3 ms·
US Copyright Office refuses application with AI algorithm named as author
- jacquesm 4y agoI wonder what the implications are for AI generated code. The implications for that could be massive, including all code generated by tools such as co-pilot.
- rjzzleep 4y agoI was wondering the same. If you can feed a bunch of code into an AI and then use the generated code that's basically like a money mixer. Do you get to decompile things then and then feed them with existing code into an AI? Can you reuse the leaked Microsoft code when you mix it with other code into a dataset? Can a third party do it and you claim ignorance when you use it?
- namaria 4y agoLegal matters don't exist in a vacuum. Short answer is: yes you can do all of those things. But some of them might land you in hot water if done in the context of a contract. Copyright is not absolute, it's about what potential claims people might have.
- dsr_ 4y agoLet's consider some simplified cases. A. I get a copy of ChatGPT's code (via some legitimate means) and train it exclusively on my written work. I argue that all output from the dsr_%_ChatGPT instance is derivative from my work. I assert that when I prompt it, the results are also my work. Further, when someone else prompts it, the results are infringing on my work. B. Same as A, but I train it 50% on my written work and 50% on jacquesm's written work. I assert that when I prompt it, the results always infringe on jacquesm, and if jacquesm prompts it, the results always infringe on me. Does anyone disagree with either of the above?
- jacquesm 4y agoThat's a very interesting way to try to find the line.
- candiddevmike 4y agoWhat part of ML is copyrightable/considered IP?
- detaro 4y agoIt's far less general than the headline suggests, to the point of it being misleading: The human behind the AI did insist that they had absolutely no part in creating the image, and the decision is taking that at face value. No human creator - no copyright. Since it's purely based on their input, it also doesn't look at questions like "was the AI created using input material that's copyrighted and might that have relevance" It has zero applicability on "AI art"/code/text/... created by a human using an "AI" as a tool to do so. But somehow this gets paraded around every few months as being some important decision...
- ckocagil 4y agoThat brings the question: in order for a work to be copyrighted, does a human need to put "some" effort into generating that work (prompt engineering, tweaking knobs, etc.) or does it suffice to click a "generate" button?
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoClicking the shutter on the camera grants you copyright. As things stand, clicking a button is enough
- ape4 4y agoOf course, there is more to that than taking a photo. You have to be at the location. Aim at the subject. Possibly select other settings.
- molotovh 4y agoThere is more to taking a photo, yes, but not to claiming a copyright, at least not in the US. "Generally, the author and initial copyright owner of a photograph is the person who 'shoots' or 'takes' the photo." https://www.copyright.gov/engage/photographers/ https://www.copyright.gov/engage/photographers/ Let's say a photographer sets up his camera, aims it, composes it, focuses it, etc. But he decides the light isn't quite right yet, so he goes for lunch. While he is away, his assistant clicks the shutter on a whim, capturing more or less the exact image what the photographer intended to capture. The resulting photograph's copyright belongs to the assistant, not the photographer. This is in theory, of course. In practice, this would be difficult to prove, since the picture is likely to be on a roll of many other pictures for which the photographer does own the copyright. The assistant would need some definitive evidence that they clicked the shutter on that exact frame if they wanted credit for their work.
- dzdt 4y agoWow this is a seriously important ruling. The law moves slow but technology is moving fast. AI generated art is a curiousity now but will be the majority of all art produced (by at least some measures) in a few short years. This makes a precedent that could dramatically shift the balance of power between corporate creators of commercial works and the general public.
- weinzierl 4y agoJust a few says ago there was a thread where artists recreated Disney art with A.I. I simply cannot imagine a world, where this stance will stand. Sooner or later we will see a massive crackdown by the large copyright holders.
- awb 4y agoWhat if a marketing team generates 100 candidate characters with AI for the next feature film, selects the best one and then writes an incredibly detailed brief for a human artist to reverse engineer the character. Could you then copyright the human generated art?
- jl6 4y agoA key litmus test: can an AI produce output that can substitute for a copyrighted work, to the extent that the commercial value of that copyrighted work is diminished? e.g. if a future hypothetical DALL-E-for-video can diffuse a mkv file containing something that plays very much like Star Wars, then surely possessing the model would be treated as possessing a copy of the movie.
- bbig 4y agoCurious how such a crackdown would even be enforced. Stable Diffusion is allowing artists to opt-out, so I guess that's a start?
- jacquesm 4y agoThe whole idea that the copyright holder needs to opt-out is seriously broken. Copyright is not 'opt-out'. Stable diffusion has set themselves up for trouble, this should have been opt-in.
- kolinko 4y agoThe current copyright is quite clear on this already, imho. Tools don't matter, what matters is how similar the output is to the original.
- willcipriano 4y agoUnsurprising, it has been ruled previously that a human must be involved to obtain a copyright[0]. [0]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monkey_selfie_copyright_dispute https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monkey_selfie_copyright_disp...
- xt00 4y agoWhile AI definitely will be used to help artists, nobody would be happy with somebody being the first to brute force run through tons of prompts on stable diffusion and submitting copyrights on all of those.. imagine if Getty did that..
- dsr_ 4y agoHeadline rewrite suggestion: US Copyright Office Rules A.I. Can't Be Owner of Copyright This should not be controversial until we have general AIs that are people.
- jacquesm 4y agoAgreed, but see HN's requirement for original headlines. Frustrating.
- xwdv 4y agoImagine a program where you draw something, and then use an AI to “touch up” parts of it and enhance the image. You’ve blown your copyright.
- detaro 4y agono, you really haven't
- nickthegreek 4y agoi.e. photoshop
- merricksb 4y agoThis case was discussed heavily here at the time in March (different article, same topic): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30702117 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30702117 (328 points | 9 months ago | 166 comments)
- jacquesm 4y agoIndeed it was, I missed it. But given the recent developments in AI driven art generation (and other creatives) I think it is getting to be more and more relevant.
- yalogin 4y agoCan that be extrapolated that any and all AI output cannot be copyrighted?
- systoll 4y agoThe precedent is purely that the AI itself won’t be awarded the copyright. The claimant here explicitly denied being involved in authoring the piece, and the copyright office took that at face value. Anyone who actually wanted copyright would claim to be the author.
- WheelsAtLarge 4y agoBut this does not mean that derivative works can't be copyrighted. So as long as there has been human input and it can be proved then it's copyright able. Also, the courts still have to decide how to deal with the data that went into the AI. We are a long way from figuring out copyright law for AI's.
- jacquesm 4y ago> Also, the courts still have to decide how to deal with the data that went into the AI. That's the big one. Another commenter mentions that Stable Diffusion is 'opt-out', I think that was a huge mistake on their part.