5 ms·
Couldn't agree more on this. The market forces governing new home construction are completely broken and nothing short of government is going to change that. It
by Spivak 4y ago
Couldn't agree more on this. The market forces governing new home construction are completely broken and nothing short of government is going to change that. It is genuinely a travesty how bad in virtually every aspect new construction it and the lack of investment in minimizing long-term tcoo is going to bite us down the line. I almost cant even blame the builders, you literally can't source quality materials at prices affordable by a family. The bit about humans evolving polyamory in response to housing prices is feeling less and less like a joke every day. Inflation plus a generation of wage stagnation has made it so that house prices are still outpacing the savings from cheaper construction which is an everyone looses situation.
- onphonenow 4y agoExcept govt intervention is why we have crazy 6,000 square feet per unit minimums
- sokoloff 4y agoIs that a land area requirement (about 7 units to an acre), or gross living area requirement? Requiring 6K ft^2 of the latter is quite high for a government-imposed requirement (and therefore likely not common enough to be a major source of overall housing pressure).
- zip1234 4y agoIt depends on the area. For example a city near me requires 60 feet of road frontage in 90% of the city in order to build a house. Maximum height 30 ft, side setbacks required a total of 15 feet. Front setback required 20 ft. Only 35% of the lot is allowed to be covered by buildings. No ADUs allowed. If the government addressed this problem, there could be a lot more construction.
- onphonenow 4y agoLand area requirements are commonly 5,000 sq feet in cities
- zip1234 4y agoThe government has been subsidizing home construction in the form of mortgage interest deduction, federally insured mortgages, and interest rates. None have helped solve the problem, which is simply that homes are not allowed to be built in areas they are desired. A developer can make a nice efficient design for an attractive building and then go through 3 years of reviews because of zoning and nimbyism and ultimately get nothing built. Solve zoning and housing affordability will massively improve.
- refurb 4y agoProblem: building new homes is impossible due to restrictions and costs imposed by government regulation. Solution: We need more government regulation!
- Spivak 4y agoNot everyone lives in SF but the problem is everywhere. Even in areas where the city doesn’t give a shit houses aren’t magically higher quality. The problem is bigger than your local city planners. Go get all housing regulations repealed for all I care, it won’t fix the problem.
- germandiago 4y agothis does not mean more regulations would fix it.
- germandiago 4y agoI see this attitude in lots of problems. Idk or can figure out why ppl think that throwing more gast at the problem might lead to the solution. Not only in this case.
- Spivak 4y agoBecause market failures exist and one of the main goals of gov't is to change the incentives to correct them. Right now the failure is in long term planning and a total lack of investment in the longevity and energy efficiency in new home construction that, to me, is the direct result of real purchasing power of the average family dropping and builders having to do their equivalent of shrinkflation. The correction proposed in this article of gov't requiring that new homes be energy efficient and directly paying for it I think strikes the right balance. I would even go further and put money up for every home to be updated and retrofitted. Government regulation bad market good is too naive and is a meaningless statement in abstract. You have to look at each case and the real effects market distortions will have.
- 4y ago