4 ms·
No, he’s saying “we can’t rule it out, but the evidence doesn’t currently support the assertions being made about trans generational epigenetic transmission.”
by rayiner 4y ago
No, he’s saying “we can’t rule it out, but the evidence doesn’t currently support the assertions being made about trans generational epigenetic transmission.”
- 082349872349872 4y agoconsider also that nurture is a major confounding factor. I am skeptical in part because I should think that if the Soviets could have demonstrated Lamarckism, they would've.
- type0 4y ago> if the Soviets could have demonstrated Lamarckism, they would've. They tried to demonstrate a form of Lamarckism - Lysenkoism, resulting in countless deaths across Siberia, especially among ethnic minorities that were deported there. https://www.encyclopedia.com/science/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/disastrous-effects-lysenkoism-soviet-agriculture https://www.encyclopedia.com/science/encyclopedias-almanacs-...
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoThe title of his article includes "You can’t take it with you". That is not anything close to implying "we can’t rule it out". I know the evidence does not totally support epigenetic transmission, but it is pointing towards that conclusion. What we need is more evidence, not dismissing it on the basis of not knowing. Besides, it just makes sense biologically. Why would we not have a biological system that prepared offspring for risks or even changes in the environment?
- rayiner 4y ago> I know the evidence does not totally support epigenetic transmission, but it is pointing towards that conclusion. The point of the article is the opposite: that the evidence is pointing away from epigenetic transmission. Acknowledging that we can’t yet rule out epigenetic transmission doesn’t undermine the point that the existing evidence is pointing away from it.
- oa335 4y agoWhat evidence in particular? I scanned the article but couldn’t find much.
- robertlagrant 4y ago> Besides, it just makes sense biologically. I think the author is trying to pursuade us that this sort of instinct is not sufficient to base large social theories on.