3 ms·
Ice has only been widely available for the last ~100 years, which means presumably ice to treat injuries has only been around for 100 years, which in turn means
by londons_explore 4y ago
Ice has only been widely available for the last ~100 years, which means presumably ice to treat injuries has only been around for 100 years, which in turn means I assume someone must have done a modern study to prove it benefitted patients?
So what changed that it is no longer beneficial?
- bena 4y agoLooking at "PEACE & LOVE", the "A" stands for "Avoid Anti-inflammatories" because anti-inflammatories will reduce tissue healing. Ice is used as an anti-inflammatory. Because swelling often prevents movement. So since ice reduced the inflammation and swelling, it increased movement, which we've translated as "being better". But apparently what you want is to not move and aggravate the actual injury. We've moved from treating the symptoms to treating the cause.
- contravariant 4y agoAssuming something must have been studied because it became more pervasive recently is a dangerous assumption. Especially with things that seem obvious. Like cooling an injury with ice for instance, which seem like a good idea (or feels better anyway). Also people have tried to keep stuff cold for ages, I'm pretty sure the folk remedy of using a slab of cold meat to cool an injury has been around longer than just the period in time that people had free access to ice.
- rascul 4y ago> I'm pretty sure the folk remedy of using a slab of cold meat to cool an injury has been around longer than just the period in time that people had free access to ice. Wouldn't it have been difficult to keep the meat cold?
- noja 4y agoProbably two presumptions: less swelling is good, cold reduces pain. Now it has been tested.
- bennyelv 4y ago> which in turn means I assume someone must have done a modern study to prove it benefitted patients I wouldn't assume that :) Ice treatment was about pain relief, not overall benefit. I believe it also came from the world of sports science, to which a lower bar is applied due to the general non-life-or-death consequences.
- AstixAndBelix 4y ago>I assume someone must have done a modern study to prove it benefitted patients? why assume in the age of the internet? if it's something that tickles your curiosity just do a little research
- fsh 4y agoI wouldn't be surprised if that assumption turns out to be wrong. A lot of medical procedures seem to have little or no empirical backing. Apparently there are not many incentives to do high-quality studies in the field.