3 ms·
This is a fantastic article -- I've seen these confusions play out on forums (including HN) countless times, but not just regards with free speech, but really w
by crazygringo 4y ago
This is a fantastic article -- I've seen these confusions play out on forums (including HN) countless times, but not just regards with free speech, but really with regards to any policy -- tech monopolies being a big one here. We see the equivalent:
1) What actually is a monopoly legally (e.g. Apple and iPhones are not, because not enough market share)
2) What should be considered a monopoly, the law should be changed (e.g. make walled gardens considered monopolies)
3) OK it's not a monopoly but it's still indecent/bad (e.g. Apple has every right to charge 30% but it makes them an a**hole)
It's easy to think of 10 other subject areas we see the same debates/confusions playing out over endlessly. And while there already exist general-purpose terms for the three categories -- 1) legal, 2) moral, and 3) preference -- people really seem to often mix up legal vs. moral, and moral vs. preference. Because when you just say "X should Y"... your "should" could be based on any one of those three.
- tracker1 4y agoThere's really, also Monopoly vs a Trust, etc. [1] The concepts tend to overlap and used with the meaning of one another, but using "monopoly" in a more generic sense. 1. https://www.writingtips.cc/monopoly-vs-corner-vs-pool-vs-syndicate-vs-trust-vs-cartel/ https://www.writingtips.cc/monopoly-vs-corner-vs-pool-vs-syn...