4 ms·
The role of drought during the Hunnic European incursions in the 4th-5th C. CE
- 082349872349872 4y agoThe desire for gold may indicate that the Huns thought of themselves as short-timers. A European group in this period would perhaps have conquered the provinces and stayed, extracting rents as a local aristocracy (cf Anglo-Normans), but the Huns are said to have been interested in taking high value-to-weight assets, suitable for transport (back to wherever their normal pastures were?).
- fsckboy 4y agoit's really remarkable how little we know about who the Huns were, including where they really came from or even went for that matter.
- jaclaz 4y ago>The violence of the Hunnic elites that was so dramatically recorded in late Roman written sources could thus have been a consequence of climatic fluctuations in the first half of the 5th c. Or possibly the descriptions were largely fabricated by the Romans in their writings, that the article itself specifies as being largely non-contemporary.
- Simon_O_Rourke 4y agoI think it's safe to assume they were properly violent, however maligned they may have been by Roman sources.
- jaclaz 4y agoSurely, rarely invaders (successful ones) have not been violent, historically. But I don't think that the Goths, the Gauls and the Romans were that much less violent in fights. And if the cause is the draught, then it should have raised the violence in all the populations affected in the area, not only the Huns.
- 082349872349872 4y agoOne violence advantage pastoral peoples have over settled is that they are accustomed to herding, and driving said herds to slaughter; we have several thousands of years of history that tell us it is relatively common for h sapiens to take a skill once learned for dealing with 4 legged animals and apply it to 2 legged. (another example: cartoon feudalism is the notion that dominance relations in a herd are also the proper organising metaphor for human society)
- chrisco255 4y agoThere's evidence of brutal violence between human tribes going far back into hunter-gatherer days as well. Even our closest primate cousins, the chimps, engage in brutal violence between each other: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gombe_Chimpanzee_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gombe_Chimpanzee_War
- jessaustin 4y agoThat's true, but it operates at a different level than parent is talking about. Romans and Huns were both human, so they both had a capacity for violence. Performance improves with practice, however. Parent contends that the inherent (inter-species) violence of pastoral life functioned as practice for the Huns' violent conflict with Rome. That isn't totally convincing, given that Rome at that time had dominated pastoral cultures for hundreds of years. It's possible that Rome had become more vulnerable, and the Huns just had good timing.
- 082349872349872 4y agoGood point, although I'll note that Romans were known for their infantry, and their armies tended to recruit non-Roman (pastoral?) auxiliaries for cavalry.
- krisoft 4y ago> Parent contends that the inherent (inter-species) violence of pastoral life functioned as practice for the Huns' violent conflict with Rome. But the Romans also butchered animals at massive scales. Why would there be more inter-species violence in pastoral life than in settled life?
- thom 4y agoIt’s naturally mentioned in the article, as one of the main sources for the period, but I’ve always enjoyed Priscus’s account of his dinner with Attila: https://faculty.georgetown.edu/jod/texts/priscus.html https://faculty.georgetown.edu/jod/texts/priscus.html Meanwhile, this is an interesting paper. Kyle Harper’s The Fate of Rome advances climate change and disease as some primary drivers of the Western Empire’s collapse, both internally and externally. He uses a somewhat hotly contested theory that the Huns were actually driven from as far away as Tibet by drought (the evidence of drought in the East from juniper tree rings mentioned in the article is quite strong). But clearly drought affected peoples far to the West as well so the argument need not rest in the Hun-Xiongnu link. Of course, it’s still fairly likely that the empire would have fallen even if the Huns had retired to some quiet, evergreen pasture elsewhere.
- 082349872349872 4y ago> Attila ate nothing but meat on a wooden trencher. In everything else, too, he showed himself temperate; his cup was of wood, while to the guests were given goblets of gold and silver. His dress, too, was quite simple, affecting only to be clean. Attila was a hipster before it was cool? At the very least he was countersignalling: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33942670 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33942670
- thom 4y agoIn fairness, all his fancy cups had been swindled by Silvanus.
- yosito 4y agoI didn't notice it specifically mentioned in the article, but it's worth noting that the Huns were most likely a completely different group than the Hungarians. Historical evidence of what happened is thin, but one likely theory is that the Huns terrorized Europe first, and then the 13 Magyar tribes (modern Hungarians) migrated from north-central Asia and took advantage of the Huns' fearsome reputation whereby Europeans began calling them Hungarians. Modern Hungarians still refer to themselves as Magyar, terms derived from Hun tend to be used by foreigners. Either way, modern Hungarians are genetically Slavic and European. The language of the Magyars has long outlasted the genes. The name Attila is still popular in modern Hungary though.