3 ms·
Two observations: (1) maybe it doesn't need to scale for people to ultimately have a much better experience and (2) bottlenecks tend to be identified and resolv
by jacquesm 4y ago
Two observations: (1) maybe it doesn't need to scale for people to ultimately have a much better experience and (2) bottlenecks tend to be identified and resolved up to the limit of the scaling laws and hardware improvements, bandwidth cost reduction and storage cost reduction tend to over time make the impossible thing from yesterday feasible today.
Keep in mind that Torrents tend to be much larger than your average Tweet/Toot/Whatever and that the interconnects between the servers need to transport only those messages for which there are subscribers, something that could be optimized for (you really only need to transport each message once per sender if there are subscribers, not once per subscriber).
- Zak 4y agoBeing based around a protocol rather than a single piece of software, it will likely end up that servers intended to grow large will run different software than servers intended to stay small.
- jacquesm 4y agoThat could well happen, a bit like the difference between say 'gmail' and your own private mail server. The big trick will then be to stop it from becoming siloed again.
- pwinnski 4y agoI suspect that key to the future of the fediverse is likely to be a more efficient piece of software than mastodon.
- Zak 4y agoI expect very large servers will be commercially operated and running bespoke software. When Tumblr adds ActivityPub support, it will be the largest Fediverse instance by far.
- factormeta 4y agohmmm didn't know Tumblr was planning on doing that. Any more info on this?
- Zak 4y agoThey announced it, oddly enough on Twitter. Techcrunch reported it, among others. Flickr is also considering it. https://techcrunch.com/2022/11/21/tumblr-to-add-support-for-activitypub-the-social-protocol-powering-mastodon-and-other-apps/ https://techcrunch.com/2022/11/21/tumblr-to-add-support-for-... https://twitter.com/donmacaskill/status/1594945727255699457 https://twitter.com/donmacaskill/status/1594945727255699457
- jacquesm 4y agoIt will probably immediately cause those directly upstream to find some new bottlenecks in their implementation.
- Karrot_Kream 4y ago> (1) maybe it doesn't need to scale for people to ultimately have a much better experience Big, heavy doubt. This Twitter debacle has generated ridiculous, crazy amounts of drama and emoting, the likes I haven't seen on the net in ... a while. This kind of emoting and drama stirring only works when the pot is large. A storm in a small teapot really isn't much. It reminds me of the high drama that used to happen on large IRC channels run by teens in the early '00s, where you'd wake up and some portion of the server got muted or banned for some completely opaque but intensely personal reason. (I was one of the teens so I'm not implying like I was much better than the rest of them lol.) I'm in 20-something small Matrix rooms/spaces and Discord guilds and none of them are nearly this dramatic. The kind of folks that seek engagement on Twitter IMO are in it for the high drama that you can only get on a large social platform. The folks that stay on the Fediverse are looking for something entirely different. I'm hopeful that some folks try the Fediverse and realize they didn't need Twitter at all (not in some sense of Twitter anger, but more that it's good for folks who want to socialize in smaller spaces be aware that it's very possible to do that on the net right now.) FWIW If you're trying to build a small community and afraid of scaling issues, I still think hopping onto Matrix or Discord (preferably in that order) is a better idea. Synapse might be heavyweight but it's still lighter than running Mastodon, and if your community doesn't want to federate, you can run the much lighter Dendrite (or even lighter Conduit which is a bit more raw.) There's a large ecosystem of clients on all the big platforms for Matrix. Discord being a centralized, closed system has all of these problems solved as well.
- cactusplant7374 4y ago> maybe it doesn't need to scale for people to ultimately have a much better experience It certainly needs less features. I'm sure quite a bit of Twitter's infrastructure is dedicated to ads and analytics.
- elsjaako 4y agoThere's also no full text search on Mastodon, and no single server has access to all the posts on the federated system.
- jacquesm 4y agoThat's a good observation, a federated, non-commercial messaging platform has a different tech footprint than one that needs to be monetized to the max to satisfy a bunch of shareholder and generate quarterly earning reports.
- cactusplant7374 4y agoPlus, it's written in Rails. [0] I love Rails but they could switch to something else and tweak it to the extreme. There were very popular sites in the past (i.e. Slashdot) that didn't have many servers and were extremely performance tuned. [0] https://github.com/mastodon/mastodon https://github.com/mastodon/mastodon