I am sure I am not alone in finding the lexical structure of the "windows subsystem for... " very unfortunate. Windows is the dom0 and the android or linux is the domU instance. Kinda.
It's windows hosted Android. or Android as a subsystem hosted on windows. Android running on Windows. But no, it has to be "for"
But I bet they workshopped it for hours in the marketing department and decided Windows had to come "first"
- kevingadd 4y agoNot especially new terminology though, they used that 'Windows S... for <x>' framing for the original unix subsystem: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Services_for_UNIX https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Services_for_UNIX Subsystems are pretty old Windows tech and it's cool to finally see the Android one come back. AFAIK they started with an Android one before ditching it to pivot to WSL. I think there may have been an OS/2 subsystem for a bit at one point as well?
- becurious 4y agoProject Astoria to allow Android apps to run on Windows Phone. Though WSL2 is not a classic NT kernel subsystem in the way WSL1 was.
- rewgs 4y agoMicrosoft is baffling bad at naming things. I sometimes think that they’re playing a game to see just how badly they can name their products before they start to lose money.
- PaulHoule 4y agoYou’ve got to be quite the gamer to understand the hierarchy of XBOX consoles.
- tomrod 4y agoThere have been like 3 throughout history, right? We are to the Xbox 36One?
- PaulHoule 4y agoBase, 360, One, and Series One!
- eclipxe 4y agoAnd Series X
- eclipxe 4y agoAnd Xbox One S
- pca184 4y agoAnd the Xbox Series S!
- eyelidlessness 4y agoHuge if true
- LocalH 4y agostill waiting on the Xbox SX and then the enhanced Xbox SEX
- dragonwriter 4y agoBase, 360 (360 S, 360 E), One (One S, One X), Series (Series S and Series X)
- rewgs 4y agoCalling it the "S Series" or "X Series" would make sense, but "Series" as the base name of the product line is just...I mean, what were they thinking? It makes absolutely zero sense. Meanwhile Sony's over here with PS1, PS2, PS3, PS4, PS5, and all the sub-versions make perfect sense (base, slim, pro, etc).
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>You’ve got to be quite the gamer to understand the hierarchy of XBOX consoles. I have the feeling Microsoft intentionally sought to create this confusion so they can move the old stock as well. Example: Young Billy wants an Xbox for Christmas so clueless parents/grandparents go to Walmart and purchase something made by Microsoft with Xbox written on the box, preferably on sale and at a cheaper price.
- ironick09 4y agoThere is a reason why it is named what it is: The Windows Subsystem for Android now runs Android 13 in beta https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34060390 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34060390
- jonhohle 4y agoI think the problem is that the name could be interpreted as a subsystem that runs on Android to provide a Windows API or services. I had that issue with WSL; it sounds like it could be the name of an official WINE-like product from Microsoft. “For” is often used to specify the target.
- pitterpatter 4y agoEdge is probably the one that annoyed me the most
- MishaalRahman 4y agoThe reason it's named that way is because of Google's trademark on Android. Per Rich Turner @ Microsoft: "As I mentioned earlier in the thread, it's not about positioning of words, it's about the legalities of trademark usage; we cannot lead a product name with a term trademarked by someone else." Source: https://twitter.com/richturn_ms/status/1245742145119510529 https://twitter.com/richturn_ms/status/1245742145119510529
- dataflow 4y agoThis keeps coming up and I keep saying that, if the issue is the leading term, they could've just called it the Windows Android Subsystem. (I suspect the real issue is that "for" makes it clearer this is a third-party thing, but nobody ever mentions that.)
- ocdtrekkie 4y agoI believe Android branding guidelines explicitly only allow the use of it by third parties in the form of "for Android".
- gpm 4y agoAndroid branding guidelines are very unlikely to matter at this point, given that it's descriptive use (not forbidden by trademark law in the first place) anyways...
- gibolt 4y agoThis is Microsoft using Google branding. That isn't a risk worth taking, even if more Android access benefits Google
- czx4f4bd 4y agoI don't think that's what descriptive fair use means. > Descriptive Fair Use: Found at 15 U.S.C. § 1115(b)(4), the descriptive fair use defense protects your ability to use ordinary words to describe your own goods or services, even if those words happen to be part of someone's trademark. https://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/using-trademarks-others https://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/using-trademarks-others Since the Windows Subsystem for Android actually runs Android, "Windows Subsystem for Android" is a product name and not just a description, and "Android" isn't a generic descriptive term in this context, it seems to me that Microsoft is using Google's Android trademark in a way that isn't protected as fair use.
- andrecarini 4y ago> decided Windows had to come "first" I heard someone say it here at HN that the reason it's worded this way is to avoid copyright infringement issues if they were to lead the name with someone else's trademark.
- MishaalRahman 4y ago>As I mentioned earlier in the thread, it's not about positioning of words, it's about the legalities of trademark usage; we cannot lead a product name with a term trademarked by someone else Source: https://twitter.com/richturn_ms/status/1245742145119510529 https://twitter.com/richturn_ms/status/1245742145119510529
- 8note 4y agoWithout knowing what it actually is, the name gives me the assumption that I can start an Android instance through PowerShell, and it can do things in a kinda, but not quite native way
- constantlm 4y agoWhile I know what it is, it reads the opposite way for me - like, it's some sort of Windows running on Android
- DrammBA 4y agoAs another perspective, your comment is the first time I read the terms "dom0" and "domU instance", and "Windows subsystem" is the only phrase in my vocabulary that uses the word "subsystem". With that perspective, "Windows Subsystem for X" makes total sense in my mind. To me it means that Windows (as an operating system) has one (or more) Subsystems, and those subsystems are created for specific use cases, for example we have a Windows Subsystem for Linux, and another Windows Subsystem for Android, and they'll probably create more Subsystems in the future. I'm sure it sounds wrong for people with your level of education and background, but to people like me it's actually very descriptive and straight forward.
- ggm 4y agoA totally valid perspective. I am probably coming at this with prior-art in mind and you're coming at it (presumed, and no insult intended) from inside the MS ecosystem which is after all the core market. If the term makes sense for windows users, windows administrators it did it's job.
- rpeden 4y agoIt's worth noting that subsystems are an old Windows concept dating back to the original Windows NT in 1993. The win32 API itself is a subsystem of the underlying NT system. And the WoW64 subsystem allows 32-bit Windows apps to run on 64-bit Windows. There used to be POSIX and OS/2 subsystems, as well. I believe the "Windows Subsystem for x" nomenclature is a departure from the way MS previously described subsystems. That doesn't mean it is wrong, though. Just a bit inconsistent.
- croes 4y agoIsn't the WSA a layer between Windows and Android to map Android calls to the corresponding Windows calls?
- nullish_signal 4y ago"Windows running Android"?
- dragonwriter 4y agoThe Windows Subsystem for X is the thing that allows X to run on top of Windows. If there was going to be a “Windows Hosted X”, it would be the thing that runs on top, but they mostly just call that X.
- karmakaze 4y agoI had the same difficulty making sense of, and internalizing, the naming. What finally stuck for me is not to parse it as "(Windows subsystem) for ..." but rather as "Windows' (subsystem for ...)". Related rant: I don't like the "reverse-proxy" naming--it's not self-explanatory. It's only historical that client proxies came first and thus server-proxies are 'reverse' (other end). The proxy is a stand-in for a client or for a server, so client proxy or server proxy (or proxy-client or proxy-server). I've come to accept the historically arbitrary naming.
- tgv 4y agoI read it more like "the (Windows subsytem) for ...", but the outcome is the same. Our language system, however, has a strong penchant for what's known as right attachment: constituents such as the prepositional phrase (in this case "for ...") are preferably attached below the preceding constituent, and that preference already takes effect at the preposition, so the decision is made before knowing the complete sentence. Because the sentence is ambiguous, you get stuck on the wrong interpretation. Curiously enough, I have the same feeling about reverse proxy. Neither proxy reverses anything functional. A reverse proxy would be something that lets you talk to the proxied entity directly, a tunnel perhaps.
- HeckFeck 4y agoExactly the point. Were I describing the concept, I'd say 'It is a Linux subsystem for Windows', if I said 'a Windows subsystem for Linux', you'd think I meant WINE. I hate the loss of clarity in our speech and I wonder what the cumulative effect will be.