18 ms·
Title is "Oatly, Other Deflated IPO Stocks Haunt New-Issue Market" -- In June 2021, "Oatly priced its initial public offering at $17 per share, giving it an i
by sph 4y ago
Title is "Oatly, Other Deflated IPO Stocks Haunt New-Issue Market"
--
In June 2021, "Oatly priced its initial public offering at $17 per share, giving it an implied valuation of $10 billion."
10 billion dollars for an oat drink company. We're way overdue a correction on tech stocks, the time for free, cheap money is over.
- Ekaros 4y agoAnd oat drink should in no way be considered a tech stock. It is even less one than for example Tesla...
- sph 4y agoRight. With tech stock, I meant a startup venture capitals and investors were eager to give a lot of money to. Usually those are tech stocks, but plant-based ultra-processed food startups have become quite prominent in VC portfolios lately, see Beyond Meat.
- dokein 4y agoI suspect that VCs are disproportionately exposed to people (e.g. upper and upper-middle class tech workers in SV) that are open to e.g. oat milk, meat substitutes, etc., and so bias towards everyone in the US being similarly open. Of course they probably know intellectually it's not true but it's hard to overcome the subtle biases formed by one's day-to-day experiences. Similarly my understanding is that Cambly had a hard time raising their early round because all those VCs already knew English.
- Ekaros 4y agoAnd they might think they have done so well with software and SaaS in low interest rate enviroment that they will do well with physical products. Not seeing that food is much harder market to penetrate, with often low margins and products spoiling in various ways, not forget fun of manufacturing and distributing to more than Amazon or single warehouse.
- Semaphor 4y agoIt’s not even just that, imo. Our supermarket (in Germany) has a ton of plant-based not-milks. Those seem to sell pretty well. It’s just that oatly does not seem special in any way besides having hipster-friendly marketing. I see no reason to get their milk over any of the competitors.
- Klonoar 4y agoOatly has a full fat variant that is 10x better for baking usage than any other plant milk I’ve tried. (This in no way justifies that valuation but I wanted to randomly chime in here.)
- mistrial9 4y agooat milk is the only non-milk that tastes good in coffee, to me
- forgetfulness 4y agoI recently cut back on seed oils, and the taste of sunflower oil in oat milk is now very noticeable. I don't mind it because of thinking that having a bit of it in every other cup of coffee is poison, it's more that the aftertaste is less enjoyable than straight espresso or an americano now that I notice it. Time to give soy lattes a try, lactose intolerance is a literal PITA.
- Semaphor 4y agoI’m not diluting my tasty coffee ;)
- omgwtf1000 4y agoHear! Hear!
- im3w1l 4y agoI do think there is something there, maybe time is just not ripe. The "eat, sleep and work out properly and naturally"-conservatives are currently winning and dominating the zeitgeist. Science must eventually win, and produce foods that are healthier than the natural ones. But there is no telling when that happens, and even after it has happened, it may take a long time to prove itself. Edit: Personally I think the key to fast progress is better and better whitebox modelling of the body. More diagnostics and sensors to rapidly detect and respond to issues. When that is in place, we can do more fearless experimentation, secure in the knowledge that if something trends bad we can catch it quickly and abort / reverse.
- sph 4y ago> Science must eventually win, and produce foods that are healthier than the natural ones. I do not share your optimism, because you forgot about economy, investors and shareholders driving science forward, not viceversa. The primary goal for public companies is to increase revenue and market share, not creating healthier food than nature, if unhealthier food sells more. Also, I do not share the hubris that science wins over nature. We have evolved to thrive on what exists in nature, it is not logical to assume we would thrive more with something we are not evolved for. Especially when profit, not health, is the primary driving force. I guess I'll keep eating real meat and real vegetables.
- newsclues 4y agoI don't know why we need science to make healthier versions of food that naturally is healthy. Unless it's science to scale up tradition food systems and abandon the unhealthy food system we have today.
- forgetfulness 4y agoCreating these foods is engineering, we shouldn't conflate it with science or medicine. Engineering can serve a lot of functions in society no doubt, but the price signal baked into the engineering process often makes it so that long-term human welfare is averaged out to matter very little. Whew that was taxing to write in HNglish. My man, look at your second paragraph, even the high tech mitigation strategy you came up with is what can be done in short enough term to be part of a product development process, it won't change anything from the situation now. The problem is not acute toxicity that is measurable in the short term, we have that nailed down or else people would be dropping dead fulminated from new Oreo flavors, but rather very long-term effects, sensors to respond rapidly will do nothing when the problem is what your diet does to you over the course of years.
- robertlagrant 4y agoAn oat drink is even less tech-oriented than Tesla. I'm not sure in what universe Tesla is not only not a tech company, but so un-tech-like that they're closer to a drink company, but I don't think it's this one.
- forgetfulness 4y agoBecause then BMW is also a tech company. Tesla is exempted from being a motor company for some reason, I can only think of it being Elon Musk's personal brand as the cause.
- grumple 4y agoWell, they are at the forefront of two techs - batteries (which is more traditional engineering) and autonomous driving (which despite the problems, they are still known for).
- forgetfulness 4y agoOther motor companies are also investing in autonomous driving. It's just the nature of vehicles, they get more complex all the time. Toyota has announced that it will have autonomous driving by 2025. I'm not sure I believe it, but if the criteria is being working on it, would we be classifying Toyota as a tech company? Vehicles have air conditioning but that doesn't make motor companies appliance companies or HVAC companies either.
- grumple 4y agoI wasn't advocating for a position, just explaining that they clearly lead (or led) in two big technological advances. It depends on what the company's core value proposition is. Toyota's is clearly a car company. Tesla is now more of a car company, but there was a time when they had no or few cars but still had the battery and driving tech. Their valuation and promise was of bringing a new technology to the world, rather than a physical product.
- 4y ago
- substation13 4y agoYes. At least Tesla has a battery-tech / machine learning / robotics angle to it.
- oatman1000 4y agoFirst of all it's not a tech stock, it's a biotech.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> 10 billion dollars for an oat drink company. We're way overdue a correction on tech stocks Oat drink is tech? I am sometimes amazed how people can position a bog-standard business as 'disruptive tech'?
- patentatt 4y agoAt this point 'tech' is more an aesthetic than anything else. Just keep repeating the word 'disruptive' and light a pile of VC money on fire and you're 'tech.' Bonus points if that pile is at least a billion dollars and from some big name foreign entity looking to launder ill-gotten wealth. Whether or not you actually do anything productive or useful is besides the point.
- FooBarBizBazz 4y ago> launder ill-gotten wealth Explain how this works? The Saudi Sovereign Wealth Fund has a bunch of oil money. It's known to be an oppressive regime. It buys a bunch of Uber stock with that money, and its name is now in the cap table. Everyone saw every transaction. Its name is still clearly there. It also doesn't need to turn, say, drug money into carwash profits, to avoid suspicion from tax agencies, because it is the tax agency; it's sovereign. And even if I'm not the Saudi Sovereign Wealth Fund, but a private individual, and I want to launder money, I don't see how buying Uber shares helps me do that, because I will still need to have gotten the cash from somewhere, and buying shares creates no pretext for where that cash might have come from. Unless there's a wash trade thing going on? Where legitimate actor A buys shares to keep the price up, while illegitimate secret ally B sells shares, in order to transfer wealth from one to the other? I don't think that's what you're saying though. So what, really, do you mean? Honestly I'm assuming this is just one of those rhetorical things that we say but haven't really thought about. But if there's meat there, I'd like to know.
- skinnymuch 4y agoLaunder might not be right. Ill-gotten wealth fits though. Gulf oil companies exploit the workers to funnel money to the top. No one is being paid fairly.
- friedman23 4y agoESG as an investment thesis is a sad joke. I wonder how much of the money that was destroyed by investing in oatly was done because of virtue signaling. You couldn't seriously look at projections and think this company would ever be worth $10billion right?
- malfist 4y agoDo you have any evidence that investment in oatly was done because of virtue signaling?
- friedman23 4y agoThe evidence is that an entire class of multi billion dollar companies based on vegetarian and vegan food alternatives exists and they will all go bankrupt or be acquired for pennies on the dollar. So how did VCs get that so wrong other than turning a blind eye to the obviously terrible business models and investing because of their moral beliefs?
- TheCondor 4y agoCatering to vegetarianism is virtue signaling? Aren’t there entire religions (real ones, not, you know, prosperity gospel derivatives) that encourage people to eat more plants? In addition there are lots of nonreligious that support the science that indicates that it is a viable and healthy way to live with lower cases of certain types of heart disease and certain types of cancer and less obesity. I’m certain I know of conservative nonmeat eaters. I sort of expect the market to solve these things. Someone placed a bet, once we process the hell out of soy and make it behave like a hamburger, the entire world will be willing to pay more money for a burger that might not be healthier but will have less saturated fat and no animal product in it. They raised some capital, proved they could build the product, spent and invested to get it in stores and fast food restaurants. Along the way they probably bumped into numerous issues scaling a food enterprise but somehow have managed to stay pretty close to the mission. Turns out that might be a bad bet. What if the veggie burgers were cheaper? What if you have to use GMOs to achieve that price point? Or maybe the idea isn’t that great or the product has some deficiencies, maybe those can be repaired. That’s why we do it. Was the investment because of “moral beliefs” or because it takes billions to get a food to that market? The TAM here is interesting too, it just well distributed which is what makes it expensive.
- itsoktocry 4y ago>We're way overdue a correction on tech stocks, the time for free, cheap money is over These companies have been getting crushed for the past 6-12 months. Oatly is down 83% YTD. The economy has been tightening for months. I think you're a few steps behind the financial machinations in progress.
- oatman1000 4y agoActually, Oatly is a coiled spring and misunderstood by the market. It's actually more of a lifestyle brand, not simply an oat drink as you say...