4 ms·
With work fromn home and the efficiency, its worth asking if billion-dollar right-of-way public transiy makes sense anywhere. Waymo is to rail as packet-based n
by xnx 4y ago
With work fromn home and the efficiency, its worth asking if billion-dollar right-of-way public transiy makes sense anywhere. Waymo is to rail as packet-based networking is to dedicated copper analog phone lines.
- johannes1234321 4y agoYes, a car can bring people point to point, however it still isn't space efficient. Each traveller in their own vehicle is read of a compact bus or train. Still requiring broad roads and space in the attractive areas.
- ghaff 4y agoGiven autonomous driving, computer-dispatched and scheduled mini-buses and vans could make sense for a lot of scenarios where there's reasonable demand and no transit.
- mrshadowgoose 4y agoYes, cars are less space efficient. However, what is the objective line of "too space inefficient", and are cars over that line? If not, why should one care? We aren't optimizing for "most space efficient as possible", there are other factors in the mix. Despite all the complaining, Western society seems to generally be accepting of the space inefficiency of cars as it currently stands. And computer modelling has shown that, all other things being equal, autonomous vehicles are expected to increase the capacity of existing roadways. Also, don't forget that a lot of people want to get around in a car, regardless of bus/train availability, despite what your personal feelings on the subject might be. However, don't get me wrong here, a lot of people also want to get around on foot, by bike, and by bus. Admittedly these options are lacking in most Western urban environments. We should also be building up these options for the people who want to use them. Transportation doesn't have to be a winner-take-all, one-solution-for-everyone fight. Different people want different things, and there's no reason that transportation options shouldn't reflect this.
- themacguffinman 4y agoBecause of global warming? The idea is fairly straightforward: - less space efficient means less fuel efficient which means heavier carbon footprint - less space efficient means more vehicles which means heavier carbon footprint - less space efficient encourages suburban sprawl which means lower city service efficiency which means heavier carbon footprint - less space efficient encourages suburban sprawl which means more efficient alternatives like public transit are more costly and less convenient which means heavier carbon footprint You say transportation doesn't have to be a winner-take-all fight but that completely ignores market/political forces shaped by city planning. You handwave it away by saying "admittedly these options are lacking in most Western urban environments" but why do you think that is? It's a consequence of American city space-inefficiency which makes efficient public transit worse and favors inefficient cars. It doesn't have to be winner-take-all, winner-take-most is enough to change climate change outcomes significantly.
- mrshadowgoose 4y agoOn the converse, you don't get to say the words "global warming" to handwave away human wants and desires. Especially when there are alternative solutions that allow car users to keep doing their thing, while also completely mitigating global warming concerns. Carbon footprints can be offset. It just needs to be done honestly. Specifically, an "honest offset" is an offset that has already occurred prior to purchase of the offset, and prior to the production of the carbon being offset. If vehicular use was required to be honestly offset, your global warming concerns completely evaporate. It really is that simple. The one downside is that you don't get the emotional satisfaction of "sticking it" to car users. If your sincere and sole goal is to fight global warming, you have to remember that most people simply do not care. If your proposed solution is to take comfortable things away from people that want those comfortable things, you are simply going to lose.
- themacguffinman 4y agoThere's nothing really fundamental about humans wanting cars. In European cities with a long history of public transit, people like public transit. In American cities where cars have been king for a long time and have almost never been pressured to build good public transit, people like cars. Public transit can be comfortable. If vehicular use was required to be honestly offset, the comfortable thing that is the modern car and suburban sprawl would no longer be affordable. I don't doubt that most people don't care, it's why we're in this mess in the first place. It's also why humanity is on track to lose a lot to the damage from climate change. I find myself wondering whether I care either, I appreciate the reminder that I'm simply going to lose even if I do.
- abecedarius 4y agoOnce robocars are clearly about ready to scale up, there'll be a variety of designs including one- or two-passenger cars. Conversely, buses usually go mostly empty except during rush hour. Finally, small on-demand robocars should be a great way to conveniently connect to a local train station and then to your ultimate destination, raising demand for complementary mass transit.
- xnx 4y agoMass transit is often less cost (and therefore environmentally) efficient than private vehicles per passenger mile. Multi-ton busses and trains run empty most of the time. A self-driving car never wastes a trip.
- mrshadowgoose 4y agoI've also had a variation of this thought, and have received mostly revulsion from my fairly technical social circles. When most people think of "public transit", they only picture busses, trains and multi-billion dollar corruption-laden mass transit projects. However, in many cases, it is far far cheaper to (as a municipal government) purchase and operate fleets of self-driving electric vehicles. Don't get me wrong, there are still cases where dedicated rights-of-way for trains make more sense, but we should be using the optimal solution for each given situation, and the optimal solution is not always "trains and busses". "Public transit" can also be "publicly owned electric self-driving vehicles, making use of the roads that already exist". However, a lot of people have an entrenched opinion of "CAR BAD NO MATTER WHAT", with no objective basis of what "bad" is.