28 ms·
Does it bug anyone else that they don't play enough games to actually reasonably determine 2nd and 3rd place among the 4 semi-finalists? The current system of
by tzs 4y ago
Does it bug anyone else that they don't play enough games to actually reasonably determine 2nd and 3rd place among the 4 semi-finalists?
The current system of having two teams that win in the semi-finals play a game to determine the final winner, and the two teams that lose in the semi-finals play a third place play-off only actually determines who is 1st (the winner of the final) and who is 4th (the loser of the third place play off).
In years like this one, where the winner of the third play play-off (Croatia) loses in the semi-finals to the eventual winner of the final (Argentina), we get no information on how they compare to the loser of the final (France).
In years where the winner of the third place play off played the loser of the final in the semi-finals, we then do have enough information to rank all 4. The winner of the finals is #1 with no losses, the loser of the final and the winner of the third place play-off both have 1 loss, but they played each other in the final so we can order them, giving the loser of the final 2nd place, the winner of the third place play-off 3rd place, and the loser of that 4th place.
In years like this one, we are missing that game between the loser of the final and the winner of the third place playoff, who both have 1 loss, to order them, so all we can reasonable say this year is Argentina is in 1st, France and Croatia are 2nd and 3rd but we don't know which is which, and Morocco is 4th.
I suppose as a practical matter they don't want to have a France/Croatia game to figure it out because that game would come after the final and they want the final to be the last. But why not determine who gets 2nd and who gets 3rd by applying the tie breaks they use in the group stage?
- magarnicle 4y agoI don't think most of the players really care. Watch the body language of France after they lost: second means nothing to them. Some of them ripped their medal off as soon as they got it.