4 ms·
I know this is not very scientific, but I have always figured that my body knows what it’s doing when it responds to an injury with inflammation.
by kube-system 4y ago
I know this is not very scientific, but I have always figured that my body knows what it’s doing when it responds to an injury with inflammation.
- akerl_ 4y agoI think it's worth remembering that your body does what it does for a reason, but that it's nearly always working with imperfect information. Some notable examples: When you're in a stressful situation at work, your body can't tell the difference between that and "Oh no, we spotted a material threat to our life", so it reacts in ways that would make fight or flight easier, not in ways that help you handle the real situation. If your liver fails and you get a transplant, your body sees "ah, a foreign invader", and will set about the task of rejecting the new liver, despite it being very important for your wellbeing.
- guerrilla 4y agoDefinitely true, but the way I think of it is that you should go with the default unless you have a reason not to. Things like fear and depression are useful tools but if they get out of control and only then are they mental illness, for example. In all of your examples, the person can know better, but when we're talking about the type of injuries from the OP then we usually don't unless we've consulted with medical professionals (or are one ourselves) so it makes sense to start with the default.
- kube-system 4y agoI'm the type of person who produces their best work when they're under pressure, so, maybe my fight response does help me at work.
- onion2k 4y agoI have always figured that my body knows what it’s doing when it responds to an injury with inflammation. Applying the logic of "your body knows" is probably not in your best long term interest. In purely evolutionary terms, getting a bad enough injury that you require medical attention should mean you just die because you weren't strong enough to survive. Artificially saving your life is "unnatural".
- nh23423fefe 4y agoThis is an often repeated but incorrect interpretation of 'survival of the fittest.' Newborn babies can not survive, yet that says nothing about whether they 'should' or 'shouldn't' according to 'evolution.' Evolution isn't goal directed, it isn't picking winners and losers.