6 ms·
Everything i have heard about this makes it sound more like a milestone than a breakthrough. I.e. its great it happened and an important step, but its not shock
by bawolff 4y ago
Everything i have heard about this makes it sound more like a milestone than a breakthrough. I.e. its great it happened and an important step, but its not shocking that we eventually did it.
When i hear breakthrough i think of something more unexpected. I.e. figuring out how to solve a problem we had no idea how to solve.
- vesinisa 4y agoExactly.. The article fails to answer the question posed by its very title. What I've gathered, this was a very much expected result and NOT a "breakthrough". And with regards to making fusion a viable source for commercial, large-scale energy production .. this is only tangential at best to that effort. The problem with celebrating "fake victories" (and being scolded for calling them out) is that when there really is a breakthrough (i.e. something so big it fundamentally changes our perception of the problem), people are going to think you are making just another over-hyped publicity stunt. I am definitely of the opinion that such media attention focused advertising of (otherwise perfectly valid) fundamental research is doing no one favors (not the researches nor the public.)
- tpmx 4y agoAnother danger: I've seen quite a few people arguing in (a European context) that we shouldn't build out nuclear in the "short term", "since we can just get fusion without any of the downsides of fission".
- jokteur 4y agoI've seen also people arguing that we should never ever build nuclear fission again because it is "bad". What I want to say is that bad faith arguments will always exist, and calling this a breakthrough won't significantly increase the number of people using bad faith arguments, because they would just find another excuse instead of the fusion one.
- zmgsabst 4y agoTheir chart seems to indicate that this is a qualitative improvement where the kind of fusion produced substantially changed. I share your skepticism towards commercial impact — but this is certainly a breakthrough in their technology. Just look at the chart. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Ignition_Facility#/media/File%3ANIF_output_over_10_years.png https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Ignition_Facility#/...
- dotnet00 4y agoI feel like HN is being especially pedantic and jaded about this specifically and I don't really get why. Scientifically this is absolutely a breakthrough, just like the detection of the Higgs boson was despite them already having expected it or just like LIGO's detections of gravitational waves were despite that being entirely what it was built for or just as JWST's detections of galaxies much older than those seen from other telescopes was despite that being part of the entire point of dumping billions into it. Ingenuity's first flight was also hailed as a breakthrough despite that being exactly what it was designed to do. In every case we had an idea of how to solve a problem and the outcome was generally expected. All that had changed was that the data had been collected of the solution working, just as it has been in this case. To put it differently, it's a breakthrough because after decades of work, the National Ignition Facility can actually achieve the thing in its name.
- Hnrobert42 4y agoExactly. If you look closely enough, no breakthroughs appear completely out of nowhere.
- jacquesm 4y agoI think after decades of fusion 'breakthroughs' people have become a bit jaded and would simply like to short-cut to the point where there is a fusion reactor in a box that produces more energy out than is put in.
- gaoshan 4y agoResponding in a pedantic/jaded manner is one way to assert a form of intellectual dominance. For this audience I feel like that sort of dominance is unsurprising.
- zug_zug 4y agoAgreed, but I think it has the side-effect of signaling "This technology advancement isn't worth excitement/praise/prestige" which I think in this case could have effects like demotivating people who might be considering going into the field.
- kreco 4y ago> Everything i have heard about this makes it sound more like a milestone than a breakthrough. I guess milestone assume you already know you will reach it. I also think breakthrough as a lot of meaning and people would assume there is a few years before a real application. In a sense it's probably a breakthrough within the scientific ring rather than from the people perspective.
- nend 4y agoBreakthrough: 1. a sudden advance especially in knowledge or technique 2. an act or instance of moving through or beyond an obstacle Milestone: 1. an action or event marking a significant change or stage in development. I'm failing to see why labeling it one or the other even matters.
- felipellrocha 4y agoSome people think semantics is a good spend of time... These same people tend to amount to nothing, so I just ignore nowadays.
- walnutclosefarm 4y agoExactly. If there was a breakthrough at all, it in 2021, when NIF finally reached the point of "burning plasma." But breakthrough, or milestone, I fear it may all be for naught. The improvements over the last two years are essentially all due to changes in the hohlraum geometry and preparation. All good, if your goal is to get burning plasmas to study. But NIF is orders of magnitude away from anything useful for power production. They have a Q of 1.5, but need something more like 100. They have a cycle time of, maybe, .1 shot/hour, and need something like 10,000/hour. Some real breakthroughs in the lasers (or maybe particle beams instead), coupling, and scale, not fine tuning of hohlraum shape, are needed.
- poopbutt7 4y agoAgreed, and I'm concerned that this journalistic malpractice will devalue legitimate breakthroughs.