5 ms·
Federal judge overrules NIH veterinarians about lab chimp retirement
- fredgrott 4y agoI have stupid question Why do we get to elevate chare givers feelings over the well being of those chimps and claim such elevation meets law requirements?
- liveoneggs 4y agoanimals are property - this property was contracted to move into facility X. Failure to do so is a contract breach.
- joxel 4y agoI guess the fact that treating the animals like property leads to unwanted effects begs the question on whether we should be treating animals as property. Clearly there is a difference between an animal and an inanimate object. We have animal welfare and cruelty laws, etc. While this may be legal, whether it is ethical is a more important question. Seems to me it’s time to update the laws that describe living beings the same way as pencils.
- PhasmaFelis 4y agoThis is true but not really relevant, in a "you're in an airplane" sort of way.[1] The chimps in question have no remaining value as property; both parties involved are acting out of their perception of what's best for the animals. [1] https://m.facebook.com/daytondailynews/posts/10155481346940508 https://m.facebook.com/daytondailynews/posts/101554813469405...
- kelnos 4y agoNo, this has nothing to do with contracts or property. A federal law enacted with the intention of protecting post-experimental chimps requires labs (regardless of their other contractual obligations) to relocate chimps to a government sanctuary upon retirement.
- WaitWaitWha 4y agoI wonder how NIH requirements compare to farmers' requirements for animal welfare? My uneducated guess is that NIH is less compliant, and have lower consequences.
- jherskovic 4y agoThe 'caregivers' in this case are professional veterinarians who think the cure can be worse than the disease. The caregivers allege that the chimps are being cared for at a standard that is as high as the one they'd get at the Federal facility, without needing to move them, which causes stress and jeopardizes their well-being as well. Part of the problem here is that the law seems to say "they will be moved to the Federal sanctuary," not "they will be cared in [list of appropriate ways]". To fully comply with the law, you need to move them even if they're sick, have social bonds in their current place, or are perfectly happy. Disclaimer: I've visited one of the non-federal facilities and I've seen retired chimps that looked content. I have zero experience in animal welfare.
- alistairSH 4y agoWhy do we get to elevate chare givers feelings over the well being of those chimps? Where are you reading this? The current caregivers are professional veterinarians and believe the chimps are too sick/elderly to be moved. The law requires the chimps to be moved regardless of their well-being. The judge has followed the letter of the law, but not the intent (because the intent wasn't codified in a way that was clear). Congress wrote a shitty law; the judge is following it.
- kortilla 4y agoWhy do you presume to know the intent? The law may have been written to ensure the chimps are out of their experimenters’ confines, regardless of how good said experimenters claim the chimps had it.
- kelnos 4y agoIf that's the intent, then that's a stupid, vindictive intent. The law should be written to protect the well being of the animals, and ensure the best outcome for them. Anything else is not something I'd care to support, anyway. > regardless of how good said experimenters claim the chimps had it. Had is not the operative word here: have is. The veterinarians at the lab claim that they currently receive as good or better care than they'd receive at the sanctuary. Certainly that claim should be evaluated by an independent third-party, but, frankly, the chimp's quality of life in the past (such as when they were experimental subjects) isn't particularly relevant now. All that matters (ethically) is the level of care they get now, and the likely negatives to their well being that moving them would cause. Sure, one can reasonably disagree with the lab vets' assessment. But I don't think any of us here are in the position to have an informed opinion on that. All of it is pretty moot, though, as the law doesn't seem to provide any exceptions. If that is indeed the case (and the NIH either chooses not to appeal, or does and fails), they'll be forced to relocate... assuming they live that long, anyway.
- dirtybirdnj 4y agoBecause the people who've been doing the work caring for the chimps before this ruling probably have a good idea of what will / won't work with the individual animals. Some people decided to make laws with hard and specific rules without considering the downstream ramifications. It's a social failure to adapt to the situation. We must ignore the experts because the rules say so. We must kill the chimps from stress by moving them because what the caretakers have to say has no standing in the legal world. If "the law" is on your side there is no slope too slippery that can't overcome pesky constraints of morality or reality.
- Consultant32452 4y agoBut what if they are infected with rage? /28 days later
- Georgelemental 4y agoIt's called "rabies" in English
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jefftk 4y agoSummary: the NIH veterinarians responsible for these chimps claim they are old and sick, and would be better off "retired in place". The ruling says that doesn't matter, and they're required to be moved to the federal sanctuary because the law explicitly requires that.
- strangattractor 4y agoThought they were talking about grad students at first:)
- abruzzi 4y agothe photo of the top is chimp haven, which doens't look like that nice a place--but I suspect that the other options are picturaesque either. And that chimp in the photo--has a cigarette in his mouth. Obviously I don't think its lit up and he's smoking, but is he copying humans?
- jefftk 4y agoChimps sometimes hang out with sticks in their mouths in a way that looks like smoking, but they do this in the wild too. Sort of like the traditional caricature of a farmer or cowboy with a stalk of wheat or other grass in their teeth.
- smugma 4y agoIt’s by a fake termite mound. My guess was that it’s a stick used to prod the mound.
- kbelder 4y agoHumans aren't the only animals with oral fixations, although I don't know how widely it's present. Indulging in pop-psych, possibly it's a part of all mammalian psychology.
- sigzero 4y agoHSUS seems like they are just being unreasonable in the article and don't really have the animals best interest in mind.
- mfer 4y agoThere's a lot we don't know here. For example: 1. What's the difference in care between where they are at and the sanctuary? That doesn't appear to be stated so we can only make assumptions. 2. The facilities that want to keep them are the ones that experimented on them. They may also be the ones employing the vets. Is there something they don't want others to see? As a place that experimented on animals you have to wonder if they did things they don't want people to generally know about. These questions aren't answered. How we fill in the blanks depends on our own assumptions or outside info we may be aware of. As a reader I'm left wondering and don't really have enough information to make an informed assessment.
- sigzero 4y agoYeah, I was actually coming back to edit my remark to say "That might not be the case" since it's a perception I get from the article.
- _HMCB_ 4y agoThis is a perfect example of where thorough reading (not the first few paragraphs only) sheds light on the matter. Two ears and one mouth.
- harpiaharpyja 4y agoYes, the headline is particularly misleading.
- boomboomsubban 4y agoThorough reading presents both arguments, but I certainly didn't finish the article with any idea what course of action would actually be better for the chimps.
- kelnos 4y agoBecause it's just not clear. It depends on if you trust the veterinarians in the lab to provide an objective assessment, and also just believe that they are correct. And I do wonder if they might be correct for some of the animals, but not all, so maybe some should be kept to retire in place, and some should be sent to the shelter. Regardless, on a more personal note, I wouldn't want to subject my cat to the kind of transportation and relocation they're talking about, regardless of health or age. And I believe chimps are much more self-aware and intelligent than cats; I expect they'd find it much more stressful. I think this is a case where the law was well-intentioned, but didn't provide any escape hatches for situations not considered by the law.
- CobrastanJorji 4y agoIt's true. I saw the headline and thought "wow, what a thoroughly evil thing to be on the side of not sending chimps to a sanctuary," but the NIH's stance seemed extremely reasonable.
- dang 4y agoOk, we've attempted to give the article a more neutral title. If anyone can suggest a better title (i.e. more accurate and neutral, preferably using representative language from the article), we can change it again.
- hammock 4y ago
- JadeNB 4y agoThat seems like idle speculation with a question mark. Of course there's a possibility, in the sense that it's not impossible. But how would any of us here know if it's anything more than that?
- KineticLensman 4y ago> thus posing a risk to public health by not being put down Nothing in the article is about putting the chimps down (for whatever reason). The options mentioned are 1) leave them in place vs 2) rehome them at a dedicated retirement facility.
- theptip 4y agoAn interesting book is “Chimpanzee politics”, which details the raucous power struggles and intricate social interactions within a troop of chimps. Eye opening in its complexity. I do wonder about the social ramifications of moving them; this part in particular is key: > Then they would face a world of strangers and uncertain social groupings—intensely stressful to old chimps with established conspecific and human families I think on balance it’s probably misguided to move chimps like this. Better to regulate the quality of care in situ and only move them if it’s deemed to be sub-par. If you start a chimp colony you should be on the hook for ensuring they have a good life in perpetuity, in my book. The great apes have moral value closest to humans of all the animals.
- polishdude20 4y ago>Then they would face a world of strangers and uncertain social groupings—intensely stressful to old chimps with established conspecific and human families. It seems like we do this to humans all the time and don't batt an eye. I'm not saying we should not extend this courtesy to chimps but it seems like there's more care taken here for these chimps than we give to humans.
- kodah 4y agoI very much dislike that we callously move people around and have systems that reinforce it. Some people, namely the ones having to do it, adapt to it but it's still not great or even good.
- ethbr0 4y agoThe moral difference is that the chimps have no say in their movement. So it's more like forcibly relocating humans. Which we've historically done, but generally try to not do now, Russia aside.
- theptip 4y agoThe big difference I see with the case you're considering is that humans have agency, and can choose for themselves whether to move or stay. (Even though harsh circumstances might strongly influence their decision - still, it's their choice by their evaluation of the trade-offs.) With chimps, we are not asking them what they want; we're making the decision for them. Therefore we carry all of the burden of responsibility that would usually rest with the individual making the decision for themselves. Indeed the only reason they are in this captive environment is because we kidnapped/bred them and put them there. So that's another layer of responsibility that we have for their situation that doesn't apply to normal human decisions.
- M2Ys4U 4y agoI misread NIH as NIF for a second there and was very confused as to why chimps were researching nuclear fusion.
- GCA10 4y agoAnd then you're just one more letter glitch away from reading it as NFTs. Which would be marvelous, because then bored apes would be researching Bored Apes.
- LarryMullins 4y agoChimps have immense strength, they could be used to compress hydrogen until it fuses.
- yazzku 4y agoThey should really ask the chimps what they think about Chimp "Haven" for a fully unbiased report. "Yeah, it's pretty rad," said Joseph, 22, male, originally from San Francisco. "I was paying $4000/mo in rent and when a friend of mine told me about Chimp Haven, I was like 'Yo, def gotta check out that place.'"
- iav 4y agoSort of related - the price of chimps has gone up 10x during COVID from $2k to $20k. Multiple factors, there was a corruption scandal in Cambodia (see ticker NOTV that is being investigated) that caused those exports to stop and China has stopped exporting chimps because their own pharma industry is booming
- weberer 4y agoWow, I never expected to see chimp inflation at this scale. I laughed off my friend who kept a stack of chimps under his mattress, but look who's laughing now.
- pyuser583 4y agoSeems the law is clear and the th judge sided with the law. Congress didn’t want the NIH to have the discretion to refuse to send retired chimps to the haven. NIH is now saying it knows best. Maybe they do, but it’s not their call. Thank you Congress for making a clear law!
- dumbotron 4y ago> NIH is now saying it knows best Considering this law was passed, I have to doubt their judgement.
- jamesliudotcc 4y agoThe NIH, like most federal agencies, is used to this legal doctrine known as "deference," which comes in many flavors, usually you will hear of "Chevron deference." The general idea is, (step 1) when Congress does not specify what should be done, (step 2) the agency's decision need only be "reasonable." In this context, "reasonable" means "a lawyer spent words writing it," which given how the government operates, is almost always the case. So here, Congress _did_ specify what was to be done. Oh. So no deference for you. It's really hard to figure out what to write in legislation. It is also somewhat hard to update the legislation to accord with new but subtle understandings, especially considering how much attention Congress members can possibly have as compared to how much law is in the books (go to a law library, look at a copy of the United States Code without the annotations, and consider how long it would take to read it, and that is only the beginning). But it is better when courts apply the law as written than making stuff up to suit their preferences, constrained by their prior precedents (assuming you are still at a law library, look at a copy of the United States Reports -- all the Supreme Court opinions ever -- and consider how long it would take to read that, and that is only the beginning).
- pyuser583 4y agoI live in Wisconsin. We have an agency called the Legislative Reference Bureau. They are civil servants who write the laws, They’re very good at their jobs. Wisconsin laws are very clear, and rarely overturned by courts. Of course, there’s a downside. In 2008, the Democrats won a strong trifecta: control of legislature, governorship, and Supreme Court. In 2009, the Democrats ordered the LRB to draft legislation to gerrymander the state, locking in Democratic rule. In 2010, the Democrats lost control of the legislature and governorship in 2010. After the census was finished, the Republicans used that legislation for its intended purpose: one party rule. Now the Republicans have total control of the legislature, and the LRB pops out conservative policy after conservative policy, all at tax-payer expense.