3 ms·
> “This woman probably belonged to the first generation of English Christians in this part of England,” Francis Young, a historian of religion who was not invol
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
> “This woman probably belonged to the first generation of English Christians in this part of England,” Francis Young, a historian of religion who was not involved in the excavation, told The Post. “This is people wanting to show off their newly acquired identity as Christians.”
Artifact interpretation is always so tendentious. Lots of people wear necklaces with a cross pendant today. They are mostly not trying to show off their newly acquired identity as Christians.
- rhn_mk1 4y agoMost people wearing necklaces are not first generation Christians. After you eliminate those, why are the remaining necklace-wearing ones doing it?
- tommica 4y agoBecause its a pretty necklace?
- rhn_mk1 4y agoFor generic necklaces yes, but when we're talking about necklaces with a religious symbol on them, I'm not so sure.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoI'm pretty sure though; many people wear or use religious symbolism without being religious themselves or aware of it being a religious symbol. (not just physical items like jewelry, think behaviours or sayings as well).
- ceejayoz 4y agoWe should at least consider the possibility that a domain expert may have knowledge not included in that single sentence given to a reporter.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoThis is exactly the idea that I'm pointing out is false. You should not consider that possibility; that is not the way interpretation of archaeological artifacts is done, particularly when talking to reporters.
- eckmLJE 4y agoI think you may be misreading this. This isn't about some person becoming a new Christian. It's about a member of high society wearing a cross during a turbulent period of competing peoples within Britain shifting from paganism to Christianity, at a time when religious symbolism was central to (synonymous with?) political symbolism.