4 ms·
Helicon is as far as I can tell the least likely fusion effort to actually succeed because they are making serious hype without producing any data to actually b
by Retric 4y ago
Helicon is as far as I can tell the least likely fusion effort to actually succeed because they are making serious hype without producing any data to actually back it up. As well as making some wild claims that don’t match up with reality. A single advancement is vastly more believable but when they are suggesting so many advantages such as not needing tritium or steam turbines the most likely thing is for them to just be lying.
At a more practical level, any device actually producing non trivial amounts of fusion using helium 3 would quickly make the device extremely radioactive from all the high energy protons being produced.
PS: DD fusion produces H3 half the time, it also produces tritium the other half which isn’t generally going to be a waste product it’s going to fuse in the reaction chamber filled with D producing very high enegry neutrons.
- pfdietz 4y ago"Helicon". I hope that's an accidental mispelling, not libel. Why exactly do you think they need to provide public data? They're a company, not academics. They've provided data to their funders, who have also had external experts review the results, including the famous JASON physicists. The result of this got them $500M for Polaris and another $1.7B conditioned on the success of that machine. My impression of Helion is from when I thought their ideas didn't work. This invariably ended up being because I had some misunderstanding of what they were doing. When I thought of a concern, I would find they had already addressed it. This makes all of the things they're doing ring very true. Maybe it will end up not working, but it's not because of anything obvious. Your comment about high energy protons is wrong. The fraction of MeV-scale protons that will undergo a nuclear reaction in a target is very small and drops to essentially zero if the material has high atomic number (because the Coulomb barrier is too high). The induced radioactivity from the protons will be negligible in a properly designed system. About the tritium: the pulse in Helion's design is so short that the tritium nuclei do not have time to thermalize. At the energy they are initially produced the DT fusion cross section is about an order of magnitude smaller. So, most of the T (I'm estimating all but a few percent) will not fuse before the pulse ends. If they have a gas with a low D:3He ratio, DT fusion is suppressed even more. They appear to planning a scheme where there are DD reactors that make 3He, and then D3He reactors that consume it. The latter could be designed with a much more favorable neutron environment.
- Retric 4y agoThey are unquestionably creating Hype without releasing data because that’s what’s best for the company. It’s fine for a private company to maintain stealth, but the combination of hype and not releasing meaningful metrics is a very bad sign. High energy Neutrons are nasty, the issue with high atomic number shielding is it doesn’t slow them down very well. Sort of like tossing a ping pong ball at a bowling ball it just doesn’t transfer much energy. Even 1% Tritium would be a problem.
- pfdietz 4y agoI'm sorry, but the standard you are asserting there is simply ridiculous. You would have them be unable to say anything about what they are doing (the topic would ensure great interest which you call hype) without sharing all details. Of course neutrons will cause issues, but the point is the very energetic ones could be much less of a problem than in a DT reactor. It might make the difference between replacing the first wall once a year and replacing it once a decade (say). I will add that the cylindrical geometry should make such replacement much easier. I advise you to study what they've said with an open mind. I believe you'll change your opinion, or at least convince you to reserve judgment.
- Retric 4y agoJust build a working device and I am easily convinced, except why would they care about what I think if they have that. It’s really the technical details they are providing actually makes them seem more like a scam, if they shared less it might seem more reasonable. But sharing a lot except any relevant numbers while suggesting it’s ready soon screams scam. For example they need 2 DD reactions to on average produce 1 H3 which means their producing more high energy neutrons than a pure DT design for the same energy. If T is a waste product then they need to do separation etc. At the same time they are also going to have some DT reactions which means they will need basically identical radiation shielding either way. The idea of extracting energy from magnetic field interactions sounds plausible until you consider all the waste heat that’s being produced. Even if everything worked as described they would still want massive amounts of cooling which is either a problem or another power source. If they had said they are using a mix of both that would be far more believable.
- schiffern 4y ago>A single advancement is vastly more believable but when they are suggesting so many advantages such as not needing tritium or steam turbines the most likely thing is for them to just be lying. It's so strange to see someone use a PR logic process ("optics") to evaluate a technical claim, rather than using physics and engineering. The advanced fuel cycle and the direct conversion of plasma pressure to energy are connected. The former enables the latter, and the latter is quite clever.
- aardvarkr 4y ago>It's so strange to see someone use a PR logic process ("optics") to evaluate a technical claim, rather than using physics and engineering. I think it’s fair to apply the “smell test” in this case. We’ve recently see several high profile collapses of fraudulent companies like Nikola and Theranos that claimed to have miraculous technology breakthroughs. Nikola claimed to have solve problems in hydrogen synthesis, transportation, fueling, electricity generation, engine miniaturization, and more. They didn’t have a piece of that technological chain and yet made some incredibly bold claims so they could continue inflating the hype around the company and skyrocket its valuation. I’m not saying Helion is in the same boat as Nikola but it’s fair to be skeptical.
- moloch-hai 4y agoHelion is anyway the least obviously fraudulent of all the fusion startups. So if your skepticism budget is limited, save it for the other guys.
- kabouseng 4y agoJust like FTX was the least fraudulent looking of all the crypto exchanges a couple of months ago... :-)
- moloch-hai 4y agoMy exposure to crypto exchange fraud and to fusion startup fraud are both zero. People with different levels of exposure will need to evaluate accordingly.